ABAB Pedia

Guangxu Emperor

The Guangxu Emperor (1871–1908), personal name Zaitian, was emperor of the Qing dynasty from 1875 to 1908. A son of Yixuan, Prince Chun, and of a sister of the Empress Dowager CixiEmpress Dowager CixiEmpress Dowager Cixi (1835–1908), of the Yehe Nara clan, was a consort of the Xianfeng Emperor and the mother of the Tongzhi Emperor. From the coup of 1861 until her death in 1908 she ruled as co-regent with Ci’an, as sole regent and as instructing regent for two emperors, the Tongzhi Emperor and the Guangxu Emperor, and was the de facto ruler of China for nearly half a century of the late Qing.Open the full entry, he was chosen by Cixi to succeed the Tongzhi EmperorTongzhi EmperorThe Tongzhi Emperor (1856–1875), personal name Zaichun, was the eighth emperor of the Qing dynasty and the son of the Xianfeng Emperor and Empress Dowager Cixi. He reigned from 1861 to 1875 under the reign title Tongzhi; his temple name is Muzong.Open the full entry. In 1898 he launched the Hundred Days’ ReformHundred Days’ ReformThe Hundred Days’ Reform (also called the Wuxu Reform, after wuxu, the cyclical name of the year 1898) was a reform of the state and society attempted from the top by the Guangxu Emperor of the Qing dynasty in 1898 under the influence of reformers led by Kang Youwei and Liang Qichao. It lasted about a hundred days and ended when Empress Dowager Cixi staged a coup and the reformers were executed or driven into exile.Open the full entry, which ended when Cixi staged a coup; he spent the rest of his life confined on Yingtai in Zhongnanhai and died in 1908. A report published in 2008 concluded that he had died of arsenic poisoning.

Contents40 sections
Key facts

Born at the Prince Chun Mansion in Beijing

The Guangxu Emperor, personal name Zaitian, temple name Dezong, was born at the mansion of the Prince of Chun beside Taiping Lake near Xuanwu Gate in Beijing. His father, Yixuan, Prince Chun, was the seventh son of the Daoguang Emperor and a younger brother of the Xianfeng Emperor, which made him a grandson of the Daoguang Emperor; his mother was a younger sister of the Empress Dowager Cixi.⁠[1][2][3][4][5]

Yixuan’s eldest son died in infancy, and Zaitian was his second son. Four of Yixuan’s sons reached adulthood: after Zaitian came Zaifeng, Zaixun and Zaitao; Zaifeng later served as prince regent.⁠[4]

Ascends the Throne with the Reign Name Guangxu

The Tongzhi Emperor died on January 12, 1875, without a son. Overriding objections, the Empress Dowager Cixi named Tongzhi’s cousin Zaitian as his successor on the spot and adopted him, so that she could continue to rule as regent; she made Zaitian the adopted heir of herself and the Xianfeng Emperor rather than of the Tongzhi Emperor, leaving the Tongzhi Emperor without a legal heir. The dynasty’s rules of succession required a new emperor to be chosen from the next generation, and the arrangement broke them. To Cixi, Zaitian was both a nephew by marriage and her sister’s son.⁠[6][2][3][1][4][7]

Accounts of his age at the time differ: three by one account, four by another and five by a third. On his accession he took the reign name Guangxu.⁠[6][1][4][2]

Yixuan was nominally only the emperor’s uncle. Weng TongheWeng TongheWeng Tonghe (1830–1904) was an official, calligrapher and diarist of the late Qing dynasty, tutor to two emperors, Tongzhi and Guangxu, and at various times president of the Board of Revenue, Grand Councillor and Associate Grand Secretary. He was dismissed soon after the Hundred Days’ Reform began in 1898 and stripped of his ranks after the coup that ended it; the diary he kept for nearly half a century is counted among the four great diaries of the late Qing.Open the full entry recorded in his diary that on hearing his son had been chosen Yixuan “knocked his head on the ground and wept bitterly, fell to the floor in a faint, and could not rise even when helped”; Yixuan afterwards did his utmost to assure the empress dowager that his family had no ambition for the throne or for power. To thank him, Cixi exempted Yixuan from performing the full kowtow to the emperor at grand audiences.⁠[4]

Studies at the Yuqing Palace under Weng Tonghe

Weng Tonghe was ordered to teach him at the Yuqing Palace and became his tutor; Weng had earlier taught the Tongzhi Emperor in the Hongde Hall and so became known as the tutor of two emperors. From about 1889 Weng took an interest in the growing current of reformist thinking and introduced him to reformist writings, including those of Kang YouweiKang YouweiKang Youwei (1858–1927) was a Chinese scholar, political reformer and calligrapher of the late Qing and early Republican periods and a principal promoter of the Hundred Days’ Reform of 1898. After the reform was reversed he spent more than a decade in exile, founded the Baohuanghui (Chinese Empire Reform Association) and argued for constitutional monarchy; in later life he campaigned to make Confucianism the state religion. His works include The Forged Classics, Confucius as a Reformer and the Datong shu (The Great Commonwealth).Open the full entry, whose books and ideas strengthened the emperor’s reforming zeal.⁠[8][9][3]

Wu Kedu’s Suicide Memorial

After the Tongzhi Emperor’s burial Wu Kedu took poison at a Taoist monastery at Jizhou, leaving a memorial that openly accused the two empresses dowager of erring in choosing as heir to the Tongzhi Emperor one of his own generation, the Guangxu Emperor. The court regarded the suggestion as pointless, but Empress Dowager Cixi was willing to reiterate that the Guangxu Emperor’s future heir would at the same time be the heir of the Tongzhi Emperor.⁠[10][11]

The Grand Council Reshuffle and His Father Yixuan

That year the whole Grand Council was replaced, and his father Yixuan was thereafter in effect at the forefront of decision-making, though he never held the formal title of grand councillor; Yixuan also took over the newly founded Admiralty and directed the works at the Summer Palace and the Three Lakes, so that the funds of the two became hard to separate.⁠[4]

Comes of Age

He came of age but had to wait two more years before taking over the government from Cixi. Under the arrangement made that year, the empress dowager said she would hand back power after the emperor married at 19.⁠[2][4]

On the fifteenth day of the first lunar month of 1887 Cixi held the ceremony of his personal rule; from then on he nominally ruled, but in fact the empress dowager governed as his instructing regent.⁠[12]

Imperial Wedding

His wedding took place on the 26th day of the first lunar month of the fifteenth year of Guangxu, and Empress Longyu became mistress of the palace. The empress was a daughter of Cixi’s younger brother. Entering the palace the same year were two daughters of Changxu, sisters who became Consort Jin and Consort Zhen; Consort Zhen had been born in 1876.⁠[13][1][14][15]

Accounts of the sisters’ rank on entering the palace differ: by one account they were made Consort Jin and Consort Zhen at the wedding; by another they then held the lower rank of pin, and the court’s wedding records list a yellow order of the 7th day of the first month assigning Pin Jin to the Yonghe Palace, and the dowry prepared at the pin rank by the minister of the Imperial Household and sent to her family on the 16th, before the wedding.⁠[13][15]

By one account the empress was plain and the emperor deeply dissatisfied, while Consort Zhen, handsome, poised, lively and quick, was his favourite.⁠[1][14]

Assumes Personal Rule

He formally assumed power, and Cixi nominally relinquished control over the government and retired to the summer palace she had rebuilt northwest of Beijing, though she still influenced policy.⁠[6][2]

His wedding ceremonies were completed on the twenty-seventh day of the first lunar month of 1889, and on the third day of the second month he held the grand ceremony of personal rule, which marked the end of Cixi’s instructing regency.⁠[12]

Death of His Father Yixuan

His father Yixuan died and was given the posthumous name Xian; he was buried in 1892.⁠[4]

Consorts Jin and Zhen Promoted, Then Demoted

On the Empress Dowager Cixi’s sixtieth birthday Pin Jin and Pin Zhen were promoted together to Consort Jin and Consort Zhen; the same year, because Consort Zhen had offended Cixi, the two were demoted to the rank of guiren. Consort Jin was honoured as Noble Consort Jin early in the Xuantong reign and as Imperial Noble Consort Duankang after the abdication, and died of illness in the Yonghe Palace in 1924, aged 51.⁠[15]

Declaration of War on Japan

At the outbreak of the First Sino-Japanese WarFirst Sino-Japanese WarThe First Sino-Japanese War was fought between Qing China and Japan in 1894–1895, chiefly over Korea. Fighting broke out in Korea in July 1894 and both countries declared war on August 1; Chinese forces were defeated on land and at sea, Japanese armies invaded north-eastern China and the Shandong Peninsula, and the Beiyang Fleet was destroyed at Weihaiwei. The Treaty of Shimonoseki of April 1895 obliged China to recognize the independence of Korea, cede the Liaodong Peninsula, Taiwan and the Pescadores and pay a large indemnity; the Liaodong Peninsula was returned to China after the Triple Intervention, and resistance in Taiwan continued until November 1895.Open the full entry the Qing court issued an edict declaring war on Japan, and Japan declared war on the Qing the same day. The emperor, then about to turn 23, was a firm advocate of war and pressed Li HongzhangLi HongzhangLi Hongzhang (1823–1901) was a Chinese statesman, military commander and diplomat of the late Qing dynasty, the founder and commander of the Huai Army and one of the principal promoters of the Self-Strengthening Movement. From 1870 he served for many years as governor-general of Zhili and superintendent of trade for the northern ports, sponsored modern enterprises such as the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company, the Kaiping mines, railways, telegraphs and the Beiyang Fleet, and signed treaties including the Treaty of Shimonoseki and the Boxer Protocol for the Qing government; judgments of him, in his lifetime and since, have been sharply divided.Open the full entry to send troops.⁠[16][17][1]

The Treaty of Shimonoseki

After the defeat the Qing concluded the Treaty of Shimonoseki with Japan, recognizing the independence of Korea, ceding Taiwan, the Pescadores and the Liaodong Peninsula, paying an indemnity of 200 million taels and opening Shashi, Chongqing, Suzhou and Hangzhou to Japanese trade. Russia, France and Germany then intervened, and Japan returned the Liaodong Peninsula in exchange for a further 30 million taels.⁠[18]

The defeat intensified the powers’ scramble for leaseholds and spheres of influence, leaving China on the edge of partition; desperate to avert the crisis, the emperor resolved to carry out rapid and sweeping reforms.⁠[19][20]

On the eighth day of the fourth lunar month (May 2) he issued his vermilion rescript, “Approved as proposed,” on Li Hongzhang’s memorial asking for ratification of the Treaty of Shimonoseki, thereby approving the treaty; the Grand Council set the affixing of the imperial seal for the morning of the next day.⁠[21]

Learns of Kang Youwei’s Call for Reform

The emperor learned from his tutor Weng Tonghe of Kang Youwei’s call for reform and asked Kang to state his political views; he was deeply moved on reading Kang’s Memorial on Coping with the Overall Situation in Reply to an Imperial Proclamation. Weng supported Kang’s reform proposals and recommended him to the emperor.⁠[19][8]

The Edict Establishing the Fundamental Policy of the State

The emperor issued the Edict Establishing the Fundamental Policy of the State, declaring reform state policy and launching the Hundred Days’ Reform. The programme worked on several levels: more voices on political matters, modern military training, the promotion of new industries and enterprises, the abolition of the eight-legged essay in the civil service examinations, the founding of the Imperial University of Peking and more; he gathered a group of progressively minded officials around him and issued a broad series of reform edicts.⁠[22][19][2]

It has been argued that although he launched the reform he was emperor in name only, with Cixi and her faction still holding the reins of power.⁠[19]

Weng Tonghe Dismissed

An edict in the emperor’s name dismissed Weng Tonghe and sent him home, on the grounds that “of late his handling of affairs has often been improper, so that opinion is not satisfied and he has repeatedly been impeached; at audiences, when consulted, he approves or rejects at will, shows his pleasure and anger in his words and looks, and increasingly reveals a wilful grasping for power; he is quite unfit for the responsibilities of the Grand Council.” Accounts of the reason differ: it has been argued that the main cause was the deepening conflict between Weng and the emperor; by another account it was Cixi who removed Weng from his posts as assistant grand secretary and grand councillor on the fourth day after the edict, and she appointed her trusted follower Ronglu governor-general of Zhili and commissioner of the Northern Ports, posts that gave him control of Beijing and Tianjin.⁠[22][9][23]

Audiences with Kang Youwei and Zhang Yuanji

After Xu Zhijing, a sub-reader in the Hanlin Academy, recommended them, the emperor had ordered Kang Youwei and Zhang YuanjiZhang YuanjiZhang Yuanji (1867–1959) was a late-Qing jinshi and Hanlin bachelor who served as a secretary of the Zongli Yamen, was received by the Guangxu Emperor during the Hundred Days’ Reform and was dismissed after the coup of 1898. He then ran the translation bureau of Nanyang Public School and in the early twentieth century joined the Commercial Press, where he was successively head of the editorial department, manager, supervisor and chairman, directing its new-style textbooks and reprint series of old books such as the Sibu congkan and the Baina edition of the Twenty-Four Histories; in old age he was the first director of the Shanghai Research Institute of Culture and History.Open the full entry to prepare for audiences, Huang ZunxianHuang ZunxianHuang Zunxian (1848–1905) was a late-Qing poet, diplomat and reformer who served as counselor of the Chinese legation in Japan, consul-general in San Francisco, counselor of the legation in London and consul-general in Singapore. He wrote the Riben guozhi (Treatises on Japan) and the Riben zashishi (Poems on Miscellaneous Subjects from Japan), and his collected poems, which brought colloquial language and new subjects into Chinese verse, made him a leading figure of the revolution in poetry; in 1897–1898 he took part in the reforms in Hunan, and after the coup of 1898 he was dismissed and returned home.Open the full entry and Tan SitongTan SitongTan Sitong (1865–1898) was a Chinese thinker and reformer of the late Qing from Liuyang, Hunan, and the author of the Renxue (A Study of Benevolence). He took part in the reforms in Hunan in 1897–1898 and served as a secretary of the Grand Council during the Hundred Days’ Reform of 1898; after the coup of that year he refused to flee and was arrested and executed, one of the “Six Gentlemen of 1898.”Open the full entry to be presented through the boards, and Liang QichaoLiang QichaoLiang Qichao (1873–1929) was a thinker, politician, journalist and scholar of the late Qing and early Republic, a disciple of Kang Youwei and a participant in the Hundred Days’ Reform of 1898. After the reform failed he spent 14 years in exile in Japan, where he ran the journals Qingyi Bao and Xinmin Congbao; returning in 1912, he helped to found the Progressive Party, served the Beijing government as minister of justice and minister of finance, and in 1915–1916 opposed Yuan Shikai’s attempt to make himself emperor. After leaving politics at the end of 1917 he devoted himself to writing and teaching, was a tutor at the Tsinghua Academy of Chinese Learning and director of the Beijing Library, and left the collected works known as the Yinbingshi heji.Open the full entry to be assessed by the Zongli Yamen. On this day he received Kang and then Zhang. To Kang he said that China’s peril had been “brought about entirely by the conservatives” and that “today there is truly no choice but to reform”; glancing towards the screen, he sighed: “But what can I do when they hold me back!” He asked Zhang about the Tongyi school.⁠[22][24]

Years later, although he had come to see the failure of the reform differently, Zhang Yuanji still remembered with gratitude the emperor’s recognition of him.⁠[24]

Abolition of the Eight-Legged Essay

When Gangyi argued against abolishing the eight-legged essay, saying “this is a grave matter that has been practised for centuries and cannot simply be abolished”, the emperor demanded sharply: “Do you wish to obstruct me?” Gangyi asked that the empress dowager be consulted. On June 22 Kang Youwei again memorialized in Xu Zhijing’s name, urging the emperor to act decisively; the next day the emperor decreed that from the next examination onwards candidates would write policy essays instead.⁠[22]

Audience with Liang Qichao

After his audience Liang Qichao was given the sixth rank and put in charge of the translation bureau. The same year, at the request of the censor Song Bolu, the emperor approved turning the Shiwu Bao newspaper into an official paper under Kang Youwei; Wang Kangnian refused to hand it over and renamed it Changyan Bao, which closed after ten issues.⁠[25]

Sun Jianai Put in Charge of the University

The emperor appointed Sun Jianai to manage the affairs of the university.⁠[22]

Li Duanfen Proposes Opening the Maoqin Hall

In mid-July Liang Qichao had drafted a memorial for the vice-minister Li Duanfen proposing that the Maoqin Hall be opened in the inner court to discuss institutions, a way of giving reformers access to the emperor and a part in decisions. Li submitted it, and the emperor referred it the same day to Yikuang and Sun Jianai together with the grand councillors, who stressed that the choice of members called for the greatest caution but did not openly oppose it.⁠[22]

Redundant Offices Abolished

Accepting a memorial from Cen Chunxuan, junior minister of the Court of the Imperial Stud, the emperor ordered six redundant offices abolished – the Supervisorate of Imperial Instruction, the Office of Transmission, the Court of Imperial Entertainments, the Court of State Ceremonial, the Court of the Imperial Stud and the Court of Judicial Review – together with redundant provincial posts including the governorships of Hubei, Guangdong and Yunnan and the director-general of the Eastern Yellow River, and ordered the officials concerned to work out which other posts in and outside the capital should be cut or merged.⁠[22]

Four Grand Council Secretaries Appointed

The emperor gave Yang Rui, Liu Guangdi, Lin Xu and Tan Sitong the rank of fourth-grade ministers and appointed them to serve as Grand Council secretaries taking part in the new policies.⁠[22]

Audience with Yan Fu

Audience with Yuan Shikai at the Summer Palace

The Wuxu Coup and Confinement on Yingtai

The Empress Dowager Cixi staged a coup, resumed her regency and imprisoned the emperor on Yingtai, an artificial island in Zhongnanhai; the reform, which had lasted 103 days, was over. With the help of the top military commander Ronglu she confined the emperor to his palace and spread rumours that he was deathly ill; the intervention of the foreign powers saved his life, but he never again had power over the government. On Yingtai he was cut off from all contact with the outside world. By one account his quarters in the Hanyuan Hall on Yingtai were long in disrepair and draughty on all sides, with no stove even in the depth of winter, so that it was bitterly cold.⁠[23][22][2][1][5]

On September 28 six reformers – Tan Sitong, Yang Rui, Liu Guangdi, Lin Xu, Yang Shenxiu and Kang Guangren – were executed, while Kang Youwei and Liang Qichao fled the country.⁠[23]

On the course of the coup, it has been argued from archival sources that on the third day of the eighth lunar month Cixi had already ordered that the emperor be stripped of authority over government affairs, which in itself amounted to a coup; on the sixth (September 21) she announced her tutelage and ordered Kang Youwei seized; the censor Yang Chongyi did not return from Tianjin with Yuan Shikai’s so-called secret report until the evening of the seventh, so the tutelage was not prompted by it; outsiders, unaware of the full sequence, assumed it was, and the resulting rumours still have influence. It has also been argued that the claim that Yuan’s betrayal caused the coup cannot be sustained.⁠[28][22][27]

After the coup Cixi considered deposing him. Under foreign pressure the court was forced to let a French physician examine him in the palace, and Liu KunyiLiu KunyiLiu Kunyi (1830–1902), a Xiang Army officer from Xinning, Hunan, held senior Qing posts in Jiangxi, Guangdong and Guangxi, and Liangjiang. He commanded forces during the Sino-Japanese War. With Zhang Zhidong he negotiated the protection of the lower Yangtze during the Boxer crisis and submitted proposals for reform.Open the full entry warned that the people were seriously concerned and that powerful neighbours were watching. In the end Cixi was forced to abandon the plan.⁠[23]

Flight to Xi’an with the Empress Dowager

When the Eight-Nation Alliance captured Beijing, Cixi fled to Xi’an. Before dawn on the 21st day of the seventh lunar month of 1900 the court left in haste: Cixi wore a blue linen robe and rode in the cart of Zailan, Duke Zhenguo; the emperor, in a white silk robe, rode in the cart of Yingnian, commander of the left wing.⁠[29][15]

Consort Zhen, confined since 1898, was pushed into a well and died in 1900; by one account Cixi ordered palace eunuchs to throw her in. Only in 1901 did the court confer on her posthumously the title of noble consort as a mark of favour.⁠[14][1]

The Boxer Protocol Signed

While in exile Cixi ordered Yikuang to negotiate peace. The Qing signed the Boxer Protocol with 11 countries; its terms included punishing officials who had supported the Boxers, sending princes and senior officials to Germany and Japan, an indemnity of 450 million taels (later called the Boxer Indemnity), a legation quarter in Beijing guarded by foreign troops and reserved for foreigners, foreign guards on the railway linking Beijing, Dagu and Shanhai Pass, and turning the Zongli Yamen into a ministry of foreign affairs.⁠[29]

Return to Beijing

Four months to the day after the Boxer Protocol was signed, Cixi, the emperor and the rest of the court and retinue of the “western tour of inspection” reached the Forbidden City in the afternoon after the long journey from Xi’an. They arrived by train, and a great assembly of officials waited at the Beijing station to welcome them.⁠[30][29]

As he offered incense at the Zhengyang Gate, foreign photographers watching from the city wall captured his figure: Cixi waved a handkerchief at the foreigners on the wall, while the emperor stepped down from his sedan chair very quickly and did not look up at them as she did, so that his face cannot be made out. It is the only known photograph in which his figure can be seen.⁠[14]

Death

The Guangxu Emperor died in Beijing, still a prisoner on Yingtai. Counting from his dates of birth and death he was 37; some accounts give 38. He died in the you hour (5 to 7 p.m.) of the 21st day of the tenth lunar month of the 34th year of Guangxu, and Cixi in the wei hour (1 to 3 p.m.) of the 22nd. Cixi died the next day, November 15, less than 20 hours later (22 hours by another account). Accounts of when his death was made known differ: by one it was announced the day before Cixi died; by another, the emperor, who had until then been healthy, was announced at the time of her death as having died the previous day, in highly suspicious circumstances.⁠[2][31][32][6][3][5]

He had no children. Cixi’s final decree passed the throne to his three-year-old nephew Puyi, son of his brother Zaifeng, who reigned as the Xuantong Emperor.⁠[4][2]

One account runs: the minister of rites Puliang (great-grandfather of Qi Gong), attending outside the empress dowager’s quarters, saw a eunuch come out of the Hall of Joyful Longevity carrying a covered bowl, which the eunuch said was yogurt “bestowed by the Old Buddha on His Majesty”; Puliang passed the account down by word of mouth.⁠[31][32]

Building of the Chongling Mausoleum

His mausoleum, Chongling, was begun in 1909, the first year of the Xuantong reign, and completed in 1915, the fourth year of the Republic; it lies in the Western Qing Tombs below Yongning Mountain, 15 kilometres west of Lianggezhuang in what is now Yi county, Baoding, Hebei, a complex of 14 tombs including the Yongzheng Emperor’s Tailing, the Jiaqing Emperor’s Changling, the Daoguang Emperor’s Muling and the Guangxu Emperor’s Chongling. Empress Longyu, who died in 1913, was buried with him at Chongling.⁠[33][31]

The Underground Palace of Chongling Robbed

The underground palace of Chongling was robbed.⁠[31][33]

The Coffins Cleared

The authorities cleared and resealed the coffins at Chongling, and some of the emperor’s hair, bones and clothing were removed.⁠[31]

The Western Qing Tombs Inscribed on the World Heritage List

The Western Qing Tombs, listed by the State Council in 1961 among the first group of major historical sites under national protection, were inscribed on the World Heritage List by the 24th session of the World Heritage Committee in November 2000.⁠[33]

Research into the Cause of Death Begins

A proposal was made to solve the mystery of the emperor’s death by methods quite different from the study of documents. The work involved the CCTV Qing history documentary crew, the Qing Western Tombs cultural relics office, the reactor engineering institute of the China Institute of Atomic Energy and the forensic centre of the Beijing police; from this year the researchers collected evidence at the tomb, taking samples without opening the casket. In 2006 the team took residue from his hair, bones and clothing for analysis.⁠[31][34][35]

Report on the Cause of Death Announced

The National Qing History Compilation Committee held a meeting in Beijing to present the report on the cause of the emperor’s death and announced that he had died of acute arsenic poisoning (by another account the meeting was held on November 3). The highest arsenic level in segments of his hair was far above that of modern samples, 261 times that of Empress Longyu, 132 times that of a Qing fodder official and 66 times that of a modern patient with chronic arsenic poisoning; high arsenic was also found in his bones; three of his better-preserved jackets had holes eaten through at the stomach, which the researchers attributed to poison corroding outward as the body decayed. The researchers identified the arsenic as arsenic trioxide; the residue from the hair and the inner clothing alone contained about 201.5 milligrams, a lethal amount, and the study ruled out medicine and environmental contamination as the source.⁠[36][35][31][32]

The report, signed by Zhong Liman, Geng Zuoche, Li Jun, Xing Hongwei, Wang Ke, Zhang Yongbao, Zou Shuyun, Xia Pu, Li Yiguo, Zhang Xinwei, Zhang Daming, Song Chaojin and Pan Guanmin, appeared as a result of a special research project of the National Qing History Project in issue 4 of Qing History Journal, published on November 15, 2008; the same issue carried Zhong Liman’s study of the type and date of the arsenic poisoning and Dai Yi’s “The Death of Guangxu”.⁠[34]

Zhu Chengru, deputy director of the National Committee for the Compilation of Qing History, said he had touched the emperor’s bones wearing gloves; he held that the empress dowager was certainly the mastermind, since those who administered the poison were all her cronies and no outsider could have entered the palace. One expert called the project a successful attempt to solve a historical problem with modern science, combining the methods of the natural sciences with the traditional methods of the social sciences.⁠[32][37][31]

Jin Yuzhang, a great-nephew of the emperor and nephew of Puyi, believes Cixi murdered the emperor to halt his reforms. He said the emperor wanted to change the country for the better and in the end sacrificed his life for the sake of national unity and social progress; but he does not think the death changed the course of Chinese history, since the Qing dynasty was already at its end and, had the reforms succeeded, it might have lasted only a few years longer.⁠[32]

Topic: Disputes over the Cause of Death

After his death it was long said that he had been poisoned; some named Yuan Shikai or Li Lianying as the culprit, but most pointed to the empress dowager. As early as 1904 Wu Tingfang, vice-minister of foreign affairs, told the Japanese minister Uchida Kosai that “Guangxu will die before Cixi.” Yun Yuding, who long attended the emperor, recorded in his Chongling Chuanxin Lu that when the empress dowager had been suffering from diarrhoea for several days, someone slandered the emperor by saying he had looked pleased at the news, and she said angrily: “I cannot die before you.”⁠[31]

In the 1980s historians, archivists and physicians studied his medical records and prescriptions together and concluded that he had been weak all his life and died of an illness that would not yield to treatment. Others have pointed out that the records cannot be taken at face value, since the court physicians could not question the emperor directly and his symptoms were described for him by the empress dowager.⁠[31][36]

The 2008 report did not identify who ordered the killing, though suspicion has long fallen on Cixi. One explanation is that she feared that if he outlived her he would restart his reforms and undo her work. It has been argued that without Cixi’s instigation and authorization no one would have dared or been able to kill the emperor: fearing that she would die first and that he would return to power and overturn everything, she spread word that he was gravely ill in the hope that he would die first, but when she herself fell seriously ill she had trusted followers poison him before her death. Others have argued that Cixi probably gave the order but that the identity of the principal culprit still needs further research. As to who administered the poison, there are five main suspects, among them her favourite eunuch Li Lianying.⁠[2][32][5][36]

In 2023 other researchers argued from newly examined material that he died of illness. A twelve-page letter addressed to “Bojiong” in an album of letters of modern figures held by the ancient books department of the National Library of China was, by comparison of handwriting, written by Wu Shijian, then serving in the Southern Study and a reader of the Hanlin Academy, to his friend and fellow townsman Shao Zhang (courtesy name Bojiong). Written on the 30th day of the tenth lunar month of the 34th year of Guangxu (November 23, 1908), the tenth day after the emperor’s death, it says that on the afternoon of the 21st the court physicians, having taken his pulse, said that His Majesty’s pulse had ceased and that the empress dowager too was gravely ill, and that the emperor died at three minutes past the second quarter of the hour of you zheng (about 6:33 p.m.). The researchers judged the letter highly credible and held that the view that the emperor died of illness comes closer to the historical truth.⁠[39]

Topic: Medical Records and Health

His medical records show that he was already frail at fifteen or sixteen, began at twenty-seven or twenty-eight to suffer from ringing in the ears and noises in the head that grew steadily worse, and long suffered from seminal emission. By one account he was melancholy from childhood and was left with ailments that could not be cured.⁠[31][1]

Topic: Surviving Images

Accounts of photographs of him and Consort Zhen differ: by one, all her photographs in the palace were destroyed, the Palace Museum keeps a single portrait photograph of her and no image of the emperor survives; by another, no photograph can yet be confirmed as hers.⁠[13][14]

In a photograph often said to show him in his teens, the seated man is Yixuan, Prince Chun, and a boy stands beside him with his hands at his sides. It has been argued that the photograph was taken in 1888 and that the boy cannot be the emperor and can only be his younger brother Zaifeng; others agree that the boy is not the emperor but find that his age does not fit Zaifeng either, so his identity awaits further evidence.⁠[4][14]

Tsar Nicholas II and the tsarina had their minister in China present the emperor with an eight-inch hand-coloured family photograph; the emperor asked the minister’s wife many questions about the tsar and tsarina and asked her to convey his thanks for the tsar’s kindness.⁠[13]

Topic: Assessments

It has been argued that his reign was marked by progressive national humiliations and that the overriding influence in his tragic life was the Empress Dowager Cixi. Of the reform he led, some have argued that its failure after a mere 103 days showed the futility of trying to save the country by reform from the top; others that, although it ended in tragedy, it introduced new ideas that facilitated the late-Qing reforms and its grim fate fired up a budding revolution, so that its influence on modern Chinese history was positive.⁠[3][23][19]

Sources39 sources

  1. 悲剧皇帝——光绪 [The tragic emperor: Guangxu] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)paper.people.com.cn↑
  2. Guangxu (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  3. Kuang-hsü (opens in a new window)encyclopedia.com↑
  4. 李文杰:“太上皇”的烦恼——醇亲王奕譞的心结 [Li Wenjie: the troubles of a “retired emperor” – the inner knot of Prince Chun Yixuan] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)m.thepaper.cn↑
  5. 戴逸:光绪之死 [Dai Yi: The death of Guangxu] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  6. Cixi (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  7. Eminent Chinese of the Ch'ing Period/Tsai-ch'un (opens in a new window)en.wikisource.org↑
  8. 翁同龢 [Weng Tonghe] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)changshu.gov.cn↑
  9. 翁同龢 [Weng Tonghe] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)dpm.org.cn↑
  10. Eminent Chinese of the Ch'ing Period/Wu K'o-tu (opens in a new window)en.wikisource.org↑
  11. Corpse Admonition: Wu Kedu and Bureaucratic Protest in Late Qing China (opens in a new window)cambridge.org↑
  12. 女性的权力与艺术:考察慈禧居室空间的内檐装修 [Women's Power and Art: The Interior Fittings of Cixi's Living Quarters] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  13. 读图|紫禁城里的摄影术 [Reading pictures: photography in the Forbidden City] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)m.thepaper.cn↑
  14. 讲座|徐家宁:光绪与珍妃传世照片辨伪 [Lecture: Xu Jianing on identifying forged photographs of Guangxu and Consort Zhen] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  15. 《大故宫》新出纪念版:再读延禧水宫及翠玉白菜 [New commemorative edition of “The Great Palace Museum”: rereading the Yanxi water palace and the jadeite cabbage] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  16. 甲午祭︱挑事儿的日本如何获得西方舆论青睐 [Remembering 1894: how the provocateur Japan won the favour of Western opinion] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)m.thepaper.cn↑
  17. Outbreak of the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-1895 (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
  18. Treaty of Shimonoseki (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  19. The Hundred Days’ Reform: an Overview (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  20. (2) Emperor Guangxu Endorsed the Reform (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  21. 茅海建:“公车上书”考证补 [Mao Haijian: Further research on the “Public Vehicle Petition”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  22. 变法高潮与“百日维新” [The climax of reform and the “Hundred Days”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  23. (3) The Wuxu Coup Confirmed Qing China as a Lost Cause (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  24. 张元济 纵我活不到一百岁,及身已见太平来(1) [Zhang Yuanji: “Even if I do not live to a hundred, I have lived to see peace come” (1)] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)bjnews.com.cn↑
  25. 梁启超与他的时代 | 维新:愿替众生病 (1873—1898) [Liang Qichao and his times | Reform: willing to be ill in place of all beings (1873–1898)] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  26. 王中江:何以救世:严复的苦恼 [Wang Zhongjiang: How to save the world: Yan Fu's distress] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  27. 袁世凯“有密未告” [Yuan Shikai “kept a secret untold”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)epaper.gmw.cn↑
  28. 戊戌政变之真相 [The truth about the 1898 coup] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)qsyj.ruc.edu.cn↑
  29. (4) The Boxer Protocol and its Aftermath (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  30. 中美浮梦录|王朝的暮影:老佛爷到白宫 [Floating dreams of China and America: the dynasty’s twilight – from the Old Buddha to the White House] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)m.thepaper.cn↑
  31. 谁毒死了光绪皇帝 [Who poisoned the Guangxu Emperor?] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)paper.people.com.cn↑
  32. Who Murdered China's Emperor 100 Years Ago? (opens in a new window)npr.org↑
  33. 清西陵,末代帝王陵 [The Western Qing Tombs, mausoleums of the last emperors] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)visitbeijing.com.cn↑
  34. 国家清史纂修工程重大学术问题研究专项课题成果:清光绪帝死因研究工作报告 [Report on the research into the cause of death of the Guangxu Emperor of the Qing (result of a special project of the National Qing History Project)] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)qsyj.ruc.edu.cn↑
  35. China's reformist emperor died of poison (opens in a new window)dawn.com↑
  36. 一桩百年疑案的现代解读 [A modern reading of a century-old mystery] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)digitalpaper.stdaily.com↑
  37. 故宫讲坛第五十讲“光绪皇帝死因研究” [Palace Museum Lecture Series No. 50: “Research on the Cause of Death of the Guangxu Emperor”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)dpm.org.cn↑
  38. The Abortive American-Chinese Project for Chinese Revolution, 1908-1911 (opens in a new window)militarymuseum.org↑
  39. 疑案再探:吴士鉴密信所见光绪、慈禧病逝之内情 [A mystery re-examined: the deaths of Guangxu and Cixi as seen in a secret letter of Wu Shijian] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑