ABAB Pedia

Jin Yuelin

Jin Yuelin (1895–1984), courtesy name Longsun, was a philosopher and logician who founded the Department of Philosophy at Tsinghua University in 1926 and wrote Logic, On Dao and Theory of Knowledge; he has been regarded as a pioneer of modern Chinese philosophy and modern logic. He was a lifelong friend of Liang SichengLiang SichengLiang Sicheng (1901–1972) was a Chinese architect, architectural historian and architectural educator, the eldest son of Liang Qichao and the husband of Lin Huiyin. With Lin Huiyin and others he carried out extensive field surveys and studies of China’s historic buildings, pioneered architectural education at Northeastern University and Tsinghua University, and after 1949 led the design of the national emblem of the People’s Republic of China and of the Monument to the People’s Heroes, while putting forward plans for preserving the old city of Beijing.Open the full entry and Lin HuiyinLin HuiyinLin Huiyin (1904–1955) was a Chinese architect, poet and writer, the wife and longtime collaborator of Liang Sicheng. With Liang Sicheng and others she surveyed China’s historic buildings in the field, helped found the architecture departments of Northeastern University and Tsinghua University, took part in designing the national emblem of the People’s Republic of China and the Monument to the People’s Heroes, and was a poet of the Crescent Moon group.Open the full entry and in his later years lived with the family of their son, Liang CongjieLiang CongjieLiang Congjie (1932–2010) was a Chinese historian, editor and environmentalist, the son of Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin, the grandson of Liang Qichao and one of the founders of the environmental organization Friends of Nature.Open the full entry.

Contents44 sections
Key facts

Born in Changsha, Hunan

Jin Yuelin was born in Changsha, Hunan, on the 20th day of the intercalary fifth month of the lunar calendar in the Guangxu reign. His family came from Zhuji in Zhejiang. By one account, his father, Jin Zhen, was a licentiate (xiucai) of the Zhuji county school who, after the fighting of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom reached Zhuji, went to Hunan to join Jin Zhaoji, a cousin of Jin Zhen’s grandfather who was magistrate of Yongding county, as a private secretary on his staff.⁠[1][2][3]

By another account his father held office in Hunan, which is why he grew up there and was regarded, by himself and by others, as a Hunanese. In his memoir he mentioned that his father was a native of Zhejiang, and added that under a law issued by the new government after the 1911 Revolution a person belonged to the place where he grew up, so that he was beyond doubt a Hunanese.⁠[4][3]

Student at the Tsinghua School

Studies Commerce at the University of Pennsylvania

Ph.D. in Political Science at Columbia University

In his memoir he called Zhang Xiruo his oldest friend; they came to know each other in the second half of 1917, when he had just transferred to Columbia University in New York.⁠[8]

Teaches at Georgetown University and Returns Home for His Mother’s Funeral

Jin taught at Georgetown University. In May 1921 he returned to China for his mother’s funeral.⁠[5]

Study in Europe

In the first half of 1922, in Britain, he came under the strong influence of Russell and Hume. He later recalled: “In the eleventh year of the Republic I was studying in London, and two books influenced me especially: Russell’s Principles of Mathematics and Hume’s Treatise.” And: “From then on I concentrated on analysis.”⁠[5]

One day in 1924 he toured Paris with his old classmate Zhang Xiruo and his American friend Qin Lilian.⁠[5]

Witness to Xu Zhimo’s Divorce in Berlin

End of 1925: Returns to China and Teaches at China University

Ending four years in Europe, Jin returned to China that winter and first taught at China University.⁠[2][5][7]

Joins Tsinghua and Founds Its Department of Philosophy

That year, when Zhao Yuanren moved to the Academia Sinica, Tsinghua invited Jin back to his alma mater to take over the teaching of logic from him. In March he was engaged to teach logic at Tsinghua, and in September, at 31, he was appointed professor of philosophy at Tsinghua University and led the founding of its Department of Philosophy. By another account he returned to Tsinghua in July 1926 and founded the department then.⁠[5][4][2][10]

At first the department had a single professor, Jin himself as chair, and a single student, Shen Youding. Shen later said that his teacher Jin Yuelin, his fellow student Tao Yumin and he himself shared the honour of founding the Tsinghua philosophy department. Up to 1932 the department had produced only three graduates in all.⁠[10][5][6]

In 1928 Feng Youlan was appointed full professor and soon succeeded Jin as chair; thereafter Jin and Feng alternated as head of the department until it was merged into the philosophy department of Peking University in the reorganisation of 1952, twenty-six years in all. In 1934 its four full professors were Feng Youlan, Jin Yuelin, Zhang Shenfu and Deng Yizhe.⁠[10][5]

From 1927 he taught logic and symbolic logic to the department’s undergraduates and, from 1930, to Tsinghua’s graduate institute of philosophy, together with courses on Western philosophy devoted to Locke, Hume and Bradley. Hu Qiaomu, a history student in 1930, later said: “I am a student of old Jin; I had a year of his teaching in formal logic.”⁠[5]

Introduced to Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin by Xu Zhimo

That year Xu Zhimo introduced Jin to Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin, and from then on he and the couple were close friends until death.⁠[11]

The same year he published the essay “On Facts.”⁠[2]

Studies Logic at Harvard University

Writes a Poem on a Landscape by Lu Xiaoman

Neighbour of the Liang Family on Beizongbu Hutong

In his memoir Jin wrote: “Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin were my closest friends,” and “From 1932 to the summer of 1937 we lived on Beizongbu Hutong; they lived in the front courtyard, the large one, and I in the back courtyard, the small one.” He also composed a joking couplet for the pair, calling Liang “a gentleman on the beam” and Lin “a beauty beneath the trees”; another account gives the second phrase as “a beauty in the woods.”⁠[8][4][6]

Apart from breakfast, which he ate at home, he took most of his lunches and dinners with the Liangs in the front courtyard. In the 1930s some friends gathered every Saturday in his small courtyard, at meetings he himself had convened. By another account, in the 1930s he was in the habit of holding a tea party at home on Sunday afternoons, attended by colleagues, friends and students; on the same account, when in town he went every afternoon at the same hour to the Liangs’ “lady’s salon” in the front courtyard for coffee, and when Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin quarrelled it was Old Jin from the back courtyard who made peace.⁠[8][4][6]

Regular guests in the Liangs’ sitting room included Zhang Xiruo, Zhou Peiyuan, Hu Shih, Li Ji, Chen Daisun, Zhu Guangqian, Jin Yuelin, Shen Congwen, Xiao Qian and Xu Zhimo. Liang ZaibingLiang ZaibingLiang Zaibing, born in 1929, is the daughter and first child of Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin and spent most of her career in international reporting at Xinhua News Agency.Open the full entry recalled that these visitors became the family’s lifelong friends, and Jin Yuelin was one of the “uncles” she knew best. In 1934 he was photographed with Wilma Fairbank, Lin Huiyin, John King Fairbank and Liang Sicheng in the Liangs’ sitting room on Beizongbu Hutong. By one account, to her and her brother Liang Congjie, “Papa Jin,” who often brought them outsize pomegranates and apples, was an indispensable member of the family.⁠[12][13][14][6]

By one account, in 1932 Jin, then 37, confessed to Lin Huiyin, then 28, a love he had long kept to himself; Lin confided her distress to her husband, and after a night’s thought Liang Sicheng said to her: “You are free. If you choose Old Jin, I wish you both happiness,” and Jin said: “It seems Sicheng truly loves you. I cannot hurt someone who truly loves you. I should withdraw.” On this account he lived next door to the couple ever after, never married, and won the trust of the Liangs and their children. Another account comes from Liang Sicheng: after Lin Huiyin’s death, when he and Lin Zhu came together, he told Lin Zhu that one day in the 1930s Lin Huiyin had told him in distress that she had fallen in love with Jin Yuelin and asked him what to do. It has also been argued that Jin was at first opposed to marriage on principle, that his admiration and love for Lin Huiyin were never confined to romance, and that he and the Liangs lived together like kin.⁠[9][4][15]

Also Teaches Symbolic Logic at Peking University

Jin also taught a course in symbolic logic at Peking University.⁠[5]

Publication of Logic

Jin’s book Logic was published in 1935, taking Principia Mathematica as its basis; by another account it was published in 1936 by the Commercial Press in its University Series. It has been argued that the book was the first systematic introduction of modern logic into China.⁠[2][5][7][10]

He Lin judged the book “the only logic textbook in the country of a new standard,” and Feng Youlan said that Jin was “the first person in China who truly understood modern logic … and the first in China to understand and introduce modern logic.” In logic circles he was honoured as “the G. E. Moore of China,” and the nickname “Logic Jin” spread widely.⁠[5]

War against Japan: Teaching at Changsha Temporary University and Southwest Associated University

After the War of Resistance against Japan broke out, Jin was a professor at the Changsha Temporary University and then in the philosophy department of the Southwest Associated University. The writer Wang Zengqi recalled that Jin taught logic, a required course for first-year students of the College of Arts at the Southwest Associated University, and that the class was large, met in a big lecture hall and filled every seat.⁠[2][5]

In 1938 he was photographed in Kunming with Liang Sicheng’s family and other professors of the university, among them Zhou Peiyuan, Chen Daisun and Wu Youxun. In his memoir he wrote that in the Southwest Associated University years both the Liangs and the Qians lived in Longtou village on the north-eastern outskirts of Kunming, and that he lived first with the Liangs and, after they left, with Qian Duansheng, also an old friend of many years.⁠[11][8]

His student Feng Qi recalled one-to-one lessons with him at the Tsinghua Institute of Humanities in Sijiaying on the outskirts of Kunming: “Mr. Jin knew Hume’s books inside out—what sentence was on which page, what important concept—and he reminded me more than once: ‘Read a few books seriously; do not skim them and ruin them!’”⁠[3]

Writing Theory of Knowledge

Jin began Theory of Knowledge in 1938; the manuscript, some six or seven hundred thousand characters long, was entirely lost while he was taking shelter from Japanese air raids, and he had to start again from the beginning, finishing only at the end of 1948. By another account, he wrote the book in the later years of the war and rewrote it word by word after the 700,000-character draft was destroyed during an air-raid alarm.⁠[5][2][3]

Zhang Dainian recalled: “In 1948 I asked Mr. Jin, ‘Have you finished your theory of knowledge?’ He replied, ‘It is finished. Now that this book is written, I can die!’”⁠[5]

Publication of On Dao

Jin published On Dao, a book on ontology, which soon after publication won a second-class award from the Ministry of Education. He himself called it “a book I am fairly satisfied with, and of course also my most distinctly metaphysical book.”⁠[2][10][5]

After the War: Head of Philosophy and Dean of the College of Arts at Tsinghua

When Tsinghua University returned to Beiping, Jin continued as professor and served as head of the Department of Philosophy and dean of the College of Arts.⁠[2][16]

Head of the Department of Philosophy at Peking University

In the nationwide reorganisation of colleges and departments, Jin moved from Tsinghua University to Peking University as professor and became the first head of the new Peking University Department of Philosophy.⁠[16][2][5]

First Chief Editor of the Philosophical Research Supplement

When the Guangming Daily launched its Philosophical Research supplement, Jin became, in addition to his other posts, its first chief editor.⁠[16][2]

Moves to the Chinese Academy of Sciences to Help Found Its Institute of Philosophy

Jin was transferred to the Chinese Academy of Sciences to help set up its Institute of Philosophy; he then served as a first-grade research fellow and deputy director of the institute and as a member of the academy’s Division of Philosophy and Social Sciences.⁠[16][2]

Elegiac Couplet for Lin Huiyin

Lin Huiyin died in Beijing on April 1, and her memorial service was held on this day at the Xianliang Temple on Jinyu Hutong. Jin’s elegiac couplet for her—“A whole being of poetry, a waterfall a thousand fathoms high; for all ages, April in the human world”—was inscribed in his name jointly with Deng Yizhe.⁠[15][17]

Mid-to-Late 1950s: Invited Four Times by Mao Zedong

Mao Zedong invited Jin four times.⁠[4]

International Conference of Philosophy in Warsaw

Jin attended the International Conference of Philosophy in Warsaw, Poland, where his speech was titled “A Freeman’s Task.”⁠[7]

Theory of Knowledge Issued for Internal Circulation

The rewritten Theory of Knowledge was first issued for internal circulation as “reference material for the critique of bourgeois academic thought.”⁠[3]

“On ‘Therefore’” and a New Edition of Logic

In 1960 he published the essay “On ‘Therefore.’” In 1961 Logic was reissued by Sanlian Bookstore in its Logic Series, and the same year he published in the Guangming Daily “After Reading Wang Renzhi’s Article: Remarks at the Third Logic Discussion Meeting of the Beijing–Tianjin Region.”⁠[2][16]

Birthday Couplet for Mao Zedong’s Seventieth

With Deng Yizhe, Jin sent Mao Zedong a couplet for his seventieth birthday: “On one person hang the rise and fall of China; entering this year he is already seventy. Walking the great road amid the world’s transformation, he rejoices that his students number nearly three billion.”⁠[4]

Completes Russell’s Philosophy

Jin completed Russell’s Philosophy, his only book after 1949.⁠[7][3]

Cultural Revolution: Riding a Flatbed Tricycle

By one account, during the Cultural Revolution Jin, by then past seventy, went about contentedly seated on a flatbed tricycle. One explanation was that Mao wanted him to see more of society; another was that the rebel faction forbade him to use an official car; his student Liu Peiyu said that Jin felt that, since he held no leadership post, he should not use an official car when going out. On the same account, on the eve of Richard NixonRichard NixonRichard Nixon (1913–1994) was an American politician who represented California in the U.S. House and Senate, served as vice president from 1953 to 1961 and was the 37th president of the United States from 1969 to 1974. His administration opened relations with China, signed strategic arms limitation agreements with the Soviet Union and ended U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War; he resigned over the Watergate scandal on August 9, 1974, the only U.S. president to do so.Open the full entry’s visit to China the Beijing municipal government banned tricycles carrying passengers, so he could ride only a flatbed tricycle meant for goods.⁠[6]

Deputy Director of the Institute of Philosophy of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences

Jin served as a first-grade research fellow and deputy director of the Institute of Philosophy of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences and as a member of the Division of Philosophy and Social Sciences.⁠[2]

Returns to “Truth in True Novels” in His Last Paper

In his last paper Jin looked back on “Truth in True Novels,” which he had published in 1937, remarking that some old matters ought to be raised again.⁠[2]

Later Years: Living with Liang Congjie’s Family

In his later years Jin lived with the family of Liang Congjie, the son of Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin. In his memoir he wrote: “My household is still a Liang–Jin household. The only difference is that I still have no descendants, while Liang Congjie has lost his elders.” And: “From 1932 to 1939 I lived with the Liangs on Beizongbu Hutong; now Liang Congjie and I live together, which is a continuation of Beizongbu Hutong.”⁠[8]

By one account, Jin, who seldom entertained, one day in his old age invited some old friends to the Beijing Hotel and, raising his glass, announced: “Today is Huiyin’s birthday,” and everyone present sighed. When a publisher asked him to write a preface to Lin Huiyin’s collected works and reporters asked for his assessment of her, he declined every request, saying: “Everything I have to say I ought to say to her herself; I cannot say it. What I have had no chance to say to her I do not wish to say, nor do I wish such words to exist.”⁠[9]

Theory of Knowledge Formally Published

Theory of Knowledge was formally published; in the 1980s the Commercial Press reprinted it together with On Dao.⁠[2][7][3]

Death in Beijing

Jin Yuelin died in Beijing at the age of 89. Liang Congjie, Liang Sicheng’s son, saw him through to the end.⁠[16][1][6]

Publication of Russell’s Philosophy

Russell’s Philosophy was published after his death; his student Feng Qi had his own students prepare it for publication.⁠[7][3]

120th-Anniversary Symposium at Tsinghua

The Symposium Commemorating the 120th Anniversary of the Birth of Mr. Jin Yuelin opened at Tsinghua University, hosted by the university and the Jin Yuelin Academic Foundation with the support of Peking University, East China Normal University, the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, the Beijing Logic Society and the Chinese Association of Logic. In his address the foundation’s president, Xing Bensi, reviewed Jin’s lifelong contributions to Chinese scholarship as philosopher, logician and educator and praised the editing and publication of the Complete Works of Jin Yuelin. The sixth Jin Yuelin Academic Award was presented at the opening ceremony, and Tsinghua took the occasion to establish the Jin Yuelin Lectures, inviting one internationally known scholar to lecture at Tsinghua each year. Many of his former students and colleagues attended the opening.⁠[18]

Publication of Tao, Nature and Man

Springer Singapore published Jin’s English-language work Tao, Nature and Man in its China Academic Library series; the copyright is held by Foreign Language Teaching and Research Publishing Co., Ltd.⁠[19]

130th-Anniversary Symposium at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences

The symposium “Li you guran,” commemorating the 130th anniversary of Jin Yuelin’s birth, was held at the Institute of Philosophy of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences; organised by the institute’s logic department, it was one of the events marking the institute’s 70th anniversary.⁠[1]

Family and Personal Life

The Jin family genealogy, the Lingquan Jin Clan Genealogy, compiled around 1945, was found after 2000 in the Shanghai Library and in Jinjia village in Zhuji; it records him under the generation entry “Han 145,” with the given name Yuelin and the courtesy name Longsun.⁠[3]

In his memoir he mentioned his second and sixth elder brothers, and wrote that he hardly ever went to Changsha and had been to Shanghai once or twice, staying at his second brother’s home but mainly with the Xu or Zhang families, relatives of Xu Zhimo. He described Li Guoqin, a fellow Hunanese who had made a fortune in the United States, as a friend he had some contact with when young, though not a close one; he once had the idea of asking Li to donate US$100,000 to buy tonics (vitamins) for the Southwest Associated University. He never married—he called himself a “bachelor”—and had no children.⁠[8][4]

As a child Liang Zaibing loved reading, and Lin Huiyin drew a cartoon to tease her about it; seeing the cartoon, Jin also wrote a comic verse in Liang Zaibing’s little notebook to tease her: “Zaibing’s face is large and round, a moon before you in broad daylight; call her several times and she does not hear—the sound has not yet reached her face.”⁠[13]

By one account, while teaching at Tsinghua he spent three days a week at the university, living in the Gongziting dormitory and taking his meals with the dining group of Ye Qisun and Chen Daisun, and the other four days at his home on Beizongbu Hutong in the city; every morning he shut his door to visitors to read and write. Because of an eye ailment he kept his cap on even in class, its peak pulled low; his glasses had thick lenses, one dark and one clear.⁠[6]

Students

Those who studied under him and became logicians or philosophers included Shen Youding, Wang Xianjun, Zhou Fucheng, Sun Daosheng, Ren Hua, Zhang Suiwu, Yin Fusheng (Yin Haiguang), Feng Qi, Wang Hao, Zhou Liquan, Tang Zhisong, Su Tianfu and Wang Yutian. Duanmu Hongliang and Li Changzhi of the philosophy department both took his courses. By one account he once argued with his student Zhou Liquan from a little after two in the afternoon until six in the evening.⁠[5][6]

By one account, in his later years he often said that he had let the people down by training three students who “could not keep up with the times”: Shen Youding, Yin Fusheng (Yin Haiguang) and Wang Hao.⁠[3]

Philosophical Views and Anecdotes

Jin once said that Feng Youlan was good at making complicated questions simple, whereas he himself was good at making simple questions complicated, and that Feng’s New Neo-Confucianism was “new bottles holding old wine,” whereas his own On Dao was “old bottles holding new wine.” In his review report on Feng Youlan’s History of Chinese Philosophy he distinguished “the history of Chinese philosophy” from “the history of philosophy in China.” In the introduction to On Dao he distinguished the attitude of epistemology from the attitude of metaphysics, holding that the judge in epistemology is the intellect while the judge in metaphysics is the whole person; his student Feng Qi considered this formulation open to question. He also suggested that there may be two kinds of philosophical minds, the abstract mind and the concrete mind, counting himself among the abstract and his students as preferring the concrete.⁠[3]

Stories circulating about him have it that at three or four he used his innate sense of logic to deduce from “friends are like money” and “money is like dung” that “friends are like dung”; at the Southwest Associated University he gave a lecture titled “The Philosophy in Dream of the Red Chamber” and concluded that the novel had little to do with philosophy; and after Ai Siqi criticised formal logic in a talk at Yanyuan, Jin remarked that Ai’s report was excellent, since every sentence in it conformed to formal logic.⁠[3]

Academic Posts and Assessments

He served as president of the Chinese Association of Logic.⁠[7]

It has been argued that his Logic, On Dao and Theory of Knowledge form a large philosophical system, that from early on he was guided in his philosophical work by the creed that logic is the essence of philosophy, and that he founded at Tsinghua a philosophical tradition that values analysis. It has also been remarked that among the general public he is known chiefly as a character in the television drama Renjian siyue tian (April in the Human World).⁠[1][18][3]

Sources19 sources

  1. “理有固然——纪念金岳霖先生诞辰130周年学术研讨会”在北京召开 [Symposium “Li you guran” marking the 130th anniversary of Jin Yuelin’s birth held in Beijing] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)cssn.cn↑
  2. 中国现代哲学与现代逻辑的开拓者——金岳霖哲学思想研究 [A pioneer of modern Chinese philosophy and modern logic: a study of Jin Yuelin’s philosophical thought] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)sinoss.net↑
  3. 读人话旧︱诸暨籍哲学家 [Reading people and recalling the past: philosophers from Zhuji] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  4. 金岳霖与邓以蛰的友谊 [The friendship of Jin Yuelin and Deng Yizhe] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  5. 金岳霖——清华大学哲学系 [Jin Yuelin and the Department of Philosophy of Tsinghua University] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)sinoss.net↑
  6. 谢志浩:雅人深致金岳霖 [Xie Zhihao: Jin Yuelin, a man of refined taste] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  7. Russell and Jin Yuelin on Facts: From the Perspective of Comparative Philosophy (opens in a new window)fh.pku.edu.cn↑
  8. 金岳霖笔下的朋友们:最亲密的是梁思成、林徽因 [The friends in Jin Yuelin’s memoir: the closest were Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinanews.com.cn↑
  9. 从徐志摩到金岳霖——纪念徐志摩罹难九十周年 [From Xu Zhimo to Jin Yuelin: marking the ninetieth anniversary of Xu Zhimo’s death] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinanews.com↑
  10. Rebuilding (opens in a new window)phil.tsinghua.edu.cn↑
  11. 梁思成诞辰120年|从道义良知处,致敬先生的遗产保护观 [Liang Sicheng at 120: honouring his view of heritage protection] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  12. 京华物语丨徐志摩把“太太的客厅”视为他的第二个家 [Beijing stories: Xu Zhimo regarded “the lady’s salon” as his second home] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)bjnews.com.cn↑
  13. 梁思成林徽因女儿出回忆录 [Daughter of Liang Sicheng and Lin Huiyin publishes a memoir] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  14. “太太的客厅”与文人往事 [“The lady’s salon” and stories of men of letters] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  15. 把林徽因纳入女权的范畴讨论,只怕她自己料想不到|林徽因逝世65周年 [Discussing Lin Huiyin as a feminist is something she would hardly have expected (65th anniversary of her death)] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)jiemian.com↑
  16. 金岳霖:启《哲学》园地 倡争鸣风气 [Jin Yuelin: opening the Philosophy column and encouraging open debate] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  17. 林徽因与四月天的一生缘分 [Lin Huiyin and her lifelong bond with April] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)static.cdsb.com↑
  18. 纪念金岳霖先生诞辰120周年学术研讨会在清华举行 [Symposium marking the 120th anniversary of Jin Yuelin’s birth held at Tsinghua] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)tsinghua.edu.cn↑
  19. Tao, Nature and Man (opens in a new window)link.springer.com↑