First Sino-Japanese War
The First Sino-Japanese War was fought between Qing China and Japan in 1894–1895, chiefly over Korea. Fighting broke out in Korea in July 1894 and both countries declared war on August 1; Chinese forces were defeated on land and at sea, Japanese armies invaded north-eastern China and the Shandong Peninsula, and the Beiyang Fleet was destroyed at Weihaiwei. The Treaty of Shimonoseki of April 1895 obliged China to recognize the independence of Korea, cede the Liaodong Peninsula, Taiwan and the Pescadores and pay a large indemnity; the Liaodong Peninsula was returned to China after the Triple Intervention, and resistance in Taiwan continued until November 1895.
Contents45 sections
Key facts
1875–1882The Opening of Korea and the Imo Incident
From the mid-19th century Korea under the Joseon dynasty also faced Western demands to open its ports; it valued its tributary relationship with Qing China, which it acknowledged as suzerain. On September 20, 1875, the Japanese gunboat Un’yō exchanged fire with Korean forces near Ganghwa Island, and on February 27, 1876, Korea and Japan concluded the Japan–Korea Treaty of Amity (also called the Treaty of Ganghwa); Korea then opened its ports through a series of unequal treaties with Western powers, ending its policy of seclusion.[1][2]
The Korean court was divided between a progressive faction (the Enlightenment or Independence Party) and a conservative faction (the Serve-the-Great Party) that relied on Qing protection. On July 23, 1882, the Imo Incident broke out in Hanseong (now Seoul): the Japanese legation was attacked, members of its staff were killed and Minister Hanabusa Yoshimoto fled, and power passed for a time to the Heungseon Daewongun, father of King Gojong and leader of the conservatives. Japan sent troops to call the Korean government to account and protect its residents; China held the Daewongun responsible and placed him under house arrest. The Treaty of Chemulpo of August 30, 1882, forced Korea to allow Japanese troops to be stationed in the country, so that the armies of both Japan and China were garrisoned in the capital, straining relations between them. With the Daewongun confined in China, Queen Min resumed power and relied more heavily on China.[1]
In 1882 Yuan ShikaiYuan ShikaiYuan Shikai (1859–1916) was a Chinese army leader and reformist minister of the late Qing dynasty and the first president of the Republic of China, from 1912 to 1916. The modern army he trained at Xiaozhan, Tianjin, grew into the Beiyang Army; in 1915–1916 he proclaimed a monarchy with himself as emperor, cancelled it in March 1916 and died on June 6 of that year.Open the full entry was sent to Korea on the orders of the Qing government; in 1885 he was appointed the Qing government’s trade representative in Korea.[3]
December 4, 1884The Gapsin Coup
Reformists of the Enlightenment Party led by Kim Ok-gyun, expecting Japanese support, staged a coup in Hanseong with King Gojong’s approval, seized power and killed leading figures of the Min clan. Chinese troops attacked the new government and suppressed the coup; fighting broke out between Japanese troops in the palace and the attacking Chinese forces, and many Japanese non-combatants were among the victims.[1][2]
April 18, 1885The Tientsin Convention
Itō Hirobumi for Japan and Li HongzhangLi HongzhangLi Hongzhang (1823–1901) was a Chinese statesman, military commander and diplomat of the late Qing dynasty, the founder and commander of the Huai Army and one of the principal promoters of the Self-Strengthening Movement. From 1870 he served for many years as governor-general of Zhili and superintendent of trade for the northern ports, sponsored modern enterprises such as the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company, the Kaiping mines, railways, telegraphs and the Beiyang Fleet, and signed treaties including the Treaty of Shimonoseki and the Boxer Protocol for the Qing government; judgments of him, in his lifetime and since, have been sharply divided.Open the full entry for China negotiated in Tianjin and signed the Tientsin Convention: both countries would withdraw their troops from Korea, neither would send military advisers there, Korea instead inviting advisers from a third country, and either side sending forces to Korea in future would notify the other in advance. The threat of war was averted, but the Korean court still could not control the political unrest in the country.[2][1]
After the Gapsin Coup the Min government began national reforms under Chinese direction; King Gojong sought relations with other countries as an independent state, planned a rapprochement with Russia and sent envoys to Europe and North America, while China restored the Daewongun and kept strict control over Korean diplomacy. In the early 1890s Korea’s finances gradually deteriorated, and tax increases, official corruption and Japanese merchants cornering the grain market impoverished the peasants.[1]
June 1, 1891The Board of Revenue Proposes a Two-Year Halt on Foreign Ships and Guns
In a memorial dated the 25th day of the 4th month of Guangxu 17, the Board of Revenue proposed that “all foreign machinery, ships and guns” no longer be purchased for two years. It has been argued that the decision had some bearing on the defeat of 1894–1895: it made no real difference to Zhang ZhidongZhang ZhidongZhang Zhidong (1837–1909) was an official, scholar and educator of the late Qing dynasty and one of the leading figures of the Self-Strengthening movement. He served as governor of Shanxi and as governor-general of Guangdong and Guangxi and of Hubei and Hunan, founded iron and steel, arms and textile enterprises and modern schools in Hubei, wrote the Quanxue pian (Exhortation to Learning) in 1898, and in his last years was a grand councillor and grand secretary in Beijing.Open the full entry but was close to fatal for the Beiyang Fleet.[4]
March–June 1894: The Donghak Peasant Uprising
In the spring popular uprisings broke out across Korea, partly out of discontent with local officials. The armed rebellion began among the peasants of Gobu in Jeolla Province in March and spread throughout the country. Its leaders and many participants were believers in Donghak (Eastern Learning), the rebel army was called the Donghak Party, and its aims were to expel the Japanese and overthrow the regime of Queen Min and her clan. After destroying the army the government sent against it, the rebel army marched north and at the end of May occupied Jeonju, the capital of Jeolla Province.[1][2]
The Korean government debated whether to ask China to send an army; concern over Chinese troops strengthened the Japanese government’s view that Japan should also send one. After almost a decade in which the two countries had watched each other’s actions in Korea since the Tientsin Convention, tension between them suddenly escalated.[1]
June 2–12, 1894China and Japan Send Troops to Korea
The Japanese cabinet decided on June 2 to send troops to Korea to protect the legation and Japanese residents, and notified China under the Tientsin Convention. On June 3 the Korean government, concluding that it could hardly suppress the rebellion alone, asked China for troops, and Li Hongzhang, Minister of Beiyang Commerce and Viceroy of Zhili, began preparing to send them. Two Chinese warships reached Incheon on June 5, and a force of about 2,000 landed between June 8 and 12 and set up a garrison at Asan; another account has the Qing government send 2,500 men under Ye Zhichao, provincial commander-in-chief of Zhili, and Nie Shicheng, brigade general of Taiyuan, to land at Asan.[5][6]
On June 5 Japan set up an Imperial General Headquarters within the General Staff Office and moved to a war footing; on June 7 the two countries notified each other of their deployments under the Tientsin Convention. On June 10 Ōtori Keisuke, the Japanese minister to Korea, entered Hanseong with about 400 soldiers and sailors, and on June 12 a Mixed Brigade 8,000 strong, capable of fighting independently, began landing at Incheon. With both Japanese and Chinese armies in Korea, the situation resembled that of the Gapsin Coup of 1884.[5][7]
June 11–July 22, 1894: Talks on Withdrawal Break Down
With the signing of the Treaty of Jeonju between the Korean government and the Peasant Army the rebellion ended, and the Korean government asked both sides to withdraw. Japan proposed that the two countries reform Korea jointly, both keeping their forces in Korea in the meantime, and said it would act alone otherwise; China replied on June 22 that the rebellion was over, that troops should be withdrawn at once and that reform was Korea’s own affair. Japan refused to withdraw, moved part of its 4,000-strong advance force from Incheon toward Hanseong and resumed transporting troops; Foreign Minister Mutsu Munemitsu later called his reply of the following day, refusing withdrawal, the “first letter of severance of diplomatic ties.”[5]
Japan asked Korea to let it pursue reform alone and to say whether Korea was a tributary of China; in a reply of June 30 Foreign Minister Jo Byeong-jik stated that Korea was an independent, sovereign state. The same day Russia demanded the simultaneous withdrawal of Japanese and Chinese forces, which Japan refused, and Britain, worried about Russian advances in East Asia, offered to mediate. On July 9, at a meeting between the Japanese chargé d’affaires Komura Jutarō and Prince Qing (Yikuang), China rejected Japan’s demand for equal rights but insisted on simultaneous withdrawal; Japan sent a letter of protest on July 14 (Mutsu’s “second letter of severance”) and resumed military preparations, and China came to see war as unavoidable.[5]
On July 3 Japan submitted a reform proposal to Korea; Korea, influenced by the faction of Queen Min’s family, made Japanese withdrawal a precondition for reform and set up a Board of Review and Rectification (Gyojeongcheong), which Japan regarded as an empty gesture. On July 19 Ōtori demanded that Korea build a military telegraph line between Hanseong and Busan and barracks for Japanese troops, and on July 20 he added demands for the withdrawal of Chinese forces and the cancellation of the China–Korea treaty of 1882 and other agreements, with a deadline of July 22. Korea’s midnight reply on that day repeated its plan for its own reforms and demanded the withdrawal of both armies, and Japan decided to overthrow the Korean regime by force and install the Heungseon Daewongun.[5]
July 23, 1894Japanese Troops Occupy the Korean Royal Palace
Before dawn the Mixed Brigade under Major General Ōshima Yoshimasa, stationed at Yongsan on the outskirts of Hanseong, entered the capital; just after 4:30 a.m. the troops surrounded Gyeongbokgung, King Gojong’s palace, broke through the gates and exchanged fire with the Korean guards. After several hours of fighting Japan occupied the palace and took control of the king, and the Heungseon Daewongun was brought to the palace under Japanese guard. That evening King Gojong, in Ōtori’s presence, entrusted the Daewongun with government and reform, to be carried out in consultation with Ōtori.[5]
Japan then took a Korean request to expel the Chinese forces at Asan as its justification and made Asan its first target; this marked the start of war between the two countries.[5]
July 25, 1894The Battle of Pungdo and the Sinking of the Kowshing
On July 19 the Japanese navy formed a Combined Fleet from the Standing Fleet and the newly formed Western Fleet under Itō Sukeyuki and sent it from Sasebo to the west coast of Korea, with orders to control the seas there. On July 25 the British-registered merchant ship Kowshing, carrying Chinese reinforcements for Asan, together with two escorting warships and another Chinese warship coming from Asan, met part of the Japanese Combined Fleet near Pungdo Island; both sides opened fire in the first naval clash of the war, and the Chinese vessels were sunk, wrecked, surrendered or escaped.[5]
Returning from Asan, the Jiyuan and the Guangyi were attacked off Pungdo by the Yoshino and two other Japanese warships. Shen Shouchang, first officer of the Jiyuan and a former student of the Chinese Educational MissionChinese Educational MissionThe Chinese Educational Mission was the Qing government programme and office that sent boys to study in the United States from 1872 to 1881. Proposed by Yung Wing and approved on the memorials of Zeng Guofan and Li Hongzhang, with Chen Lanbin and Yung Wing as commissioners, it sent 120 boys in four detachments between 1872 and 1875 to live and study in New England, with headquarters in Hartford, Connecticut, until the whole mission was recalled in 1881; among its students were Zhan Tianyou, Tang Shaoyi, Liang Dunyan, Liang Cheng and Tang Guoan, who later became known in railways, diplomacy and education.Open the full entry, climbed to the lookout platform to direct the return fire and was killed by a shell fragment to the head at the age of 32, the first senior officer of the Beiyang Fleet to die in the war. By one account the captain, Fang Boqian, had taken refuge in his cabin, and Shen and the second officer Ke Jianzhang agreed that Shen would direct the fighting from the platform while Ke supervised the forward guns.[8][9]
The Kowshing was sunk by the cruiser Naniwa, commanded by Tōgō Heihachirō. Her British crew were rescued by a Japanese warship. The sinking of a merchant ship before any declaration of war provoked a strong reaction in Britain; several leading jurists argued in The Times that international law did not require a declaration of war before hostilities began and that the Japanese fleet’s action was lawful.[10][5]
Accounts of how many were on board and how many died differ. Denby, the American chargé d’affaires in Peking, wrote to the Secretary of State on July 28 that the Zongli Yamen had received a telegram from Korea on July 27 saying that the Kowshing, “having on board 1,500 Chinese troops,” had been sunk by Japanese warships, “only 11 lives being saved”; he added that the ship belonged to the Indo China Steam Navigation Company and flew the British flag, that the Chinese government had chartered her around July 16 through the agents Jardine, Matheson & Co., and that under the charter she was to sail under the British flag while it was safe to do so and, on a formal declaration of war, run into the nearest Chinese port and hoist the Chinese flag. Another account puts the main body on board at about 1,000, more than 700 of them men of the Huai Army, mostly from two battalions under Wu Yuren, with many of the dead coming from Liujiafan in Feidong; on that account the uncle and grandfather of Wu Bangguo were among them. Yet another puts the Chinese officers and men killed at more than 800.[11][12][13]
The Japanese cabinet decided on August 25 that the actual starting date of the war should be determined, and on September 10 it fixed the start as July 25, the day of the Battle of Pungdo, rather than August 1.[5]
July 29, 1894The Battle of Seonghwan
Ōshima Yoshimasa’s Mixed Brigade, which had landed at Incheon from mid-June and kept some units in Hanseong to guard the legation and the palace, began moving south toward Asan on July 25. On the Chinese side, Ye Zhichao’s units were at Asan and Nie Shicheng’s forces had moved from Jeonju to Seonghwan. The Japanese advancing on Asan reached Seonghwan on July 29, and the first land battle of the war was fought.[5]
August 1, 1894Declarations of War
After the battles of Pungdo and Seonghwan, Emperor Meiji issued an Imperial Rescript declaring war on China; on the same day the Guangxu EmperorGuangxu EmperorThe Guangxu Emperor (1871–1908), personal name Zaitian, was emperor of the Qing dynasty from 1875 to 1908. A son of Yixuan, Prince Chun, and of a sister of the Empress Dowager Cixi, he was chosen by Cixi to succeed the Tongzhi Emperor. In 1898 he launched the Hundred Days’ Reform, which ended when Cixi staged a coup; he spent the rest of his life confined on Yingtai in Zhongnanhai and died in 1908. A report published in 2008 concluded that he had died of arsenic poisoning.Open the full entry declared war on Japan; he was a firm advocate of war and pressed Li Hongzhang to send troops. Only China was named in the Japanese declaration, not Korea. On August 26 Japan and Korea signed the Japanese-Korean Alliance, under which Japan would conduct the war against China and Korea would help, including by supplying food, supplies and manpower.[5][15]
Denby telegraphed the Secretary of State that day: “War is declared”; he added that the Japanese chargé d’affaires had left Peking that day, that the interests of Japanese subjects had been placed in the charge of the American legation, and that an outbreak was feared at Tianjin. In his dispatch of July 27 he had written that the emperor had “nominated two commissioners to investigate and report upon the Viceroy Li’s conduct of the Korean business”: Weng TongheWeng TongheWeng Tonghe (1830–1904) was an official, calligrapher and diarist of the late Qing dynasty, tutor to two emperors, Tongzhi and Guangxu, and at various times president of the Board of Revenue, Grand Councillor and Associate Grand Secretary. He was dismissed soon after the Hundred Days’ Reform began in 1898 and stripped of his ranks after the coup that ended it; the diary he kept for nearly half a century is counted among the four great diaries of the late Qing.Open the full entry, president of the Board of Revenue, and Li Hongzao, president of the Board of Rites.[16][17]
August–October 1894: The Empress Dowager’s Sixtieth Birthday and War Funds
Empress Dowager CixiEmpress Dowager CixiEmpress Dowager Cixi (1835–1908), of the Yehe Nara clan, was a consort of the Xianfeng Emperor and the mother of the Tongzhi Emperor. From the coup of 1861 until her death in 1908 she ruled as co-regent with Ci’an, as sole regent and as instructing regent for two emperors, the Tongzhi Emperor and the Guangxu Emperor, and was the de facto ruler of China for nearly half a century of the late Qing.Open the full entry’s sixtieth birthday fell on the tenth day of the tenth lunar month of 1894; the court had appointed officials to prepare the celebrations as early as 1892 and set up a celebrations office in 1893. During the war the Empress Dowager ordered 3,000,000 taels from the privy purse to be allotted to military expenses and called off the reception of congratulations at the Summer Palace, but on September 25 cartloads of birthday tributes from princes, ministers and provincial officials were still brought into the palace, and from October 1 officials at court and in the provinces celebrated her birthday with great ceremony; it has been argued that cancelling the Summer Palace ceremonies was only a gesture to placate opinion.[13]
Weng Tonghe recorded in his diary that during the celebrations of the Empress Dowager’s sixtieth birthday in the tenth lunar month of 1894 he and his colleagues, because of the war, asked for some of the festivities to be stopped and expenses to be cut, which earned her resentment; by one account she said that whoever made her unhappy that day she would make unhappy for the rest of their life.[18]
September 13–15, 1894Imperial General Headquarters Moves to Hiroshima
Japan’s Imperial General Headquarters, set up in the General Staff Office in June, moved into the Imperial Palace on August 5 and to Hiroshima Castle on September 13, and Emperor Meiji arrived there on September 15. Hiroshima’s port was at Ujina, and the city became Japan’s temporary capital during the war. In mid-August Japan had already adopted the policy of driving the Chinese forces out of Korea or attacking China directly.[14]
September 15, 1894The Battle of Pyongyang
On September 1 Japan formed the 1st Army from the 5th Division and the newly dispatched 3rd Division, under General Yamagata Aritomo. Lacking command of the Yellow Sea, Japan landed its reinforcements at Wonsan or Busan; the main body of the 5th Division reached the Hanseong area at the end of August and set out for Pyongyang on September 1, joining the 9th Mixed Brigade and the Sangnyeong and Wonsan detachments.[14]
Before dawn the Japanese surrounded Pyongyang and launched an all-out attack. The Chinese garrison numbered 13,000 by Japanese military estimates; another account gives about 15,000 Chinese and about 16,000 Japanese. It was the first large-scale land battle of the war. The Chinese defence was strong and the fighting fierce; towards evening the Chinese units facing the Sangnyeong and Wonsan detachments stopped attacking and raised the white flag, the Chinese evacuated the city that night during a heavy thunderstorm, and the Japanese entered at dawn the next day. In Pyongyang the Japanese captured letters exchanged between the Chinese commanders Ma Yukun and Zuo Baogui and their overall commander, Ye Zhichao.[14][19][6]
September 17, 1894The Battle of the Yellow Sea
The Yellow Sea and Bohai Sea were controlled by China’s Beiyang Fleet, based at Port Arthur and Weihaiwei and commanded by Admiral Ding Ruchang; its main ships were the flagship Dingyuan and the Zhenyuan, and the Chinese had improved their ships after the Battle of Pungdo. Itō Sukeyuki, commander of the Japanese Combined Fleet, lacked information on the Beiyang Fleet’s location. Returning from escorting reinforcements for Pyongyang, the Beiyang Fleet was off Dagushan, west of the mouth of the Yalu River, when it met the Japanese Combined Fleet heading for an anchorage at Dalu Island off Dagushan, and the two fleets engaged. The battle is also called the Battle of the Yalu River or the Battle of Dagushan.[14]
The Beiyang Fleet had only ten ships that day; by another account each side had twelve ships in the clash. At 11:50 a.m. the flagship Dingyuan, under her captain Liu Buchan, fired the first shot; Ding Ruchang was critically injured, and the two sides exchanged fire for more than five hours. It has been pointed out that the Japanese Combined Fleet formed its twelve ships into two single columns by speed, exploiting their mobility and broadside fire, while the Beiyang Fleet kept to the ramming tactics of the age of sail and a less manoeuvrable line-abreast formation and was put on the defensive.[6][10][20][21]
To relieve the burning Dingyuan, Deng Shichang, captain of the cruiser Zhiyuan, ordered his ship to charge the enemy; running out of ammunition, the Zhiyuan tried to ram the Japanese cruiser Yoshino but was sunk by a torpedo first. Deng refused rescue and died with more than 200 officers and men of his ship, and his dog died with him; the Guangxu Emperor wrote a tribute to his courage. Lin Yongsheng, captain of the Jingyuan, was killed in action, and Huang Jianxun of the Chaoyong and Lin Lüzhong of the Yangwei also refused rescue after their ships went down.[10][9]
Accounts of the Chinese losses differ: by one count four Beiyang ships were sunk; by another five were lost, the Zhiyuan, Jingyuan, Chaoyong and Yangwei and the Guangjia, which ran aground while fleeing and was destroyed, and the Laiyuan was heavily damaged. More than 600 Chinese officers and men were killed, or, by another count, killed or wounded. On the Japanese side four ships were damaged, the flagship Matsushima and the Hiei, Akagi and Saikyō Maru, and the Akagi’s captain, Sakamoto Hachirōta, was killed; Japanese dead numbered 121, or, by another count, more than 300 were killed or wounded. The Dingyuan and Zhenyuan caught fire and returned to Port Arthur after the battle (by another account they retreated to Weihaiwei), and Chinese naval strength in the Yellow Sea was greatly reduced.[14][6][10][9]
Fang Boqian, captain of the Jiyuan, took his ship out of the battle early; Li Hongzhang memorialized that Fang fled as soon as the Zhiyuan had sunk. Fang was arrested and was beheaded at the foot of Huangjin Hill in Port Arthur on September 24, aged 42; it has been argued that the facts of the case were clear and the sentence appropriate, and that it was not a miscarriage of justice.[9]
Thereafter, on Li Hongzhang’s order to avoid battle and preserve the ships, the Beiyang Fleet withdrew to Weihaiwei and no longer put to sea to fight, although the surviving ships were still battleworthy.[10]
October–November 1894: The Second Donghak Rising and the Battle of Gongju
The rebellion had ended with the Treaty of Jeonju, but after the Japan–Korea alliance and the establishment of the Heungseon Daewongun’s regime the Donghak army denounced the government and rose again, attacking Korean government forces and the Japanese army in Korea from October. Japanese reinforcements fought alongside Korean government troops; on November 28 and 29 a peasant army “tens of thousands strong” attacked Gongju in Chungcheong Province and was repulsed by about 1,000 Japanese and Korean troops. The Peasant Army suffered heavy losses and was practically wiped out; sporadic clashes continued into the following year, and the rebel leaders were captured one by one.[14]
October 24–November 11, 1894: The Japanese Cross the Yalu
With Pyongyang lost and the Beiyang Fleet withdrawn to Weihaiwei, Japan launched a two-pronged attack: the 1st Army would cross the Yalu River and advance on Beijing, and the newly formed 2nd Army would land on the Liaodong and Shandong peninsulas and attack Port Arthur and Weihaiwei. The rest of the 3rd Division landed at Incheon in mid-September and reached Pyongyang at the end of the month; the Chinese garrisons on the way, at Jongju and Anju, withdrew without fighting, while food, porters and packhorses were problems for the Japanese.[14]
The 1st Army built temporary bridges at two points on the Yalu on October 24 and began crossing; Chinese units from Jiuliancheng and troops retreating from Pyongyang, based at Hushan, attacked them and there was fierce fighting. At dawn on October 26 the Japanese surrounded Jiuliancheng, whose defenders had withdrawn before the attack began. The 5th Division marched west and took Fenghuangcheng on October 29; the 3rd Division moved south along the Yalu, captured Dadonggou, pursued the Chinese to Dagushan and took it unopposed on November 5, after which Dagushan’s port became a supply base. Japan set up a Civil Administration Bureau for Andong County, which included Dagushan, with Komura Jutarō, formerly chargé d’affaires in China, as its first director. On November 11 the 5th Division captured Lianshanguan; Chinese forces then attacked the Japanese units at the nearby Motian Pass, and the Japanese withdrew from Lianshanguan to Caohekou.[14]
October 24–November 7, 1894: The Japanese 2nd Army Lands on the Liaodong Peninsula
On September 25 Japan formed the 2nd Army from the 1st and 2nd Divisions and the 12th Mixed Brigade, under Army Minister Ōyama Iwao. The Combined Fleet proposed landing at Huayuankou, halfway between Dagushan and Jinzhou, which Ōyama at first opposed as too far from the target; the 2nd Army landed there between October 24 and 27, and the 12th Mixed Brigade landed at Huayuankou on November 7. The 1st Division marched west and attacked Jinzhou on November 6, whose garrison withdrew early in the attack, and on November 7 captured the battery at Dalian Bay, after which, with the 12th Mixed Brigade, it prepared to attack Port Arthur and landed its heavy artillery at Dalian Bay. After the fall of Jinzhou, Li Hongzhang concluded that China must make peace.[14][22]
November 14, 1894The Zhenyuan Runs Aground
Early that morning the Zhenyuan, returning to Weihaiwei from a cruise in the Bohai Sea, met a falling tide and struck a reef; several cracks were torn in her bottom plates, water poured in and she was put out of action. Her captain, Lin Taizeng, blaming himself for the damage, took his own life.[6][9]
November 18–21, 1894The Fall of Port Arthur
Port Arthur (Lüshun, now Lüshunkou District of Dalian, Liaoning) was the base of the Beiyang Fleet, and troops retreating from Jinzhou increased its garrison; a telegram of November 19 from Major General Fukubara Toyonori to Lieutenant General Kawakami Sōroku estimated the Chinese troops there at about 12,000, of whom 3,000 to 4,000 were trained. Hostilities began on November 18; before dawn on November 21 the Japanese launched an all-out attack, captured the batteries, and Port Arthur fell.[14]
From November 21, 1894The Port Arthur Massacre
By one account, after capturing Port Arthur the Japanese carried out a massacre there that lasted four days and three nights, and only 36 people survived, because they were ordered to bury the bodies of their compatriots; on this account the Wanzhongmu (Tomb of Ten Thousand Loyal Souls) at Lüshun holds more than 20,000 people of Lüshun killed by Japanese troops during the war, and in 1896 the Qing government built the tomb and erected a stele for the victims.[23]
James Creelman of the New York World telegraphed an account of the massacre from Yokohama on December 11, and Foreign Minister Mutsu Munemitsu, who obtained a copy, sent it to Edwin Dun, the American minister to Japan. In his report of December 20 to the Secretary of State, Dun wrote that Mutsu, back in Tokyo on December 15, said that a searching investigation had been ordered and frankly acknowledged that the Japanese government and people “recognized and deplored the fact that a much greater number of Chinese soldiers had been killed at Port Arthur than was necessary”; Mutsu explained that the Japanese troops had been enraged by Chinese atrocities against captured comrades, that most residents had fled days earlier, and that civilians had died because Chinese soldiers had changed into civilian clothes, and he called Creelman’s telegram “a gross exaggeration of the truth.” Dun judged that the killing of Chinese soldiers could not be justified under the accepted rules of war but that Creelman’s account was sensational. Mutsu’s written statement of December 19 said that “about 355 Chinese prisoners who were taken at the fall of Port Arthur have been kindly treated” and were being sent to Tokyo.[24]
November 26, 1894Gustav Detring’s Mission to Kobe
Li Hongzhang sent Gustav Detring, a German Commissioner of Customs at Tianjin, as his envoy to Kobe with a letter to Prime Minister Itō Hirobumi; the Japanese refused to recognize him because he lacked proper accreditation, and he left Japan on November 29.[22]
December 13, 1894–March 1895Haicheng and the Lower Liao
From November severe cold and deep snow hit the area from the Liaodong Peninsula to Fengtian Prefecture, food supply remained a problem, and Japan considered a winter halt and winter quarters. The 5th Division garrisoned Jiuliancheng and Fenghuangcheng and saw no fighting after a Chinese counter-attack in mid-December; the 3rd Division took Haicheng, a Chinese base in Fengtian Prefecture, on December 13, and Chinese forces made repeated attempts to retake it, fighting continuing until the end of February.[14]
After the destruction of the Beiyang Fleet the Japanese 1st Army advanced into the Liaodong Peninsula; the 3rd Division, defending Haicheng, joined the 5th Division in attacking Niuzhuang through deep snowdrifts on March 4, and Japan went on to capture Yingkou and other places, and the Chinese counter-attack lost momentum.[22]
January 15–March 5, 1895: Yung Wing’s Proposal to Zhang Zhidong for a Loan to Buy Warships
Yang Ru, the Chinese minister to the United StatesUnited StatesThe United States is a federal country in North America made up of 50 states, the District of Columbia as the seat of government, and territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam; its capital is Washington, D.C. The Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776. The 2020 census (April 1, 2020) counted a resident population of 331,449,281, and the 435 seats of the House of Representatives are apportioned among the states on the basis of the census.Open the full entry, telegraphed on Yung WingYung WingYung Wing (1828–1912) was a Chinese educator and diplomat of the late Qing period who graduated from Yale University in 1854 and is described as the first Chinese student to graduate from an American university. He proposed and led the Chinese Educational Mission, which brought 120 Chinese boys to study in the United States from 1872 to 1881, served as the Qing associate minister to the United States, Spain and Peru, and wrote the memoir My Life in China and America (1909).Open the full entry’s behalf to Zhang Zhidong, then acting Viceroy of Liangjiang in Nanjing, that a gunboat with heavy guns could be bought from Brazil for £218,000 in all, and that if the whole province of Taiwan were pledged as security a loan of £200,000,000, or a billion American dollars, could be raised. On February 12 Zhang telegraphed Yang Ru, asking him to tell Yung Wing that the gunboat, guns and the rest could all be ordered and asked for a price quickly, but did not answer on the pledge of Taiwan; on March 5 he telegraphed Yung Wing that the loan had been arranged and ships and guns could be bought, but the deal came to nothing.[25]
January 20–February 17, 1895: Weihaiwei and the Destruction of the Beiyang Fleet
After the fall of Port Arthur, Japan’s Imperial General Headquarters postponed winter quarters, kept up the pressure toward Beijing and attacked Weihaiwei (now Weihai, Shandong), the Beiyang Fleet’s other base. On January 20 the Japanese 2nd Army and the Combined Fleet landed at Rongcheng Bay on the tip of the Shandong Peninsula in a combined sea and land attack. Ōyama Iwao sent a message through the British urging Ding Ruchang to surrender, which Ding refused. The Japanese attacked the Chinese batteries on January 30 and on February 2 occupied all the batteries along the Weihaiwei coast (by another account Weihaiwei fell on February 3), cutting off Liugong Island, the seat of the Beiyang Fleet’s command.[22][10]
On February 6 the Weiyuan was sunk by a Japanese torpedo, and on February 7 the Japanese began an all-out assault. The flagship Dingyuan, hit in a surprise attack by Japanese torpedo boats, ran aground off the east village of Liugong Island; her captain, Liu Buchan, ordered her blown up to keep her out of enemy hands and then took his own life. By one account the Dingyuan was hit by a Japanese torpedo on February 10 and put out of action.[10][26][22]
With no hope of relief, Ding Ruchang took his own life with opium on February 11, aged 59; the same evening Zhang Wenxuan, commander of the guard troops, also killed himself, and Yang Yonglin, the Zhenyuan’s new captain, shot himself with a rifle. On February 12 a Chinese gunboat flying a white flag delivered the surrender, offering to hand over the warships, batteries and weapons and asking for guarantees of safety for foreigners; Ding had already committed suicide, and a telegram of February 13 from Captain Kuroi Teijirō announced the suicides of Ding Ruchang and Liu Buchan. The terms were signed on February 17, the whole Combined Fleet entered Weihaiwei harbour and Japanese forces occupied Weihaiwei; the Kangji was handed back to carry Ding’s coffin.[6][9][22]
The Beiyang Fleet was destroyed. From the Battle of Pungdo on July 25, 1894, to the fall of Weihaiwei on February 17, 1895, the naval war lasted nearly seven months; the Beiyang Fleet lost all three of its battles, at Pungdo, in the Yellow Sea and at Weihaiwei, without sinking a single Japanese ship. It has been pointed out that more than half of the fleet’s senior commanders were killed in action or took their own lives, something very rare in the history of the world’s navies. After the war the surviving officers, including Ye Zugui, Qiu Baoren, Lin Guoxiang and Cheng Biguang, were sent back to their home districts to await the court’s decision, and the Beiyang naval posts were abolished altogether; Li YuanhongLi YuanhongLi Yuanhong (1864–1928) was a naval engineer officer and a commander of the Hubei New Army in the late Qing who became military governor of the Hubei Military Government after the Wuchang Uprising of 1911, served as vice president in the early Republic and was twice President of the Republic of China, in 1916–1917 and 1922–1923; in his last years he lived in Tianjin and invested in industry, and he died there in 1928 and was buried at Wuchang in 1935.Open the full entry, then a second engineer in the Beiyang navy, later left the navy and entered the service of Zhang Zhidong.[20][9]
January 31–February 1, 1895: Failed Peace Talks at Hiroshima
With American mediation coordinated by Edwin Dun and Charles Denby, Japan and China agreed in January to begin peace talks at the Imperial General Headquarters in Hiroshima, with Itō Hirobumi and Mutsu Munemitsu as Japan’s plenipotentiaries. The Chinese envoys Zhang Yinhuan and Shao Youlian arrived in Hiroshima on January 31; at the first session on February 1 Japan refused their credentials and broke off the talks, the envoys returned to China and the war continued.[22]
March 19–30, 1895The Shimonoseki Talks, the Attack on Li Hongzhang and the Armistice
After the fall of Weihaiwei the Qing court appointed Li Hongzhang Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary, with Li JingfangLi JingfangLi Jingfang (1854 or 1855–1934) was a Qing-dynasty diplomat, a son of Li Zhaoqing, the sixth younger brother of Li Hongzhang, who was adopted by Li Hongzhang as his eldest son. A former Chinese minister to Japan, he was one of the two Chinese plenipotentiaries at the 1895 peace talks with Japan and signed the Treaty of Shimonoseki together with Li Hongzhang; on June 2, 1895, off Keelung, he handed Taiwan over to Japan’s governor-general Kabayama Sukenori. He was later Chinese minister to Britain.Open the full entry, the former minister to Japan, as the other plenipotentiary. They arrived at Shimonoseki (then also called Akamagaseki, in Yamaguchi Prefecture) on the morning of March 19, and the conference opened at the Shunpanrō, a Japanese-style inn, on March 20 (by another account on March 21); it held seven sessions in all.[22][27][2][28]
At the first session China asked for an armistice; at the second, on March 21, Japan set as conditions the occupation of Dagu, Tianjin and the Shanhai Pass, Japanese operation of the Tianjin–Shanhai Pass railway and Chinese payment of Japan’s military expenses, which China refused; the third session on March 24 made no progress. That day Li Hongzhang was shot at by Koyama Toyotarō (also called Rokunosuke) and wounded in the face; he was 73. An unconditional armistice was signed on March 30, from which, at Japan’s wish, Taiwan and the Pescadores were excluded.[22][27]
Japan had at first demanded an indemnity of 300,000,000 taels; after the attack on Li, embarrassed and facing hostile international opinion, it reduced the figure to 200,000,000, and by one account Li considered that his blood had been shed to China’s benefit. Li recovered and resumed his seat at the fifth session on April 10; Japan’s draft treaty included the Liaodong Peninsula, Taiwan and the Pescadores, and Itō is said to have hurried to sign because he expected Western intervention.[27][22]
March 23–24, 1895Japan Seizes the Pescadores
Japan began preparations in mid-January and formed a Mixed Detachment on February 1; its main body left Ujina in Hiroshima on March 8, joined the rest of the force at Shimonoseki the next day, came under the command of Itō Sukeyuki at Sasebo and arrived off Penghu on March 20. On March 23, three days after the peace conference opened, the Combined Fleet shelled the coastal forts and troops landed on Penghu, the largest of the Pescadores, 50 km west of Taiwan; on the 24th they attacked Magong in the centre of the island under covering fire from the fleet, and late that night the Chinese surrendered.[29]
Cholera broke out among the Japanese troops during the fighting at Magong, and for lack of personnel and medicine many died every day; the disease began to abate in mid-April, by which time 1,700 men had been affected, of whom around 1,000 died.[29]
April 17, 1895The Treaty of Shimonoseki
China and Japan signed the Treaty of Shimonoseki, known in Japan as the Sino-Japanese Peace Treaty or the Shimonoseki Treaty. It was signed for Japan by Prime Minister Itō Hirobumi and Foreign Minister Mutsu Munemitsu and for China by Li Hongzhang and Li Jingfang, and had eleven articles.[28][30][27]
Article I: China recognized “the full and complete independence and autonomy of Corea,” and Korea’s tribute and ceremonies to China were to cease. Article II: China ceded to Japan in perpetuity, with their fortifications, arsenals and public property, the southern portion of Fengtian Province (bounded by a line through the Yalu, Anping, Fenghuang, Haicheng and Yingkou and by the middle course of the Liao River, together with the islands in the eastern part of Liaodong Bay and the northern Yellow Sea), the island of Taiwan with its islands, and the Pescadores (the islands between 119° and 120° east longitude and 23° and 24° north latitude). Article III: a joint commission of two or more delegates from each side was to delimit the frontiers within one year of its appointment.[30][28]
Article IV: China was to pay Japan a war indemnity of 200,000,000 Kuping taels in eight instalments, 50,000,000 within six months of the exchange of ratifications, 50,000,000 within twelve months and the rest in six annual instalments; unpaid amounts bore interest at 5 per cent a year, which would be waived if the whole sum were paid within three years.[28][31][30]
Article V: inhabitants of the ceded territories could sell their property and leave within two years, after which those remaining might, at Japan’s option, be deemed Japanese subjects, and the transfer of Taiwan was to be completed within two months of the exchange of ratifications. Article VI: China would appoint plenipotentiaries to conclude a treaty of commerce and navigation and a convention on frontier trade, granting Japan most-favoured-nation treatment in the meantime; it would open Shashi (Hubei), Chongqing (Sichuan), Suzhou (Jiangsu) and Hangzhou (Zhejiang) to Japanese trade and residence with Japanese consuls; Japanese steamers could navigate the upper Yangtze from Yichang to Chongqing and the Wusong River and the canal from Shanghai to Suzhou and Hangzhou; Japanese buying goods inland could rent warehouses free of taxes; and Japanese subjects could engage in manufacturing in all the open cities, towns and ports of China and import machinery on payment of the stipulated duties only.[30][28]
Article VII: Japanese armies were to leave Chinese territory within three months of the exchange of ratifications, subject to Article VIII. Article VIII: Japan would temporarily occupy Weihaiwei in Shandong as a guarantee, evacuating it once the first two instalments had been paid and the commercial treaty ratified, provided China pledged its customs revenue as security, and otherwise only when the indemnity had been paid in full. Article IX: prisoners of war were to be returned on the exchange of ratifications and not ill-treated, and China would release Japanese subjects held as alleged military spies and not punish Chinese who had been compromised in relations with the Japanese army. Article X: all offensive military operations were to cease from the exchange of ratifications. Article XI: ratifications were to be exchanged at Chefoo (Zhifu, now Yantai, Shandong).[30][28]
The Guangxu Emperor approved the treaty in vermilion on the 8th day of the 4th month (May 2), and the seal was affixed the next day; ratifications were exchanged at Chefoo on May 8. Japan promulgated the treaty in May; the original bearing the emperor’s signature, held by the National Archives of Japan, is dated the tenth day of the fifth month of Meiji 28.[32][22][28]
It has been argued that the indemnity exceeded the total of all reparations paid under the unequal treaties since the Opium War, and that by allowing foreign factories in the treaty ports the treaty turned foreign goods into foreign capital in China, made China an exporter of raw materials and a market for foreign goods and capital, and, with foreign control of manufacturing, mining and transport, hindered China’s industrial development.[27]
April–May 1895: Petitions by the Examination Candidates
Kang YouweiKang YouweiKang Youwei (1858–1927) was a Chinese scholar, political reformer and calligrapher of the late Qing and early Republican periods and a principal promoter of the Hundred Days’ Reform of 1898. After the reform was reversed he spent more than a decade in exile, founded the Baohuanghui (Chinese Empire Reform Association) and argued for constitutional monarchy; in later life he campaigned to make Confucianism the state religion. His works include The Forged Classics, Confucius as a Reformer and the Datong shu (The Great Commonwealth).Open the full entry later recalled that news of the treaty reached Beijing by telegraph on the 21st day of the 3rd month of Guangxu 21; provincial graduates in the capital for the metropolitan examination then submitted petition after petition against the treaty. One count finds that between the 27th day of the 2nd month and the 21st day of the 4th month there were 154 memorials submitted directly, transmitted by others or sent by telegraph, with more than 2,464 participations; graduates submitted 31 petitions of their own with 1,555 participations and joined seven petitions headed by officials with 135. Among the Guangdong graduates, for example, a petition of 80 headed by Liang QichaoLiang QichaoLiang Qichao (1873–1929) was a thinker, politician, journalist and scholar of the late Qing and early Republic, a disciple of Kang Youwei and a participant in the Hundred Days’ Reform of 1898. After the reform failed he spent 14 years in exile in Japan, where he ran the journals Qingyi Bao and Xinmin Congbao; returning in 1912, he helped to found the Progressive Party, served the Beijing government as minister of justice and minister of finance, and in 1915–1916 opposed Yuan Shikai’s attempt to make himself emperor. After leaving politics at the end of 1917 he devoted himself to writing and teaching, was a tutor at the Tsinghua Academy of Chinese Learning and director of the Beijing Library, and left the collected works known as the Yinbingshi heji.Open the full entry was transmitted by the Censorate on the 6th day of the 4th month and one of 289 headed by Chen Jinghua on the 7th; Cheng Weiqing led 121 graduates from Jiangxi, Ge Mingyuan 110 from Guizhou and Zou Daiyao 115 from Guangxi.[32]
Kang also wrote that he had gathered graduates from the provinces at the Songyun Hall for a joint petition with more than 1,200 participants, and that it was refused when taken to the Censorate on the 8th day of the 4th month (May 2); another account speaks of more than 1,300. This joint petition later became known as the Gongche shangshu (the Petition of the Examination Candidates). It has been established that the Censorate was still transmitting the graduates’ petitions that day and that the inter-provincial petition Kang organized was never delivered, so that there was no refusal; it has been argued that there are two different “Gongche shangshu”: the petitions launched from the top of the government, organized by officials in the capital and joined by graduates from the provinces, and the inter-provincial petition organized by Kang, which was an abortive political action with no effect on the politics of the time. On this view Kang’s account in his autobiography is wrong in many places and not very reliable, and the story was amplified and built up in layers into the version given in most history books today.[32]
April 23–November 1895: The Triple Intervention and the Return of Liaodong
Japan’s possession of the Liaodong Peninsula met strong international opposition. Russia, concerned about its interests in north-eastern China, persuaded France and Germany to join it, and on April 23 the German, Russian and French envoys handed notes to Vice Minister Hayashi Tadasu advising Japan to relinquish the peninsula: the Triple Intervention. On April 24 the Japanese government met in the emperor’s presence, considered an international conference or seeking British or American support, and finally accepted the three powers’ terms.[22][27]
On November 8 Li Hongzhang and Hayashi Tadasu signed in Beijing the Convention for the Retrocession of the Liaodong Peninsula: Japan returned the southern portion of Fengtian Province to China in perpetuity and Article III of the Treaty of Shimonoseki was suppressed; China was to pay Japan 30,000,000 Kuping taels in compensation on or before the 30th day of the 9th month of Guangxu 21 (November 16, 1895), Japanese troops would withdraw within three months of the payment, China would not punish Chinese subjects compromised by the Japanese occupation, and the convention was signed in Chinese, Japanese and English, the English text governing any dispute of interpretation. With this payment for Liaodong, China paid 230,000,000 taels in all; another figure given is 231,500,000.[30][22][31][27][6]
It has been argued that the Triple Intervention deepened the rivalry between Japan and Russia and laid the groundwork for the Russo-Japanese War of 1904–1905. Within four years the powers obtained leases in China: Germany at Jiaozhou in 1898, Russia at Port Arthur and Dalian in 1898, France at Guangzhou Bay in 1899 and Britain at Weihaiwei in 1898.[27][22]
May–November 1895: The Republic of Formosa and the Japanese Conquest of Taiwan
Taiwan was then part of Qing China, which had made it a province in 1885. Recognizing that Japan was likely to demand its cession, the governor, Tang Jingsong, had petitioned the government to refuse. After the Treaty of Shimonoseki, Japan on May 10 appointed Kabayama Sukenori, promoted from vice admiral to admiral, as the first Governor-General of Taiwan, with the Office of the Governor-General in Taipei. On May 23 Taiwan proclaimed itself an independent state, the Republic of Formosa, and on May 25 Tang Jingsong became its president; a new era name, Yongqing, and a flag were adopted. Western nations neither intervened in the cession nor recognized the republic.[29]
Kabayama and his staff sailed from Ujina on May 24, met the Imperial Guards in Okinawa and on May 29 landed at Cape Santiago (Sandiao) in the north-east of Taiwan. On June 2 Li Jingfang, sent by the Qing government as imperial commissioner, arrived off Keelung and concluded the formal handover of Taiwan with Kabayama. Japanese troops occupied Keelung on June 5; on June 6 Tang Jingsong and other leaders fled to the mainland, Chinese command of the army broke down and the Japanese entered Taipei unopposed. The Office of the Governor-General held its inauguration ceremony on June 17.[29]
Liu Yongfu, popular for his actions in the Sino-French War of 1884–1885, succeeded Tang as leader and kept his base at Tainan. Kabayama asked for reinforcements and pressed on toward Tainan. Formosan forces fought the Japanese at Hsinchu on June 20; the Japanese entered the town on June 22 but were surrounded, and retook it on June 25. Changhua fell to the Japanese on August 29, the Formosans suffering heavy losses in the battle there. On September 16 Kabayama ordered the formation of a Southern Expeditionary Army from the Imperial Guards, the 4th Mixed Brigade around Keelung and the 2nd Division from the Liaodong Peninsula; the Imperial Guards took Chiayi on October 9, the 4th Mixed Brigade landed at Po-te-chui north-west of Tainan on October 10 and 11, and the 2nd Division landed west of Fangliao, south-east of Tainan. Liu Yongfu escaped on the night of October 19 and crossed to Xiamen the next day; on October 21 part of the Japanese 2nd Division entered Tainan without firing a shot, the Republic of Formosa collapsed, and the remaining Chinese units surrendered and were sent back to the mainland. On November 18 Kabayama announced that peace had been restored throughout the island; organized fighting had continued until November. Taiwan remained under Japanese rule for the next fifty years.[29][33]
1906–1910Ding Ruchang Is Rehabilitated
After Ding Ruchang’s coffin reached Yantai, Li Hongzhang asked that the penalties against him be lifted, but Li Bingheng, governor of Shandong, memorialized that Ding had been dismissed and handed over to the Board of Punishments for the loss of Port Arthur; the court ruled that no posthumous honours were to be considered, and his coffin was bound with three copper hoops. In the summer of the 32nd year of Guangxu, more than 300 gentry and merchants of Weihai, Yantai and other places, ten officials and 114 others petitioned the Beiyang commissioner Yuan Shikai to clear Ding’s name, and the grand secretary Sun Jianai also memorialized for his rehabilitation; in 1910 Zaixun, Minister of the Navy, asked for his rehabilitation, the court restored his former rank, the hoops were removed and his coffin was buried.[9]
1985The Museum of the Sino-Japanese War 1894–1895 Is Founded
The Museum of the Sino-Japanese War 1894-1895 is a national museum founded to commemorate the war, located on Liugong Island in Weihai, Shandong, at the former headquarters of the late-Qing Beiyang Navy; it protects and manages 28 historic sites on the island, which the State Council designated a key protected cultural site in 1988. Its collections include more than 1,000 historic photographs, more than 200 relics of the navy and the war and more than 300 relics of ships recovered from the waters where the battles were fought, among them two giant naval guns weighing over 20 tonnes each. The museum is now named the China Jiawu War Museum (Zhongguo Jiawu Zhanzheng Bowuyuan).[34][26][35]
2013–2016Underwater Archaeology at the Wreck of the Zhiyuan
The State Administration of Cultural Heritage approved the project, called Dandong No. 1 and undertaken in connection with port construction, in November 2013; it was carried out by the National Underwater Cultural Heritage Protection Center with the Liaoning Provincial Institute of Cultural Relics and Archaeology. A geophysical survey located the wreck in April 2014 and the upper outline of the hull was uncovered in August–October 2014; in August–October 2015 a porcelain plate of the Zhiyuan, armoured deck, square portholes and a torpedo fuse were found, identifying the wreck as the Beiyang Fleet’s Zhiyuan; in September–October 2016 the bilge keel was cleared, the depth, distribution and condition of the remains were established and sacrificial anodes were fitted to protect the hull. The survey ended in October 2016, having recovered more than 200 artefacts.[36]
The site lies in the sea more than 50 km south-west of Donggang, Dandong, Liaoning, about 20 km from Dalu Island; the surviving hull, about 61 metres long, 11.5 metres wide at its widest and 2.5 metres high, is completely buried in mud. Among the finds is a telescope engraved with the name of the first officer Chen Jinkui, second in rank to the captain Deng Shichang and a former student of the Chinese Educational Mission. The discovery was named one of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences’ new archaeological discoveries of 2015 and one of China Cultural Relics News’s top ten national archaeological discoveries of 2015.[36]
2014The 120th Anniversary of the War
The newspaper Cankao Xiaoxi and the PLA bureau of Xinhua invited military officers to write a series, “Reflections of Military Experts on 1894,” serialized in Cankao Xiaoxi from March 3 to April 11; the articles of its 28 authors were collected in a book published by Shanghai Far East Publishers. From June 23 a second series, “Lessons of 1894 from Leading Scholars,” was published with the Chinese Historical Society; its authors included Dai Yi, Wu Yin, Zhang Haipeng, Wang Xiaoqiu, Liu Jiangyong, Lei Yi, Weng Fei, Chen Yue, Jiang Ming, Shen Qiang, Zhu Chengshan, Guan Jie, Zhou Suyuan, Qi Junjie, Cao Wen and Zhuo Nansheng, as well as Kōketsu Atsushi, vice-president of Yamaguchi University, Jiang Keshi, professor at Okayama University, and Wan-go H. C. WengWan-go H. C. WengWan-go H. C. Weng (1918–2020) was a collector, filmmaker and art historian who lived in the United States, a descendant of the late-Qing statesman Weng Tonghe and heir to the Weng family collection. He made dozens of educational and documentary films on Chinese art and culture, served as president of the China Institute in America, transferred the Weng family library to the Shanghai Library and gave a large part of the family’s paintings and calligraphy to the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, and other institutions in the United States and China.Open the full entry in the United States, whose article was titled “‘For War’ and ‘For Peace’ Is a False Question about the War of 1894.”[37]
On July 24 a symposium on the 120th anniversary of the war brought together military figures and historians of the war. A six-part documentary on the rise and fall of the Beiyang Navy, 45 minutes per episode and subtitled as a 120th-anniversary commemoration of the naval war, was completed in June 2014 after two years of preparation and scheduled for first broadcast on CCTV’s documentary channel from July 29 to August 3.[12]
July–September 2019: The Wreck Site of the Dingyuan Is Identified
With the approval of the State Administration of Cultural Heritage, a joint team of more than 30 specialists from the National Underwater Cultural Heritage Protection Center, the Shandong Underwater Archaeology Research Center, the China Jiawu War Museum and Weihai Museum carried out a first underwater survey in July–August 2019; building on geophysical surveys and diving in 2017 and 2018, they removed sediment to expose a section of hull beneath one to three metres of mud and recovered more than 150 artefacts, similar to finds at the wrecks of the Zhiyuan and the Jingyuan. At a meeting on Liugong Island on September 2 to define a protection zone for the Weihai Bay No. 1 wreck site, experts concluded that the place where the Dingyuan sank had been essentially identified.[26]
The Dingyuan was a 7,000-ton first-class ironclad built for China by a German shipyard (in the city now called Szczecin, Poland); she joined the Beiyang Navy in 1885 as its flagship. After the war the Japanese stripped the wreck, and its weapons and materials were taken to Japan.[26]
January 1–March 30, 2025: Calligraphy of Figures of the War at Tsinghua University
The Tsinghua University Art Museum held the exhibition “Loyal Hearts on Angry Seas: Calligraphy of Figures of the Sino-Japanese War of 1894” in Gallery 10 on its fourth floor, showing more than 170 letters and other writings by key figures of the war, with the support of the Xiangjiang Museum (Hanmo Xuan), the China Jiawu War Museum and Weihai Museum; it was arranged in four sections, on the court, the soldiers, the awakening and the lessons, centred on writings of Li Hongzhang, Ding Ruchang, Zhang Jian and others, and also showed writings by figures on the Japanese side.[35]
Names
Japanese Casualties
Since the start of the war around 1,400 Japanese officers and men had been killed in all the fighting, while many times more, 11,900, died of disease; in Taiwan the army also suffered from malaria, dysentery and beriberi.[29]
Debates on the Causes of the Qing Defeat
It has been argued that the defeat reflected, at a deeper level, problems of the Qing system: after the Meiji Restoration Japan built a modern military system, set up a wartime Imperial General Headquarters before the war to coordinate operations against China, and organized and commanded its Combined Fleet better than the Beiyang Fleet, while the Qing navy kept an old system with divided authority and overlapping functions, the court set up no unified command after war broke out, and the army and navy fought separately and were defeated one by one. On this view the two fleets were roughly equal in firepower and ship performance; Japan’s headquarters, following Mahan’s ideas of sea power, treated command of the sea and a decisive naval battle as the key to the whole war, whereas the Qing court had no clear naval strategy and merely ordered the Beiyang Fleet to hold the Gulf of Bohai, and Li Hongzhang’s strategy of deterrence and his policy of preserving the ships to restrain the enemy left the fleet in passive defence.[20]
Another view holds that the Japanese fleet was far superior in tonnage, firepower, speed and strength (195 guns on the Chinese side against 268), that the Beiyang Fleet was poorly trained and maintained, the flagship Dingyuan having gone seven of her twelve years in service without maintenance or refit, and that some military funds were allegedly spent on the Summer Palace. The sum diverted from naval funds to the Summer Palace is commonly put at 20 to 30 million taels; one researcher, calculating from Qing palace archives, puts it at about 7.5 million; it has also been argued that the Empress Dowager diverted 5 to 6 million taels of naval construction funds to build the Summer Palace, but that the defeat cannot simply be attributed to the building of the Summer Palace.[10][12][38]
Yan FuYan FuYan Fu (1854–1921) was a translator, thinker and educator of the late Qing and early Republican period. Trained at the Fuzhou Navy Yard School and the Royal Naval College at Greenwich, he served for many years at the Beiyang Naval Academy in Tianjin; his translations of Thomas Henry Huxley, Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill and others, above all the Tianyan lun, introduced Western thought to China, and he set out faithfulness, comprehensibility and elegance as the standards of translation. In 1912 he became the first president of Peking University, and in 1915 his name was listed among the founders of the Chouanhui.Open the full entry summed up three causes of the defeat: the Self-Strengthening MovementSelf-Strengthening MovementThe Self-Strengthening Movement (also called the Foreign Affairs Movement) was a reform effort of the Qing dynasty from the 1860s to the mid-1890s, usually dated 1861–1895, that adopted Western military technology, industry and education. It was led by Prince Gong and Wenxiang in Beijing and by provincial leaders such as Zeng Guofan, Li Hongzhang, Zuo Zongtang and Zhang Zhidong, and as a whole it came to an end after China’s defeat in the First Sino-Japanese War of 1894–95.Open the full entry had concentrated on material things without turning to institutional change, the examination system was flawed, and the fundamental political system was flawed; he also criticized Li Hongzhang’s choice of men. It has been pointed out that before the war Japan already had more than 900 banks, over 100 of them national banks, while China had not a single modern bank and still relied on remittance houses and native banks. Others have argued that the fundamental cause lay in the change in the nature of Chinese society in the 54 years after 1840.[12][13]
Consequences and Assessments
The war marked Japan’s emergence as a major world power and exposed the weakness of the Qing empire; it encouraged further Western demands on China and sparked a reform movement and early revolutionary activity against the Qing. After the defeat Liang Qichao warned that the country might perish any day, Yan Fu translated Evolution and Ethics, and Kang Youwei founded the Society for National Strengthening and promoted the Hundred Days’ ReformHundred Days’ ReformThe Hundred Days’ Reform (also called the Wuxu Reform, after wuxu, the cyclical name of the year 1898) was a reform of the state and society attempted from the top by the Guangxu Emperor of the Qing dynasty in 1898 under the influence of reformers led by Kang Youwei and Liang Qichao. It lasted about a hundred days and ended when Empress Dowager Cixi staged a coup and the reformers were executed or driven into exile.Open the full entry of 1898.[7][13]
It has been argued that the war was a turning point in the modernization of China and the other countries of North-East Asia; it has also been described as an important turning point in the histories of both China and Japan and as marking the end of the traditional order in East Asia. Some have argued that the defeat marked the failure of the Self-Strengthening Movement and left the Chinese nation facing extinction, and that it was not the Opium War of 1840 but the war of 1894 that was the decisive moment in old China’s slide into the abyss.[39][35][13]
It has been argued that without the war of 1894 there would have been neither the Russo-Japanese War ten years later nor the Mukden Incident and the Marco Polo Bridge Incident, the same scholar listing Japan’s 50 years of rule over Taiwan, 40 years of occupation of Dalian, 14 years of occupation of the north-east and 8 years of war across China. Others have seen it as the first war of Japan’s national policy, by which Japan turned from oppressed to oppressor and joined the imperialist powers, going on to the Russo-Japanese War, the First World War and the invasion of China; others again stress that its impact went beyond China and Japan.[12][37]
After the war Japan tightened its control over Korea, where resistance continued; in 1909 the Korean nationalist An Jung-geun assassinated Itō Hirobumi, Japan’s first Resident-General of Korea, and in 1910 Japan annexed Korea.[27]
The French newspaper Le Figaro published more than 130 articles on the war between July 1894 and November 1895; it has been pointed out that Westerners at the time generally regarded Li Hongzhang as the only senior Qing official who saw the situation clearly.[12]
Records, Archives and Images
The Japan Center for Asian Historical Records has an online exhibition on the war showing prints held by the British Library and Japanese archival documents; the print images are provided by the British Library and are in the public domain. The documents shown include the original Imperial Rescript declaring war signed by Emperor Meiji, the Japanese cabinet’s decision on the starting date of the war, and the signed copies of the Japan–Korea Treaty of Amity, the Treaty of Chemulpo, the Tientsin Convention, the Japanese-Korean Alliance and the armistice.[19][5][1][22]
During the war Hakubunkan of Nihonbashi, Tokyo, published the magazine Nisshin Sensō Jikki (A True Record of the Japan–Qing War); the first issue appeared on August 27, 1894, the 27th day after the declaration of war, issues followed about every ten days, and the 49th appeared on December 27, 1895. It covered the fighting, the destruction of the Beiyang Fleet and the Treaty of Shimonoseki, profiled the fleet’s admirals, ships and fighting strength, and printed an article on Li Hongzhang. A set of the 49 issues is held by the Nanjing Folk Museum of the War of Resistance against Japan.[40]
It has been pointed out that the Englishman James Allen’s Under the Dragon Flag preserves first-hand evidence of the Port Arthur massacre, and that the memoir Thirty Years in Moukden by Christie, a Scottish Presbyterian medical missionary, describes the leadership and death of the Chinese general Zuo Baogui and Japanese atrocities in Fengtian; newspapers such as Shenbao, the North-China Daily News, The New York TimesThe New York TimesThe New York Times is an American morning daily newspaper published in New York City. Founded in 1851, it is published by The New York Times Company.Open the full entry and The Times covered the war, and Japan preserved a large body of original war records that can make up for the gaps in Chinese records of the land war.[20]
Literature and Commemoration
Huang ZunxianHuang ZunxianHuang Zunxian (1848–1905) was a late-Qing poet, diplomat and reformer who served as counselor of the Chinese legation in Japan, consul-general in San Francisco, counselor of the legation in London and consul-general in Singapore. He wrote the Riben guozhi (Treatises on Japan) and the Riben zashishi (Poems on Miscellaneous Subjects from Japan), and his collected poems, which brought colloquial language and new subjects into Chinese verse, made him a leading figure of the revolution in poetry; in 1897–1898 he took part in the reforms in Hunan, and after the coup of 1898 he was dismissed and returned home.Open the full entry wrote poems including “Lament for Pyongyang” and “Song of Donggou.”[41]
Statues of Deng Shichang and his dog stand in Weihai, including on Liugong Island. In a Japanese naval cemetery the gravestones of more than 50 Japanese officers and men killed in the Battle of the Yellow Sea are well preserved, each with flowers and fresh water before it.[10][12]
A memorial to Shen Shouchang stands on the Huxi campus of Tongji University in Shanghai. His grave, inscribed “Tomb of Lord Shen Shouchang of the Imperial Qing,” was found when graves were moved for land levelling in April 1964; his coffin was reburied beside a stream outside the wall of the Shanghai Railway Institute and, unmarked, was gradually forgotten. The new site was confirmed in November 1996, the foundation stone of the memorial was laid on May 18, 1997, and it was completed in the mid-autumn of 1998; in 2005 it became one of the first patriotic education bases of Putuo District.[8]
Sources41 sources
- 1. Origins and background : Upheavals in Korea and the reactions of Japan and China – Donghak Peasant Rebellion (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- Glossary (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- Yuan Shikai (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- 陈晓平:河工用款对北洋海军“停购船炮”的影响 [Chen Xiaoping: How river-works spending bore on the halt to ship and gun purchases for the Beiyang Navy] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)m.thepaper.cn↑
- 2. Outbreak of the war : Japan and China dispatch troops to Korea, fighting begins – Declaration of war (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- 甲午海战告诉我们什么 [What the naval battles of 1894 tell us] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)paper.people.com.cn↑
- First Sino-Japanese War (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
- 甲午祭|两甲子之后,仍有人在沈寿昌的墓前唏嘘 [Jiawu memorial: two sixty-year cycles later, people still sigh at Shen Shouchang’s grave] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
- 如是我读︱英雄狗熊:甲午海战中的众生相 [Heroes and cowards: people in the naval war of 1894] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
- (4) The Modernized Naval Battle (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
- Foreign Relations of the United States, 1894, Appendix I, Document 31 (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
- 甲午祭︱用数字说话,8位学术名家的甲午镜鉴 [Jiawu memorial: eight leading scholars on the lessons of 1894, in numbers] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
- 李慎明:咀嚼100多年前那场惨烈悲壮的中日甲午战争 [Li Shenming: Reflecting on the tragic and heroic Sino-Japanese War of more than 100 years ago] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)cssn.cn↑
- 3. Course of the fighting : Fall of Pyongyang and the Battle of the Yalu River –Japanese army enters China (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- 悲剧皇帝——光绪 [The tragic emperor: Guangxu] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)paper.people.com.cn↑
- Foreign Relations of the United States, 1894, Appendix I, Document 33 (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
- Foreign Relations of the United States, 1894, Appendix I, Document 30 (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
- 翁同龢日记最具权威性的版本 [The most authoritative edition of the Diary of Weng Tonghe] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)epaper.gmw.cn↑
- 15 Sep 1894 Fall of Pyongyang (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- 深化甲午战争史研究 [Deepening research on the history of the Sino-Japanese War of 1894–1895] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)sinoss.net↑
- Naval Warfare and the Refraction of China's Self-Strengthening Reforms into Scientific and Technological Failure, 1865–1895 (opens in a new window)princeton.edu↑
- 4. Towards peace : Start of peace negotiations –Treaty of Shimonoseki and Triple Intervention (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- 旅顺军港首次对公众开放 百年要塞见证海军崛起 [Lüshun naval port opens to the public for the first time] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)mil.huanqiu.com↑
- Foreign Relations of the United States, 1894, Appendix I, Document 87 (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
- 茅海建:张之洞为何对容闳评价一般 [Mao Haijian: Why Zhang Zhidong rated Yung Wing only moderately] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
- “定远舰”沉舰遗址在山东威海发现,出水一批沉舰遗物 [Wreck site of the Dingyuan found at Weihai, Shandong; artefacts recovered] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
- (5) Signing of the Treaty of Shimonoseki (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
- 日清戦争 [The Sino-Japanese War] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)archives.go.jp↑
- 5. Fighting in Taiwan : Establishment of Office of Governor-General of Taiwan and Republic of Formosa – Conclusion of the war (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- Treaty of Shimonoseki (opens in a new window)pages.ucsd.edu↑
- Treaty of Shimonoseki (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
- 茅海建:“公车上书”考证补 [Mao Haijian: Further research on the “Public Vehicle Petition”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
- About the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-1895 (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
- Museum of the Sino-Japanese War 1894-1895 (opens in a new window)regional.chinadaily.com.cn↑
- 怒海丹心:甲午风云人物墨迹展 [Loyal Hearts on Angry Seas: Calligraphy of Figures of the Sino-Japanese War of 1894] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)tsinghua.edu.cn↑
- “丹东一号”水下考古创新使用牺牲阳极法保护致远舰 [Dandong No. 1 underwater archaeology protects the Zhiyuan with sacrificial anodes] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinanews.com.cn↑
- 《参考消息》推出“学术名家的甲午镜鉴”系列 [Cankao Xiaoxi launches a series of leading scholars on the lessons of 1894] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
- 中日甲午战争与慈禧太后 [The Sino-Japanese War of 1894 and Empress Dowager Cixi] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)qsyj.ruc.edu.cn↑
- 中国近30年来甲午战争研究综述 [A Review of the Studies on the Sino-Japanese War in the Last 30 Years] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)xb.szu.edu.cn↑
- 甲午战争日本对李鸿章了如指掌:在清廷处境尴尬 [In the war of 1894 Japan knew Li Hongzhang inside out] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)rmzxw.com.cn↑
- 黄遵宪:发“五四”白话诗之先声 [Huang Zunxian: A Precursor of the Vernacular Poetry of the May Fourth Era] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑