ABAB Pedia

Self-Strengthening Movement

The Self-Strengthening Movement (also called the Foreign Affairs Movement) was a reform effort of the Qing dynasty from the 1860s to the mid-1890s, usually dated 1861–1895, that adopted Western military technology, industry and education. It was led by Prince Gong and Wenxiang in Beijing and by provincial leaders such as Zeng GuofanZeng GuofanZeng Guofan (1811–1872) was an official, military commander and Neo-Confucian scholar of the late Qing dynasty, the founder and commander of the Xiang (Hunan) Army. He led that army against the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom for more than a decade, then governed the Liangjiang provinces and Zhili and helped to begin the self-strengthening projects that brought Western machinery and technology to China.Open the full entry, Li HongzhangLi HongzhangLi Hongzhang (1823–1901) was a Chinese statesman, military commander and diplomat of the late Qing dynasty, the founder and commander of the Huai Army and one of the principal promoters of the Self-Strengthening Movement. From 1870 he served for many years as governor-general of Zhili and superintendent of trade for the northern ports, sponsored modern enterprises such as the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company, the Kaiping mines, railways, telegraphs and the Beiyang Fleet, and signed treaties including the Treaty of Shimonoseki and the Boxer Protocol for the Qing government; judgments of him, in his lifetime and since, have been sharply divided.Open the full entry, Zuo ZongtangZuo ZongtangZuo Zongtang (1812–1885) was a statesman and military commander of the late Qing dynasty. Holding only the provincial degree, he joined the staff of the governor of Hunan, raised the Chu Army against the Taiping Rebellion and served as governor of Zhejiang and governor-general of Fujian and Zhejiang, of Shaanxi and Gansu and of Liangjiang, rising to grand secretary and grand councillor; from 1875 he directed the campaign in Xinjiang that defeated Yakub Beg, after which Xinjiang was made a province.Open the full entry and Zhang ZhidongZhang ZhidongZhang Zhidong (1837–1909) was an official, scholar and educator of the late Qing dynasty and one of the leading figures of the Self-Strengthening movement. He served as governor of Shanxi and as governor-general of Guangdong and Guangxi and of Hubei and Hunan, founded iron and steel, arms and textile enterprises and modern schools in Hubei, wrote the Quanxue pian (Exhortation to Learning) in 1898, and in his last years was a grand councillor and grand secretary in Beijing.Open the full entry, and as a whole it came to an end after China’s defeat in the First Sino-Japanese WarFirst Sino-Japanese WarThe First Sino-Japanese War was fought between Qing China and Japan in 1894–1895, chiefly over Korea. Fighting broke out in Korea in July 1894 and both countries declared war on August 1; Chinese forces were defeated on land and at sea, Japanese armies invaded north-eastern China and the Shandong Peninsula, and the Beiyang Fleet was destroyed at Weihaiwei. The Treaty of Shimonoseki of April 1895 obliged China to recognize the independence of Korea, cede the Liaodong Peninsula, Taiwan and the Pescadores and pay a large indemnity; the Liaodong Peninsula was returned to China after the Triple Intervention, and resistance in Taiwan continued until November 1895.Open the full entry of 1894–95.

Contents29 sections
Key facts

Background

The movement arose after the two Opium Wars (1839–1842 and 1856–1860) and internal rebellions such as that of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom (1851–1864); in 1860 British and French troops entered Beijing and burned the Summer Palace. The same years saw the Nian Rebellion (1853–1868), the Tungan Rebellion in the northwest (1862–1878) and the Muslim Rebellion in Yunnan (1863–1877).⁠[1]

Qing cooperation with Westerners in suppressing the Taiping rebellion also helped to inspire the movement.⁠[2]

The Zongli Yamen Is Established

In response to the settlement of foreign representatives in the capital, the Qing court opened the Zongli Yamen (Office for General Management of Foreign Affairs) in 1861 to handle foreign affairs, under the control of Prince Gong (Yixin).⁠[3][1]

It has been noted that 1861, the year the Zongli Yamen was set up, is regarded as the year the movement began.⁠[4]

The Anqing Arsenal

Zeng Guofan founded the Anqing Arsenal in 1861; it has been described as China’s earliest arsenal.⁠[5]

In 1862 Zeng Guofan summoned Xu Shou to the arsenal at Anqing. Within a few months Xu and his second son, Xu Jianyin, had built a model steam engine; after it was tested successfully at the governor-general's office, Zeng wrote in his diary that day that he was secretly glad that what the foreigners' ingenuity could do, Chinese could do too, and that they could no longer look down on China for what it did not know. Three years later Xu Shou and Hua Hengfang completed a powered wooden steamboat, more than fifty chi long and able to travel more than forty li an hour, which was named the Huanghu.⁠[6]

The Tongwen Guan Is Founded

Prince Gong (Yixin) founded the Tongwen Guan (School of Combined Learning) in Beijing. It began as a language school to train the children of bannermen in foreign languages, and some Western sciences were later added to its curriculum. In 1863 a foreign language school was also founded in Shanghai; Shanghai’s language schools also included the Foreign Languages College (Guangfangyanguan).⁠[7][8][3][1]

Training talent was a key task of the movement: besides the language schools, the translation bureau of the Jiangnan Arsenal translated books of more than 100 kinds within a few years, an academy for naval administration was set up at Mawei, a naval academy, a military academy and a medical academy were set up in Tianjin, and Qing subjects were sent to Britain, France, Germany and other countries to learn Western naval and infantry arms and tactics.⁠[7]

The Tongwen Guan existed from 1862 to 1902; in 1865 it was decided to add a science department, admitting students well grounded in Chinese, which raised the school to university level. By one account the Tongzhi EmperorTongzhi EmperorThe Tongzhi Emperor (1856–1875), personal name Zaichun, was the eighth emperor of the Qing dynasty and the son of the Xianfeng Emperor and Empress Dowager Cixi. He reigned from 1861 to 1875 under the reign title Tongzhi; his temple name is Muzong.Open the full entry, as the school’s final approving authority, specially granted thirty per cent of customs revenue to fund it. It has been argued that the Tongwen Guan and the two other Tongwen schools raised the curtain on the Self-Strengthening Movement and marked the beginning of modern education in China.⁠[8]

Li Hongzhang Forms the Huai Army

Li Hongzhang formed the Huai Army in 1862. With Western-style training and weapons it became a strong infantry force; it was also a basis of Li Hongzhang’s political power until its defeat and collapse in the First Sino-Japanese War of 1894–95.⁠[9][3]

The Jiangnan Arsenal and the Jinling Arsenal

The Jiangnan Arsenal was formally established in 1865; it has been described as the most impressive modern arms factory in China at the time. In the summer of 1865 Li Hongzhang, as Jiangsu governor, and Ding RichangDing RichangDing Richang (died 1882), a native of Fengshun in Guangdong, governed Jiangsu and Fujian and collected rare books. He helped establish the Jiangnan Arsenal, supported Yung Wing’s plans for overseas education and initiated the construction of telegraph lines in southern Taiwan.Open the full entry, as Shanghai customs intendant, rented a machine shop in the Hongkou district of Shanghai; the arsenal began as Thomas Hunt and Company, an American iron firm in Hongkou, merged with two Qing cannon factories, and Yung WingYung WingYung Wing (1828–1912) was a Chinese educator and diplomat of the late Qing period who graduated from Yale University in 1854 and is described as the first Chinese student to graduate from an American university. He proposed and led the Chinese Educational Mission, which brought 120 Chinese boys to study in the United States from 1872 to 1881, served as the Qing associate minister to the United States, Spain and Peru, and wrote the memoir My Life in China and America (1909).Open the full entry bought more than 100 machines for it in New York. In 1867 the original site proved too small and costly, and the arsenal moved to Gaochang Temple in southern Shanghai.⁠[10][11][3]

In August 1868 the arsenal completed its first ship, the Tianji (later renamed Huiji). On September 15 that year the Tianji sounded its whistle and set out from the dock at Gaochang Temple; on September 28 it sailed to Nanjing, where Zeng Guofan, governor-general of Liangjiang, went aboard for a trial run to Caishiji. Eleven ships were built at the arsenal in eight years, and a ship built there cost about twice the price of one imported directly from Britain. By 1891 the complex covered 246,000 square meters.⁠[10][12][11]

In 1867 Xu Shou and Hua Hengfang came to work at the Jiangnan Arsenal. The arsenal’s translation work began in 1867: from 1867 to the first half of 1868 Xu Shou, Hua Hengfang and others translated, with the Englishman John Fryer and the American Jin Kaili, four Western books closely tied to machine building, and Zeng Guofan, delighted when he read them, memorialized for a translation office. In 1868 the office formally opened, with Xu Shou in charge, Fryer and Jin Kaili as oral translators and Xu Shou, Hua Hengfang and Wang Dejun as writers. The office was the creation of Hua Hengfang and Xu Shou, with Xu Shou’s son Xu Jianyin also involved, and its foreign translators also included Alexander Wylie. By 1909 the office had published more than 180 books, and it has been described as the largest and most influential translation publisher in modern China. After Fryer left in 1896 its oral translators changed frequently and, with many returned students taking up translation, the office gradually declined as a translator of books.⁠[13][10][11]

After the founding of the People’s Republic of China the Jiangnan Arsenal was renamed the Jiangnan Shipyard; in 2008, on its 143rd anniversary, the shipyard moved to Changxing Island in northeastern Shanghai.⁠[10]

The Jinling Arsenal in Nanjing, also founded in 1865, was later renamed the Jinling Ordnance Factory and, after the founding of the People’s Republic of China, the Nanjing Chenguang Machinery Factory; in 2007 the Chenguang 1865 Creative Industry Park was set up on the site, and in 2018 the Jinling Arsenal was recognised as a national industrial heritage site. Li Hongzhang established Western-style arsenals in Nanjing and Shanghai and another arsenal at Tianjin.⁠[14][15]

Missions Abroad

At the end of 1865 the Zongli Yamen asked the throne to send officials abroad to observe conditions there. On February 20, 1866, Prince Gong (Yixin), acting on a suggestion of the Inspector General of Customs, the Englishman Robert HartSir Robert HartSir Robert Hart (1835–1911), born in Portadown in County Armagh, directed the Chinese Imperial Maritime Customs for much of the late Qing period. He oversaw revenue collection, postal services and statistical reporting, advised the Qing on diplomacy and left journals, correspondence and photographs documenting his work in China.Open the full entry, memorialized for a party under Binchun to go to Europe and observe the countries directly; the party returned to Beijing on November 13, 1866. Wenxiang, a Grand Councillor who ran the Zongli Yamen together with Yixin, also argued strongly for sending envoys abroad.⁠[16]

In January 1868 a mission led by Anson Burlingame with Zhigang and Sun Jiagu set out, returning to Beijing in November 1870, nearly three years later.⁠[16]

Zuo Zongtang Founds the Fuzhou Navy Yard

In 1866 Zuo Zongtang memorialized for a modern shipyard, writing: “In my humble view, to ward off harm from the sea and reap its benefits, the navy must be put in order; and to put the navy in order, a yard must be set up to build steamships.” He bought 100 mu of farmland at the foot of Mawei Hill in Fuzhou as the site, engaged two Frenchmen, Prosper Giquel and Dekebei (the Chinese form of his name), as director and deputy director, and founded the Mawei (Fuzhou) Navy Yard, together with the Qiushitang school (later the Navy Yard School) to train Chinese shipbuilders and navigators.⁠[17][11]

Soon afterwards Zuo was transferred to be governor-general of Shaanxi and Gansu and recommended Shen Baozhen, long held in high esteem, to take charge of the navy yard; he said that though he had gone west his heart still looked east, and he kept following the yard’s construction. The Mawei yard has been described as China’s first truly modern shipyard. More than 30 ships were built there after its establishment.⁠[17][9]

The Dispute over Astronomy and Mathematics at the Tongwen Guan

Yixin and others memorialized that men from the regular examination track should be admitted to the Tongwen Guan to study physics, chemistry, astronomy and mathematics, so as to raise the standing of natural science. The censor Zhang Shengzao objected first, arguing that for self-strengthening the court should rather “put discipline in order”, “clarify government and punishment” and “make rewards and punishments strict”. Then Woren, Grand Secretary of the Wenyuan Hall in charge of the Board of Revenue, memorialized that “the way to found a state lies in propriety and righteousness, not in stratagems; the fundamental plan lies in people’s hearts, not in techniques”.⁠[18]

In the end Yixin and his colleagues pressed their case by asking to be “relieved of their duties at the Zongli Yamen”. On June 30, 1867, the court issued an edict that sharply criticized Woren and his allies while asking Woren to “consult in harmony” with the ministers of the Zongli Yamen and “together overcome the difficulties of the time”, and the dispute ended. It has been argued that at bottom the dispute was about whether Western natural science was universal.⁠[18]

Boys Sent to Study in the United States

At Yung Wing’s proposal the Qing government sent 120 boys in four groups to study in the United StatesUnited StatesThe United States is a federal country in North America made up of 50 states, the District of Columbia as the seat of government, and territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam; its capital is Washington, D.C. The Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776. The 2020 census (April 1, 2020) counted a resident population of 331,449,281, and the 435 seats of the House of Representatives are apportioned among the states on the basis of the census.Open the full entry between 1872 and 1875 — the Chinese Educational MissionChinese Educational MissionThe Chinese Educational Mission was the Qing government programme and office that sent boys to study in the United States from 1872 to 1881. Proposed by Yung Wing and approved on the memorials of Zeng Guofan and Li Hongzhang, with Chen Lanbin and Yung Wing as commissioners, it sent 120 boys in four detachments between 1872 and 1875 to live and study in New England, with headquarters in Hartford, Connecticut, until the whole mission was recalled in 1881; among its students were Zhan Tianyou, Tang Shaoyi, Liang Dunyan, Liang Cheng and Tang Guoan, who later became known in railways, diplomacy and education.Open the full entry, an early initiative of the Self-Strengthening Movement. In 1881 the entire mission was recalled to China, well short of the fifteen years originally planned.⁠[7][19][15]

The China Merchants Steam Navigation Company

Li Hongzhang established the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company in 1872 to win back for China a share of the steam-shipping profits that foreign firms had held since the early 1860s; it was the first of several officially supervised, merchant-managed enterprises set up by Qing officials. The company was officially established in Shanghai in January 1873, with 100,000 taels of government shares and 250,000 taels of merchant shares, of which Zhu Qi’ang and his brother each held 100,000 taels and Li Hongzhang himself 50,000. Zhu Qi’ang, a leading Shanghai merchant in the junk trade, was an associate director of the company.⁠[20][21][22]

In 1877 the company bought the fleet of the failing American Shanghai Steam Navigation Company; buying all its steamers, warehouses and other assets cost 2.22 million taels. From 1885 Sheng XuanhuaiSheng XuanhuaiSheng Xuanhuai (1844–1916) was a Chinese official and industrialist of the late Qing dynasty who for many years served as Li Hongzhang’s chief economic deputy. He ran the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company, the telegraph administration, the Huasheng cotton mill, the Hanyang Ironworks and Hanyeping Company, the Railway Corporation and the Imperial Bank of China, and founded Peiyang University and Nanyang Public School. As minister of posts and communications in 1911 he pursued railway nationalization, which set off the Railway Protection Movement; dismissed after the Wuchang Uprising, he went into exile in Japan for a time and died in Shanghai in 1916. His vast personal archive is held by Shanghai Library.Open the full entry was its director-general and the merchant managers lost much of their autonomy; by 1893 Sheng had taken control of the company. In 1911 it severed its official ties and became a private concern; in 1935 the Nanjing government nationalized it as the National China Merchants Company; after 1949 its mainland branches were merged into the state shipping company of the People’s Republic of China, while the Hong Kong branch stayed in business. It has been judged that the company did not grow at the same rate as its British and Japanese rivals.⁠[20][23][22]

From Arms Making to Merchant-Managed Enterprises

In the first period of modern industrial development (1861–72) the effort went into firearms and machines, the most important enterprises being the Jiangnan Arsenal in Shanghai, the Tianjin Machine Factory and the Fuzhou Navy Yard; in the second period (1872–94) the weight shifted from the weapons industry to a wider field of manufacture, with the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company and the Kaiping coal mines as leading enterprises, mostly run by the government-supervised, merchant-managed method.⁠[3]

Realising that the treasury alone could not pay for new armaments, the self-strengtheners turned to civilian industry in the movement’s later phase, with wealth building as the guiding principle. Under the government-supervised, merchant-managed model merchants supplied capital for shares and the government assigned officials to supervise operations, also holding shares in some enterprises. The model was popular in the 1870s and 1880s; from the 1890s it gradually fell out of favour and was replaced by wholly private enterprises.⁠[21]

The First Resident Envoys Abroad

The Kaiping Mining Bureau

The Kaiping Coal Mining Bureau was established in Zhili in 1878 and began operating three years later. In 1881 the Tangshan–Xugezhuang Railway began operating; it has been described as the first railway built by the Chinese in China.⁠[21]

The Shanghai Machinery Weaving Bureau

The Shanghai Machinery Weaving Bureau was established in 1879 and offered shares to the public, of which 2,000 had been sold and 2,000 were still available. In 1891 the New Huaxin Textile Bureau, a joint government-merchant venture, began operating in Shanghai; it was later renamed the New Hengfeng Textile Bureau. Sheng Xuanhuai later reorganized the Huasheng Spinning and Weaving Company, which has been called the first successful cotton mill in China.⁠[21][23][24]

The Tianjin Telegraph Headquarters

In the 1860s the provincial officials had firmly argued against telegraph and railway construction. Later, telegraph lines were trialled between Tianjin and the Beitang forts near Dagu; in 1880 the Tianjin Telegraph Headquarters was established, with seven branches elsewhere. The telegraph administration under Sheng Xuanhuai later laid over 14,000 miles of line.⁠[3][21][23]

The Lanzhou Woollen Mill Begins Operation

The Lanzhou machine woollen mill founded by Zuo Zongtang began operation. Zuo had commissioned Hu Xueyan to buy more than 1,200 pieces of machinery from German merchants in Shanghai, which took a year to reach Lanzhou; he also engaged more than ten craftsmen from Germany and chose apprentices from the militiamen of Shaanxi and Gansu, training Gansu’s first industrial workers. It has been described as China’s first wool textile mill.⁠[25][21]

The Battle of Mawei

During the Sino-French War the eleven Chinese ships at Mawei were all at least nine years old and made of wood, and the Fuzhou fleet was almost completely destroyed in fifteen minutes. The Fuzhou Navy Yard thereafter declined and was destroyed in 1884 during the war.⁠[11][3]

The Board of Naval Affairs

The Board of Naval Affairs was established in 1885, and construction of the major naval ports at Lushun and Weihaiwei began the following year. By then China had four modernised fleets — the Beiyang, Nanyang, Fujian and Guangdong fleets — supplied partly with imported warships; the Beiyang Fleet patrolled the Yellow Sea and Bohai north of Jiangsu, and the Nanyang Fleet the coasts of Jiangsu and Zhejiang. Naval academies were founded in Tianjin, Weihai, Nanyang and Lushun.⁠[9]

After 1885 the Beiyang Fleet rose to be China’s chief fleet; the new Navy Board and Li Hongzhang’s Beiyang Fleet competed for financial resources, which declined with further naval budget cuts between 1885 and 1894.⁠[11]

The Beiyang Fleet Is Formally Established

The Regulations of the Beiyang Navy were approved and promulgated, marking the formal establishment of the Beiyang Fleet with more than 4,000 men and 25 warships; by the ranking of the United States naval yearbook of the time it was the strongest fleet in Asia and the ninth in the world. Its principal ironclads, the Dingyuan and the Zhenyuan, were designed and built by the German Vulcan yard. By 1894 the Beiyang Fleet more or less equalled Japan’s entire fleet.⁠[26][11]

The Beiyang Fleet was formed under Governor-General Li Hongzhang.⁠[27]

Zhang Zhidong’s Hanyang Ironworks in Hubei

Zhang Zhidong began preparing an ironworks in 1884, when he became governor-general of Guangdong and Guangxi; transferred in 1889 to Hunan and Hubei, where he remained for 18 years, he sited the works at Hanyang. Construction of the Hanyang ironworks began in 1891 and production in 1894; it has been called the first government-operated steel works of early modern China and the largest of its kind in Asia. Only three years passed from the memorial proposing it to production; less than a year after production began the First Sino-Japanese War broke out, and the court had no more funds to spare for it.⁠[28][29][21]

The Daye Iron Mine was founded in Hubei in 1890, and between 1893 and 1894 factories for weaving, spinning, silk reeling and jute were set up in Wuchang. Zhang Zhidong also founded a mint, tanneries, tile and silk factories and paper, cotton and woollen mills in his jurisdiction, and schools, newspapers and translation bureaus were established in Hubei.⁠[21][29]

Facing bankruptcy, the ironworks was handed over to Sheng Xuanhuai in 1896 on Zhang Zhidong’s memorial; in 1908 the Hanyang ironworks, the Daye iron mine and the Pingxiang coal mine were merged and reorganized as the Hanyeping Coal and Iron Company.⁠[28][23]

The First Sino-Japanese War

The great naval battle of the Yellow Sea began on September 17, 1894, with twelve ships on each side, Japan having a decided advantage in the speed of its ships and the weight of fire in a sustained exchange of salvos. Li Hongzhang had tried to avoid the war, but his influence nonetheless suffered because of it.⁠[11][15]

On April 17, 1895, the Treaty of Shimonoseki was signed: China ceded the Liaodong Peninsula, Taiwan and the Pescadores and agreed to pay Japan a large indemnity; the Qing government had appointed Li Hongzhang as its plenipotentiary for the peace talks.⁠[30]

It has been argued that the war was a general test of the thirty-year Self-Strengthening Movement, and that it showed the aims of self-strengthening and wealth building to be far from achieved.⁠[31]

Yan FuYan FuYan Fu (1854–1921) was a translator, thinker and educator of the late Qing and early Republican period. Trained at the Fuzhou Navy Yard School and the Royal Naval College at Greenwich, he served for many years at the Beiyang Naval Academy in Tianjin; his translations of Thomas Henry Huxley, Adam Smith, John Stuart Mill and others, above all the Tianyan lun, introduced Western thought to China, and he set out faithfulness, comprehensibility and elegance as the standards of translation. In 1912 he became the first president of Peking University, and in 1915 his name was listed among the founders of the Chouanhui.Open the full entry summed up three causes of the defeat: the Self-Strengthening Movement of the preceding thirty years had divided the West into “substance” and “application” and, failing to use the advantages of a latecomer, had not moved in time from material change to institutional change; the examination system was flawed; and the fundamental political system was flawed. He also held that the Beiyang Navy had made great mistakes of command, and he repeatedly criticized Li Hongzhang, for instance for his poor choice of men.⁠[32]

The Court Turns Civilian Industry over to Merchants

The Qing government issued an edict deciding that civilian industry should be “changed over quickly and handed to merchants to run”. Most historians have seen the end of the movement as a normal step in the renewal of Chinese society; others have argued that it was not the result of the movement’s own development and maturity but of the sudden blow of military defeat.⁠[31]

Zhang Zhidong Writes the Quanxue pian

Zhang Zhidong wrote the Quanxue pian (Exhortation to Learning), which held that “old learning is the root and new learning is for use, neither to be neglected”; its inner chapters “attend to the root, to set people’s hearts right” and its outer chapters “attend to communication, to open up the general mood”. On July 25 the Guangxu EmperorGuangxu EmperorThe Guangxu Emperor (1871–1908), personal name Zaitian, was emperor of the Qing dynasty from 1875 to 1908. A son of Yixuan, Prince Chun, and of a sister of the Empress Dowager Cixi, he was chosen by Cixi to succeed the Tongzhi Emperor. In 1898 he launched the Hundred Days’ Reform, which ended when Cixi staged a coup; he spent the rest of his life confined on Yingtai in Zhongnanhai and died in 1908. A report published in 2008 concluded that he had died of arsenic poisoning.Open the full entry, having read it closely and found its arguments fair and sound and of great benefit to learning and to people’s hearts, ordered the Grand Council to send a copy to every provincial governor and education commissioner, and the Zongli Yamen to print 300 copies for distribution.⁠[33][29]

It has been argued that the Quanxue pian systematized earlier thinking into a complete ideological blueprint of the Self-Strengthening Movement and made “Chinese learning as substance, Western learning for use” a catchphrase of the time.⁠[33]

Topic: Name and Periodisation

The movement is known in English as the Self-Strengthening Movement and also as the Foreign Affairs Movement, a literal rendering of its Chinese name, Yangwu yundong.⁠[2][11]

Its dates are given in several ways: one account gives 1861–1895; one study divides these thirty-five years into a first stage (1861–1871) centred on self-strengthening and a second (1871–1895) centred on wealth building; another division gives two periods of modern industrial development, 1861–72 and 1872–94; yet another gives three stages — the Tongzhi Restoration (1862–1874), the building of a broad industrial base (1872–1885) and the diversification of industrial capacity (1885–1895). Other studies take 1865–1895 as their span, or speak of a thirty-year movement that arose in the 1860s.⁠[2][4][3][1][11][31]

Topic: Ideas

Feng Guifen has been regarded as the movement’s ideological champion; he urged China to use the foreigners’ superior techniques to control them and called for stronger gentry leadership in local administration. In his Jiaobinlu kangyi he proposed “taking China’s moral teachings and human relations as the foundation, supplemented by the techniques of wealth and power of other nations”. It has been pointed out that these reform proposals, which did not touch the court’s core interests or basic institutions, were partly adopted by the first generation of self-strengthening officials and fully accepted by Zhang Zhidong of the second generation, who put them into the outer chapters of his Quanxue pian.⁠[2][34]

Early advocates saw no need for institutional or ideological change; after 1885 some lower officials and comprador intellectuals began to emphasize institutional reforms, a parliament and a stress on economic rather than military affairs. It has been pointed out that after the Sino-French War Guo Songtao, Cui Guoyin, Song Yuren and Chen Chi were among the scholar-officials who stressed the establishment of a parliament.⁠[2][34]

It has been argued that “Chinese learning as substance, Western learning for use” was the shared consensus of scholar-officials for a full half century, from the Self-Strengthening Movement to 1911; the slogan has also been attributed to Zhang Zhidong.⁠[34][1]

Topic: Leading Figures

Besides the arsenals in Nanjing, Shanghai and Tianjin, Li Hongzhang’s projects included a commercial steamship line, Western-built warships, a coal mine, a railroad, a telegraph line, a cotton mill, a military academy and a mint, and the sending of young Chinese to the United States to learn new skills. Sheng Xuanhuai joined Li’s staff in 1870 and became his chief economic deputy; Sheng and Zheng Guanying have been regarded as leading figures of China’s first cohort of modern entrepreneurs, and the movement has been described as their cradle.⁠[15][23][21]

Others who took part in or championed the movement included Zhang Zhidong (1837–1909) and Feng Guifen (1809–1874). It has been pointed out that Wei Yuan, Guo Songtao, Feng Guifen, Xue Fucheng, Yung Wing and other talents of the age all began their careers on officials’ private staffs.⁠[1][34]

Topic: Historians’ Assessments

One assessment holds that the movement achieved some gains, particularly in the military, but that its overall success was limited by administrative failings, financial constraints and conflicts between Chinese tradition and Western methods and technology; another holds that in its enterprises the seat of decision-making and responsibility was obscure and business was spoiled by nepotism and corruption, so that Chinese society as a whole did not change structurally before 1911. Yet another holds that it failed to revitalize the economy and retool the military, its ultimate problem being a conservative and unrealistic core premise.⁠[2][3][1]

It was argued in 1954 that the Qing failure to industrialize after the Taiping Rebellion was a major reason why China lacked modern weapons in the Sino-Japanese War. It has been contended that the imperial system and its classical ideology, labelled Confucian, were incompatible with modernization; others have held that classical learning and modernization were compatible and have traced the beginnings of China’s military industry to this period. It has also been noted that after the Taipings the Qing government compensated somewhat for the depressed rural economy by instituting two new taxes that successfully financed the arsenals and shipyards.⁠[11]

It has been argued that the naval defeat of 1894–95 refracted later Chinese and Western views of the period: the defeat convinced many Chinese that the Foreign Affairs Movement had failed and that more radical political, educational and cultural change was needed, while the earlier adaptation of new technological and scientific learning before 1895 was quickly forgotten and repressed; on this view the navy’s defeat came from fragmented command, poor coordination between the northern and southern fleets and budget cuts rather than simply from a failure of science and technology. Others have described the movement as China’s first step towards modernization.⁠[11][4]

Sources34 sources

  1. China's Self-Strengthening Movement (opens in a new window)ebsco.com↑
  2. Self-Strengthening Movement (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  3. History of China - Late Qing (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  4. 洋務運動時期における中国近代技術産業の導入と発展の研究 (一) [A study of the introduction and development of modern technological industry in China in the Westernization Movement period (1)] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kanagawa-u.repo.nii.ac.jp↑
  5. 安庆有“戏” [Anqing has opera] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)news.cn↑
  6. 徐寿为何被誉为晚清“第一巧匠” [Why Xu Shou was called the “first craftsman” of the late Qing] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  7. (2) Sending Students Abroad for Talent Cultivation (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  8. 中国近代新教育的开端——晚清同文三馆启示录 [The Beginning of Modern New Education in China: Lessons of the Three Tongwen Schools of the Late Qing] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  9. (3) Strengthening the Military via Adopting Western Arms and Tactics (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  10. Guns, ships and science (opens in a new window)globaltimes.cn↑
  11. Naval Warfare and the Refraction of China's Self-Strengthening Reforms into Scientific and Technological Failure, 1865–1895 (opens in a new window)princeton.edu↑
  12. 晚清江南制造局的财务奏销与管理 [Financial Accounting and Management of the Jiangnan Arsenal in the Late Qing] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  13. 因制造而译书:江南制造局翻译馆 [Translating Books for Manufacture: The Translation Office of the Jiangnan Arsenal] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)cssn.cn↑
  14. 晨光1865文化创意产业园——从金陵机器局到文创园区 [Chenguang 1865 Creative Industry Park: from the Jinling Arsenal to a creative park] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)news.cn↑
  15. Li Hongzhang (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  16. 辛德勇:概述清朝末年向西方各国派出外交使节的经历 [Xin Deyong: An outline of the late-Qing dispatch of diplomatic envoys to Western countries] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  17. “千秋独有左文襄”:历史上的左宗棠及其功绩 [“Zuo Wenxiang, unique through a thousand autumns”: Zuo Zongtang in history and his achievements] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)xinhuanet.com↑
  18. “西学”是怎么变为“科学”的 [How “Western learning” became “science”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)sinoss.net↑
  19. Stepping Forth into the World: The Chinese Educational Mission to the United States, 1872–81 (opens in a new window)hkupress.hku.hk↑
  20. China Merchants Steam Navigation Company (opens in a new window)encyclopedia.com↑
  21. (4) The Rise of Government-Supervised, Merchant-Managed Industries (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  22. 组织依附、双边预算约束软化与清末轮船招商局的发展 [Organizational Dependence, Softened Budget Constraints and the Development of the China Merchants Steam Navigation Company in the Late Qing] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  23. Sheng Xuanhuai (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  24. 二十世纪盛宣怀 [Sheng Xuanhuai in the twentieth century] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)sinoss.net↑
  25. 1880年9月16日 左宗棠创办的兰州机器织呢局开工 [September 16, 1880: The Lanzhou machine woollen mill founded by Zuo Zongtang begins operation] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kepuchina.cn↑
  26. 从“蚊子船”到铁甲舰 北洋海军舰船实力渐增 [From “mosquito boats” to ironclads: the growing strength of the Beiyang navy] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kankanews.com↑
  27. (4) The Modernized Naval Battle (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  28. 汉冶萍公司简史及其档案的重要意义 [A brief history of the Hanyeping Company and the importance of its archives] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)news.ifeng.com↑
  29. Zhang Zhidong (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  30. 4. Towards peace : Start of peace negotiations –Treaty of Shimonoseki and Triple Intervention (opens in a new window)jacar.go.jp↑
  31. 喻大华:甲午战争与中国近代化的巨大挫折 [Yu Dahua: The Sino-Japanese War and the great setback to China’s modernisation] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  32. 甲午祭︱用数字说话,8位学术名家的甲午镜鉴 [Jiawu memorial: eight leading scholars on the lessons of 1894, in numbers] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  33. 冯天瑜:张之洞及其《劝学篇》 [Feng Tianyu: Zhang Zhidong and his Quanxue pian] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  34. 许纪霖:在“理”与“势”之间:晚清官僚士大夫的自改革 [Xu Jilin: Between principle and circumstance: the self-reform of late-Qing scholar-officials] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑