ABAB Pedia

Duan Qirui

Duan Qirui (1865–1936), a native of Hefei, Anhui, under the Qing dynasty (now Hefei, Anhui, China) and known as “Duan of Hefei,” was a Beiyang general of the late Qing and the leader of the Anhui clique of the Beiyang government in the early Republic of China. He graduated from the Beiyang Military Academy and studied military science in Germany, headed the 1912 telegram of Beiyang generals that pressed the Qing emperor to abdicate, and served as Minister of War and several times as premier; in 1917 he defeated Zhang Xun’s restoration and declared war on Germany, with Liang QichaoLiang QichaoLiang Qichao (1873–1929) was a thinker, politician, journalist and scholar of the late Qing and early Republic, a disciple of Kang Youwei and a participant in the Hundred Days’ Reform of 1898. After the reform failed he spent 14 years in exile in Japan, where he ran the journals Qingyi Bao and Xinmin Congbao; returning in 1912, he helped to found the Progressive Party, served the Beijing government as minister of justice and minister of finance, and in 1915–1916 opposed Yuan Shikai’s attempt to make himself emperor. After leaving politics at the end of 1917 he devoted himself to writing and teaching, was a tutor at the Tsinghua Academy of Chinese Learning and director of the Beijing Library, and left the collected works known as the Yinbingshi heji.Open the full entry as finance minister in his cabinet. As Provisional Chief Executive of the Republic of China from 1924 to 1926 he presided over the government at the time of the March 18 Massacre; after stepping down he lived in Tianjin and Shanghai, where he died in 1936.

Contents27 sections
Key facts

Born in Hefei, Anhui

Duan Qirui was born on March 6, 1865, in Hefei, Anhui, under the Qing dynasty (now Hefei, Anhui, China), and was known as “Duan of Hefei.” He later led the Anhui clique, one of the factions of the Beiyang government; the faction took its name from his family’s home province of Anhui.⁠[1][2][3]

Early Years: Beiyang Military Academy and Military Studies in Germany

Duan graduated from the Beiyang Military Academy and then went to Germany to study military science, spending a year of further training at the works founded by the arms maker Krupp.⁠[4][1]

Late Qing: Training Troops under Yuan Shikai at Xiaozhan

Leads the Beiyang Generals’ Telegram That Forces the Qing Emperor to Abdicate

In early 1912, on Yuan Shikai’s instructions, Duan headed a circular telegram signed by forty-six Beiyang generals that forced the Qing emperor to abdicate, the first of what came to be called his “three restorations of the republic.” After the Republic was founded he became Minister of War in Yuan Shikai’s government. Xue Guanlan recalled that Duan served as Minister of War for a long time but that real military power lay with Yuan, which left Duan frustrated, and that his deputy, the ambitious Xu Shuzheng, was the man Yuan distrusted most.⁠[2][1][5]

May–July 1913: Acting Premier

Duan was acting premier in 1913; records of the dates differ. One gives May 1 to July 31; another has him appointed on May 1 and taking office on May 2, acting for Zhao Bingjun until July 16, and appointed acting premier again on July 19 until Xiong Xiling, who was appointed on July 31, took office on August 26.⁠[2][6]

Secretary of State and Premier after Yuan Shikai Abandons the Monarchy

In March 1916, under nationwide condemnation, Yuan Shikai was forced to abandon the monarchy and invited Duan to become premier. From April 22 to June 28 he was Secretary of State of the Political Council; other records give April 22 as the date of appointment, April 23 as the day he took office and June 30 as the end of the term. He became premier shortly before Yuan’s death and kept the post in the new government: from June 29 he was premier of the State Council under President Li YuanhongLi YuanhongLi Yuanhong (1864–1928) was a naval engineer officer and a commander of the Hubei New Army in the late Qing who became military governor of the Hubei Military Government after the Wuchang Uprising of 1911, served as vice president in the early Republic and was twice President of the Republic of China, in 1916–1917 and 1922–1923; in his last years he lived in Tianjin and invested in industry, and he died there in 1928 and was buried at Wuchang in 1935.Open the full entry (other records: appointed June 29, took office June 30). He restored the provisional constitution of 1912, which Yuan had set aside in 1913.⁠[2][6][1]

April–May 1917: The Dispute over Entering the War and Dismissal by Li Yuanhong

On April 25, 1917, Duan pressed the National Assembly to declare war on Germany, going so far as to call the provincial military governors to a meeting of the Military Governors’ Corps in Beijing. Japan groomed Duan, while Britain and the United StatesUnited StatesThe United States is a federal country in North America made up of 50 states, the District of Columbia as the seat of government, and territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam; its capital is Washington, D.C. The Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776. The 2020 census (April 1, 2020) counted a resident population of 331,449,281, and the 435 seats of the House of Representatives are apportioned among the states on the basis of the census.Open the full entry supported Li Yuanhong and Feng Guozhang. Duan then tried to force Li Yuanhong and the National Assembly to approve entry into the war, and Li dismissed him in May; his term as premier ended on May 23. Duan retaliated by ordering the provincial military governors under him to declare independence and set up a general staff office of the independent provinces in Tianjin, planning to march on Beijing.⁠[3][1][2]

The Machang Oath and the Defeat of Zhang Xun’s Restoration

After Zhang Xun restored Puyi to the throne in Beijing, Duan swore an oath at Machang near Tianjin to march against him, quickly defeated Zhang Xun and forced Puyi to “abdicate” once more, the last of his so-called three restorations of the republic. Liang Qichao backed Duan’s oath at Machang; it has been argued that Liang, together with Tang Hualong of the Research Clique and with Xu Shuzheng, quickly rallied behind Duan’s return to restore the republic. Xue Guanlan recalled that Duan raised his army against the restoration with only Li Changtai’s single division and that Zhang Xun’s queue-wearing troops scattered.⁠[2][7][8][5]

On July 14, Duan returned from Tianjin to Beijing together with Liang Qichao, took office as premier and reorganized the cabinet, appointing Wang Daxie as foreign minister. Records of the dates of this term differ: one gives July 17 to December 22; another gives his appointment on July 2, his taking office on July 5 and his discharge on November 22.⁠[7][9][2][6]

Liang Qichao Becomes Finance Minister in Duan’s Cabinet

When Duan’s new cabinet was formed, Liang Qichao was appointed Minister of Finance; he took office on July 19. Liang later explained: “After the Hongxian episode I had not meant to enter politics again, but at the time, first, Duan Zhiquan was forming a cabinet and I had to cooperate with him; second, the opportunity seemed too good, and I really did have the ambition to put the finances in order, so I went to be finance minister.” It has been argued that the Duan government’s policy of “unification by force” and its campaigns in the southwest, with their enormous military spending, drained the Beijing government’s finances and were a main reason why Liang could achieve nothing as finance minister. Liang asked to resign on November 18 and was released on November 30.⁠[7]

Declares War on Germany

After declaring war on Germany, Duan received financial and military aid from the Japanese, who helped him and his warlord allies build up the Anfu clique. Foreign influence stirred public resentment, which grew stronger after a wave of protests and demonstrations swept the country on May 4, 1919.⁠[1]

The Cabinet Resigns and Withdraws Its Resignation

On November 16 Premier Duan Qirui and his whole cabinet resigned; on November 17, after extended meetings between the cabinet and the president, the resignations were withdrawn. In his report of November 20 to the Secretary of State, Paul S. Reinsch, the American minister in Peking, said that the premier was again expected to present his resignation very shortly, and he passed on the view of one of his most experienced foreign colleagues that Duan’s authority was so shaken that his retirement could be a question only of a short time.⁠[10]

Third Term as Premier

From March 23 to October 10, 1918, Duan was premier of the State Council for the third time; other records give March 23 as the date of appointment, March 24 as the day he took office and October 10 as his discharge.⁠[2][6]

Defeat in the Zhili–Anhui War

As Duan’s popularity declined, other warlords formed a coalition against him. In 1919 the failure of the Beijing government at the Paris Peace Conference set off student protests, and the next year the Zhili warlord Cao Kun seized the moment to take up arms, starting the Zhili–Anhui War; in July 1920 the Anhui troops were utterly defeated within days, Duan attempted suicide and failed, and he withdrew from the political stage. Xue Guanlan recalled that the Anhui clique collapsed because it had lost popular support and its commander in chief was the wrong man.⁠[1][4][5]

Triangular Alliance with Sun Yat-sen and Zhang Zuolin

Xue Guanlan recalled that Duan’s ambitions survived his fall: in 1921, when members of the old parliament convened an extraordinary parliament in Guangzhou and elected Sun Yat-sen president, Sun formed a triangular alliance with Zhang Zuolin and Duan.⁠[5]

Becomes Provisional Chief Executive of the Republic of China

In the autumn of 1924 Feng Yuxiang staged the Beijing coup and, together with Zhang Zuolin, occupied Beijing and called Duan back to head the government. With the backing of Feng Yuxiang, Zhang Zuolin and other powerholders, he became Provisional Chief Executive of the Republic of China on November 24, 1924. Xue Guanlan recalled that after the Zhili clique’s arrogance led to war with the Fengtian clique, Feng Yuxiang changed sides, Cao Kun was imprisoned and Wu Peifu fled, and all parties then backed Duan as Chief Executive; Duan’s nephew Duan Honggang held the real power in the Chief Executive’s office.⁠[1][4][11][2][5]

Guo Songling’s Revolt and a Responsible Cabinet

On December 26, 1925, Duan issued three mandates: admitting that he had failed to carry out his plans for political reform and peaceful unification, he added a responsible cabinet to the system of the provisional government and said he would not oppose its measures; he abolished the Chief Executive’s supreme control and vested it jointly in the Chief Executive, the premier and the members of the cabinet; and he appointed Xu Shiying premier. In a telegram of December 28 the American minister in Peking, John Van A. MacMurray, informed the Secretary of State that the appointment was understood to have the approval of Feng Yuxiang and the Kuomintang as well as of Duan and his political associates. Soon afterwards Duan’s trusted general Xu Shuzheng was killed at Langfang by Feng Yuxiang; Xue Guanlan recalled that Duan swallowed this and still clung to office.⁠[14][4][5]

The March 18 Massacre

After the Dagu incident at Tianjin, Japan joined Britain, the United States and other powers, eight in all, in presenting Duan Qirui’s Chief Executive government on March 16, 1926, with an ultimatum demanding the removal of the defenses at Tianjin and Dagu, which aroused great public anger. On March 18 the Communist Party’s Northern Regional Committee organized more than sixty bodies, including the Beijing General Labor Union and the students’ federation, and more than eighty schools, about five thousand people in all, in a “National Assembly against the Eight-Power Ultimatum” before Tiananmen, after which they marched to Duan’s government to petition. When the column reached the gate of the State Council, soldiers and police lying in wait fired volleys and attacked with broadswords, killing 47 people on the spot and wounding more than 200; Li Dazhao and Chen Qiaonian, leaders of the party’s Northern Regional Committee, were both wounded.⁠[15]

On the day after the massacre the recently appointed premier, Jia Deyao, announced the collective resignation of the cabinet. On the third day Duan issued an order as Chief Executive granting relief to the families of the dead; in English rendering, it said that the young students had been moved by ardent patriotism and hot blood, had been carried forward by a sudden surge of indignation, that their conduct was in truth forgivable, and that he therefore ordered generous condolence payments. Of the course of the massacre and Duan’s reaction, by one account the 47 dead included two policemen and one soldier, Duan was not in the Chief Executive’s office when the marchers reached its gate but at his home in Dongchang Hutong, and it was the battalion commander of the guard who gave the order to fire; by another account Duan hurried to the scene afterwards, knelt before the dead without rising and sighed that “a lifetime’s good name is ruined in a day,” and from then on kept a vegetarian diet for the rest of his life as a sign of repentance, while the parliament resolved that “the principal culprit must await the people’s judgment.” It has been argued that whoever gave the order to fire, the government cannot escape blame, that Lu Zhonglin, who was responsible for the defense of Beijing, bears guilt, and that Duan as Chief Executive must bear full responsibility.⁠[16][17]

On March 20 the Communist Party’s Central Committee issued a message to the people of the whole country accusing Duan Qirui of massacring the people. Schools across Beijing went on strike and held memorial services for the dead; on March 23 more than ten thousand people from the Beijing General Labor Union, the National Students’ Union and schools held a memorial meeting for the martyrs of March 18 at the Third Hall of Peking University. Lu Xun called the day “the darkest day since the founding of the Republic.”⁠[15]

Steps Down

On April 10, Lu Zhonglin, who was in charge of the defense of Beijing, staged a coup and surrounded Duan’s residence; by one account he also issued a proclamation laying all responsibility for the massacre on Duan. Xue Guanlan recalled that Feng Yuxiang’s troops besieged the Chief Executive’s office and Duan barely escaped with his life, the lowest point of his prestige. In April 1926 Zhang Zuolin defeated Feng Yuxiang, and Duan was no longer needed. Facing public anger over the March 18 Massacre and pressure from the Guominjun and the Zhili clique, Duan announced his resignation by circular telegram; one account dates it to April 20, another to April 22.⁠[17][5][1][2][11]

Retirement in Tianjin

After stepping down, Duan retired to the Japanese concession in Tianjin, took the name “Lay Buddhist of the Right Path” and devoted himself to Buddhism. In 1927, through the Japanese agent Doihara Kenji, he met Puyi in Tianjin; in 1928 Wang Yitang, Duan Hongye and others of his entourage worked with Doihara in the hope of bringing him into cooperation with Japan. After the Northern Expedition entered Beijing and Tianjin in June 1928, Chiang Kai-shek, then in Beijing, wrote to Duan on July 5 about the activities of the Anfu clique in Tianjin and Dalian under Duan’s banner, and sent word through Duan Honggang: “I too was a student of the Baoding army school; Mr. Duan is my teacher.”⁠[2][11]

Xue Guanlan recalled that after his fall Duan lived quietly in the Tianjin concessions, amusing himself with go, and that Xue was a frequent guest. During the Central Plains War of 1930 Doihara Kenji sought him out again, hoping that he would come forward to unite Wu Peifu, Yan Xishan, Han Fuju and others; after representatives of Han Fuju, Duan, Yan Xishan and Wu Peifu met in Jinan in early November 1931, Doihara was in frequent contact with Duan and promised that the Japanese Okura trading house would advance five million yuan for his political activities. After the Mukden Incident of September 18, 1931, he refused to deal with the Japanese, and when the Nanjing National Government later appointed him a member of the government he did not take up the post; Japanese intelligence files record that after the incident he repeatedly attended meetings that Zhang Xueliang convened at the Shuncheng Prince’s Mansion and elsewhere. In early 1932 Nanjing put him on the list for the forthcoming National Crisis Conference, and Wang Jingwei proposed him as chairman of the North China Political Affairs Council; by the end of 1932 Doihara Kenji had met him secretly in Tianjin several times to ask him to form a North China government.⁠[5][11][2][4]

Moves South to Shanghai

On January 2, 1933, Japanese rōnin again approached Duan seeking his cooperation. On January 12 he declared, in English rendering: “Japan’s young officers are hot-blooded and bent on gain; we are being cruelly trampled, but it will bring them no good either.” On January 19 Qian Xinzhi came to Tianjin with a letter signed by Chiang Kai-shek himself, and the Bank of Communications offered to bear the cost of his journey south. On January 20 Duan left by a carriage attached to the Tianjin–Pukou express with Qian Xinzhi, his former subordinates Wu Guangxin and Wei Zonghan, his nephew Duan Honggang and others. When the party reached Pukou on the morning of the 22nd it was met by Zhu Peide, Yang Jie, Huang Musong, He Yaozu, Zhang Qun, Xu Shiying, Chen Yi and others, and Chiang Kai-shek, as his former student, came in person to the Xiaguan wharf to receive him and praised him in his diary: “The bearing and spirit of this old man are hard to find in our age.”⁠[11]

On the morning of January 24 Duan arrived in Shanghai with Wu Guangxin, Duan Honggang, Xu Shiying and others and was met by Wu Tiecheng, Li Sihao, He Qigong, Sun Fo and more than a hundred people from various organizations. He said he had come to see his second daughter, who was studying in Shanghai: “My second daughter is studying in Shanghai; I missed her badly, so I went to see her.” On the 24th he also said that “Japan’s territory is one-sixteenth the size of ours; it is nothing to fear,” and on the 28th that “there is no room for compromise between China and Japan.” His departure for Shanghai thwarted the Japanese attempt to draw him in, and he broke with Wang Yitang and other pro-Japanese followers of several decades. It has been argued that Duan’s journey south was the product of mutual use between him and Chiang Kai-shek, and that in the end Duan left politics entirely while Nanjing gained very little.⁠[11][4]

Final Years in Shanghai

Apart from three months at Lushan in the summer of 1934 at Chiang Kai-shek’s invitation, Duan never left Shanghai again. Accounts of his residence in Shanghai differ: one says he first stayed at the World Society and later moved to Chen Tiaoyuan’s mansion on Avenue Joffre; another places him on Jessfield Road. Xue Guanlan recalled that Chiang Kai-shek welcomed Duan to Shanghai with the courtesy of a disciple, supported him by the arm as he walked, treated him with great respect and gave him generous gifts.⁠[11][16][5]

Duan owned no private property and had a limited income, and the financially strapped Nanjing government could not look after him; for a time after moving south he lived in real hardship, but he accepted it gladly, spending his days in Buddhist devotions and games of go and, in the last part of his life, keeping far from politics and power.⁠[4]

Dies in Shanghai

Duan Qirui died of illness in Shanghai at the age of 71; his last words still included the injunction “do not forget to strengthen national defense.” By one account his coffin reached Peiping on December 9 and was placed temporarily at the Temple of the Sleeping Buddha in the Fragrant Hills; after the Marco Polo Bridge Incident of July 7, 1937, his descendants hastily buried him in the western suburbs of Peiping; and in 1963 his nephew and Zhang Shizhao moved his remains to the Wan’an Cemetery in Beijing, where the tombstone bears the inscription, written by Zhang Shizhao, “Tomb of Lord Duan Zhiquan of Hefei.”⁠[1][16][4]

Hefei Plans to Rebuild the Duan Family Buildings

Family

Duan’s eldest son, Duan Hongye, was born to his first wife. His second wife, Lady Zhang, was related to the Yuan family: her father had died fighting the Nian rebels under Yuan Jiasan, leaving her an orphan, and Yuan Shikai adopted her and raised her as his own daughter; she grew up in the Yuan household on the Huan River in Henan before she married, and the Yuans called her “eldest young lady.” Xue Guanlan recalled that for this reason Yuan Shikai in effect treated Duan with the courtesy due to a son-in-law, and that Lady Zhang bore three daughters: the eldest married Yuan Jialang, a grandson of Yuan Shilian, the fifth younger brother of Yuan Shikai; the second married Zhang Daohong; and the third married Xi Lun. In his later years Duan also had a young concubine. Duan Honggang, his brother’s son, was his favorite nephew.⁠[5][11]

Go, Buddhism and Character

Duan loved go, and his eldest son, Duan Hongye, never gave his father any quarter at the board. In his later years he played daily with Wang Zhao, Zhang Guoying, Wu Zhongying and other players; he was also a devout Buddhist and in his later years kept a vegetarian diet. When the Japanese thinker Tokutomi Sohō visited Beijing in 1917 he called on Duan especially and was given a small photograph of him. In his later years Duan also kept a hen farm with no roosters.⁠[4][19]

Xue Guanlan recalled that Duan hated to lose: beaten at go, he was crestfallen and would not let the matter rest; he cared nothing for wealth and regarded decorations as dirt, paying no heed even when the Chilean government conferred on him a grand order set with diamonds. Xue summed up that the man Duan most admired was Yuan Shikai and the one he most trusted was Xu Shuzheng, that he most hated Wu Peifu and most feared his wife, Lady Zhang, that his proudest moment was the Machang campaign and his most wretched his flight from the Chief Executive’s office.⁠[5]

Assessments

Xue Guanlan judged that Duan served the country well in bringing China into the First World War, but that by re-electing the parliament in 1917 he caused the north–south standoff and the dispute over constitutional legitimacy, for which he could not escape blame.⁠[5]

Sources19 sources

  1. Duan Qirui (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  2. 段祺瑞的“三”和“六” [Duan Qirui’s “three” and “six”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)rmzxw.com.cn↑
  3. (3) The Rise of Warlordism and the Palace-Council Dispute (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  4. 段祺瑞下棋,日本人没看懂 [Duan Qirui played go, and the Japanese did not understand] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)paper.people.com.cn↑
  5. 袁世凯女婿薛观澜:我所知道的段祺瑞的一生 [Xue Guanlan, son-in-law of Yuan Shikai: the life of Duan Qirui as I knew it] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  6. China: Heads of Government (Beijing): 1912-1928 (opens in a new window)archontology.org↑
  7. 李炜光:梁启超:中国公共财政的启蒙师与先行者 [Li Weiguang: Liang Qichao, enlightener and forerunner of public finance in China] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  8. 马勇:1917复辟再检讨 [Ma Yong: The restoration of 1917 re-examined] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  9. 侯中军:一战期间围绕北京政府对德宣战条件的外交交涉 [Hou Zhongjun: Diplomatic negotiations over the Beijing government’s conditions for declaring war on Germany during the First World War] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  10. File No. 893.00/2744 (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
  11. 1933年段祺瑞南下探析 [An analysis of Duan Qirui’s journey south in 1933] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)journal.ipm.edu.mo↑
  12. 林长民:兼容中西、立足民本 [Lin Changmin: combining Chinese and Western learning, rooted in the people] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  13. 郭松齢の叛乱と張学良の軍事思想―「東北易幟」への道― [Guo Songling’s rebellion and the military thought of Zhang Xueliang: the road to the Northeast Flag Replacement] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kitakyu.repo.nii.ac.jp↑
  14. 893.00/6886: Telegram (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
  15. “三一八”惨案 [The March 18 Massacre] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)cpc.people.com.cn↑
  16. 王建勋:想起了段祺瑞 [Wang Jianxun: Remembering Duan Qirui] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  17. 段祺瑞何叹“一世英名毁于一旦” [Why Duan Qirui lamented that “a lifetime’s good name was ruined in a day”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)aisixiang.com↑
  18. 安徽将“复活”李鸿章和段祺瑞家族建筑 [Anhui to “Revive” Buildings of the Li Hongzhang and Duan Qirui Families] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinanews.com.cn↑
  19. 段祺瑞 Duan Qirui (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)digitalrepository.lib.hku.hk↑