Heyin Incident
The Heyin Incident was the slaughter at Heyin, on the thirteenth day of the fourth month of the first year of Wutai of the Northern Wei (528), of the princes and officials who had come to welcome the new sovereign, Emperor Xiaozhuang (Yuan Ziyou), carried out by the warlord Erzhu RongErzhu RongErzhu Rong (493–530), courtesy name Tianbao, was a powerful minister at the end of the Northern Wei, born into a family of Qihu (Jie) tribal chieftains in Northern Xiurong. He rose during the Six Garrisons Rebellion by raising an army with his own wealth and suppressing risings; after Emperor Xiaoming was poisoned by Empress Dowager Hu’s faction in 528 he marched on Luoyang, enthroned Yuan Ziyou as Emperor Xiaozhuang and carried out the Heyin Incident, killing the empress dowager, the child emperor and a great many court officials. Made Prince of Taiyuan, he controlled the government from his base at Jinyang, went on to defeat Ge Rong and Yuan Hao and was named pillar of heaven grand general; in 530 Emperor Xiaozhuang had him killed in the Mingguang Hall, and the Erzhu clan was later destroyed by Gao Huan.Open the full entry; accounts put the dead at more than two thousand or at more than one thousand three hundred. On the same day the regent Empress Dowager Hu and the infant ruler she had enthroned, Yuan Zhao, were drowned in the Yellow River. Erzhu Rong then dominated the Northern Wei court until Emperor Xiaozhuang had him killed in 530; the dynasty was left with weak sovereigns and strong ministers and soon split into the Eastern and Western Wei.
Contents18 sections
Key facts
523–528The Regency of Empress Dowager Hu and Unrest in the North
Empress Dowager Hu (the Lingtaihou) had been a consort of the rank of guipin of Emperor Xuanwu. She was brought into the palace on the recommendation of her aunt Sengzhi, a Buddhist nun who lectured in the palace, had a general grasp of the Buddhist scriptures and later sent monks to the Western Regions to obtain scriptures. She was the mother of the heir, Yuan Xu, and survived because an attempt to do away with her was not carried through. After Emperor Xuanwu died, Yu Zhong placed Yuan Xu on the throne as Emperor Xiaoming and at first honored Lady Hu only as Imperial Consort Dowager; Yu Zhong then dominated the government, which provoked opposition, and Empress Dowager Hu afterwards ruled from behind the screen.[1][2]
Empress Dowager Hu’s extravagant spending and fully sinicized way of life led to revolts. A military uprising broke out in 523, and the Northern Wei then went through ten years of civil war. Emperor Xiaoming was held in check by Empress Dowager Hu and her favorites Zheng Yan and Xu He.[3][4]
Empress Dowager Hu came from Linjing in Anding and was a daughter of Hu Guozhen, minister over the masses. On entering the palace she was given the rank of chenghua shifu. When she was pregnant, her fellow palace women cited the old palace precedent to frighten her and urged her to find a way of avoiding the birth of a son, but she vowed alone at night that if the child were a boy and in due order the eldest son, she would not refuse to die once he was born. After giving birth to Emperor Xiaoming she was promoted to the rank of chonghua pin. Later Yuan Yi and Liu Teng installed Emperor Xiaoming in the Xianyang Hall, confined her in the North Palace and killed Yuan Yi, Prince of Qinghe, inside the palace; she afterwards returned to rule from behind the screen and proclaimed an amnesty and a new era name. Li Shengui and Xu He, her intimates, within a year or two “controlled all the key posts of the palace,” and Zheng Yan “corrupted the inner palace, his power overwhelming the realm.”[5][6]
523–528The Rise of Erzhu Rong
Erzhu Rong had his base at Xiurong, and his daughter was a consort of Emperor Xiaoming. He held palace guard posts including attendant of the imperial bedchamber, general of the palace gate, general of the martial guard and general of the right guard, and about four months before he entered Luoyang he was made general of chariots and cavalry and grand master of the palace of the right, with the rank equal to the three ministers.[4]
Emperor Xiaoming was close to Erzhu Rong; one view holds that the emperor was in fact able to control him, and that Erzhu Rong’s advance and his halt at Shangdang were both carried out on the emperor’s secret orders. Erzhu Rong plotted with Yuan Tianmu and Heba Yue to march on Luoyang with the aim of purging the favorites at court and clearing away the bandits outside it. Fei Mu had held Yunzhou during the Six Garrisons RebellionSix Garrisons RebellionThe Six Garrisons Rebellion was a large-scale rising of the people of Northern Wei’s northern frontier garrisons at the end of the dynasty. Wei had set up garrisons south of the Yin Mountains to defend against the Rouran; the six principal ones, Woye, Huaishuo, Wuchuan, Fuming, Rouxuan and Huaihuang, were called the Six Garrisons, and their people lost standing after Emperor Xiaowen moved the capital to Luoyang and pursued Sinicization. The rising began, by one account, with a revolt of the Huaihuang garrison people in 523, by another with the rising of Poliuhan Baling of Woye in 524, and spread to the other garrisons, Guanzhong and Hebei, where Du Luozhou, Xianyu Xiuli, Ge Rong, Hu Chen and Moqi Chounu rose in turn. Erzhu Rong defeated Ge Rong in 528, and the rebellion was largely suppressed by 530. Gao Huan and Yuwen Tai, both men of the six garrisons, went on to control the Eastern and Western Wei, into which Northern Wei split in 534.Open the full entry and stood on the opposite side from the rebellious garrison people.[4]
528The Death of Emperor Xiaoming and the Enthronement of Yuan Zhao
In 528 Emperor Xiaoming was poisoned by Empress Dowager Hu acting with Zheng Yan and Xu He. To keep control of the government, she placed the three-year-old Yuan Zhao on the throne.[3][4][7][5][8]
On the guichou day of the second month of the first year of Wutai, Emperor Xiaoming died suddenly at the age of nineteen; Zheng Yan and Xu He, fearing that disaster would fall on them, had secretly plotted with Empress Dowager Hu to poison him, and opinion at the time likewise held it to be their scheme, to the indignation of court and country. On the jiayin day the Empress Dowager made the emperor’s daughter ruler, then issued an edict explaining that the child of Consort Pan, of the rank of chonghua, was in fact a girl; on the yimao day Yuan Zhao took the throne. By another account the Empress Dowager first enthroned Consort Pan’s daughter as though she were the heir apparent, and only some days later, seeing that people had settled, disclosed that the child was a girl and that another heir must be chosen, and set up Yuan Zhao, son of the Prince of Lintao, to the astonishment of the realm.[7][5][8]
528Erzhu Rong’s March on Luoyang and the Enthronement of Emperor Xiaozhuang
Erzhu Rong expressed his anger to Yuan Tianmu, saying that an infant ruler was unfit to govern the realm, and proposed leading his armored cavalry to the imperial tomb and setting up an adult ruler. In a memorial to the throne he demanded that Xu He, Zheng Yan and the others be handed over for judgment and that a mature and virtuous member of the imperial clan be called to the throne.[4][9][8]
Erzhu Rong sent Erzhu Tianguang and Xi Yi to confer secretly with Erzhu Shilong on a candidate, and Erzhu Tianguang then approached Yuan Ziyou, then 22 years old. Yuan Ziyou was a son of Yuan Xie, Prince of Pengcheng; his family had a record of loyal service and he himself was well regarded; Emperor Xiaoming had treated him as an intimate since childhood and he often served on night duty in the palace, while Empress Dowager Hu kept him at a distance. Another candidate, Yuan Shao, had been known for his integrity since youth and had resisted Liang raids, but Erzhu Rong passed him over. Erzhu Rong had bronze images cast of the descendants of Emperor Xiaowen and of five princes including Yuan Xi, Prince of Xianyang, on the understanding that the one whose image came out whole would be made ruler; only Yuan Ziyou’s image was cast successfully.[4]
Erzhu Rong’s army joined Yuan Ziyou at Heyang, and after crossing the Yellow River Erzhu Rong asked him to take the throne; he became Emperor Xiaozhuang, and the officials of Luoyang came to the river bridge to welcome him. Empress Dowager Hu thereupon shaved her head and became a nun, and Zheng Yan and Xu He fled to their home districts. After his enthronement Emperor Xiaozhuang made Erzhu Rong commissioner with credentials, palace attendant, commander-in-chief of all armies inside and outside the capital, grand general, with the right to open a headquarters, acting director of the Department of State Affairs, general commanding the guards and commander of the attendants, and created him Prince of Taiyuan; later he added the titles of pillar-of-state grand general and acting overseer of the Department of State Affairs, among others.[4][10][9][5]
Erzhu Rong, courtesy name Tianbao, came from Xiurong in Beidi; his family had been chief tribal commanders of the first rank for generations, he held the title of Duke of Boling Commandery, and his tribe numbered more than eight thousand households with tens of thousands of horses. He told Yuan Tianmu, governor of Bingzhou, that there could be no hope of peace if an infant who could not yet speak were set over the realm, and that, his family having received the state’s favor for generations, he could not sit by and watch it succeed or fail. Yuan Tianmu replied that Erzhu Rong’s family had long held Bing and Si provinces and his tribesmen counted “ten thousand bowmen,” and that if he would depose and enthrone, the deeds of Yi Yin and Huo Guang would be seen again. The two then swore brotherhood; Yuan Tianmu, the elder, was treated by Erzhu Rong as an elder brother, while Erzhu Rong was the leader of the compact and Yuan Tianmu in turn bowed to him.[8]
After his memorial Erzhu Rong set out for Luoyang with his forces. Empress Dowager Hu, much alarmed, made Li Shengui grand commander to block Erzhu Rong in the Taihang region. When she summoned the princes and dukes to deliberate, the imperial clansmen, resentful of the favor shown to the Hu family, would not speak; only Xu He, gentleman of the yellow gate, called Erzhu Rong “a petty barbarian of Mayi” and urged holding the river bridge and letting the enemy tire himself out. The Empress Dowager agreed and sent the commanders Li Shengui, Zheng Jiming and others with five thousand men to hold the river bridge. Zheng Xianhu, long on good terms with Emperor Xiaozhuang, opened the city gates to him with Zheng Jiming on hearing of his enthronement; Li Shengui, reaching the river bridge and learning that the northern central fortress had fallen, fled back; and Fei Mu abandoned his troops and was the first to surrender to Erzhu Rong. By one account Li Shengui and Zheng Jiming opened their gates and surrendered on seeing Yuan Ziyou, Prince of Changle, go over to Erzhu Rong’s army. By another account Xu He forged an edict, had the palace gates opened at night, took ten imperial horses from the Hualiu stables and fled east to Yanzhou; his brothers Xu Xianbo, governor of Beihai, and Xu Jichan, aide to the governor of Qingzhou, warned by him, fled with their households and went with him to Mount Tai, while Zheng Yan plotted with his cousin Zheng Zhongming, governor of Xingyang, to seize the commandery and rise in arms and was killed by his own men.[9][8][7][7]
On the night of the bingshen day of the fourth month of the first year of Wutai, Yuan Ziyou, with his elder brother Yuan Shao, Prince of Pengcheng, and his younger brother Yuan Zizheng, Duke of Bacheng, secretly crossed the Yellow River northward at Gaozhu; on the dingyou day he joined Erzhu Rong, whose officers and men all cried “Ten thousand years”; on the wuxu day he crossed back south and took the throne, made Yuan Shao the Unsurpassed Prince and Yuan Zizheng Prince of Shiping, and at the same time gave Erzhu Rong his offices and created him Prince of Taiyuan with a fief of twenty thousand households; on the jihai day the officials, led by the responsible offices, came with the seals and the full imperial carriage to welcome him. Another account, counting by days of the month, has Yuan Ziyou reach Erzhu Rong’s army on the ninth day of the fourth month, Erzhu Rong acknowledge him as sovereign on the eleventh and the officials attend him at the traveling palace on the twelfth. Yet another account has Erzhu Rong pass through Henei to the Gaotou post station on the eleventh day of the fourth month, Yuan Ziyou, Prince of Changle, cross north from Leibei to join his army, and Erzhu Rong camp north of Mount Mang on the twelfth.[10][9][7][8]
On the choice of a sovereign by casting images, one account says that when Erzhu Rong set out from Jinyang he had still not decided whom to enthrone, so he had bronze images cast of the descendants of “six princes,” Gaozu and Yuan Xi, Prince of Xianyang, among them, on the understanding that the one whose image came out whole would be made ruler, and only Emperor Xiaozhuang’s image came out whole. Another says that Erzhu Rong and Yuan Tianmu had an image cast at Jinyang for each of the princes and none came out whole except that of Yuan Ziyou, Prince of Changle, which was “perfect in radiance and form, dignified and especially fine,” so that Erzhu Rong settled on the Prince of Changle and sent his slave retainer Wang Feng to Luoyang to make the compact with him, after which Erzhu Rong’s three armies, dressed in white mourning, raised their banners and marched south. Another account names those sent to Luoyang as his nephew Erzhu Tianguang, his confidant Xi Yi and the slave retainer Wang Xiang.[9][8]
528Fei Mu’s Advice and Murong Shaozong’s Objection
Fei Mu advised Erzhu Rong that his forces were small and that he had entered Luoyang without difficulty only because he had raised up a new sovereign in accord with popular feeling; unless he carried out a great punishment and set up a party of his own, he would be unable to prevent trouble once he returned north. Fei Mu was described as fond of fame and office, and after the incident he was promoted to general of the central army and minister of personnel; one view holds that he gave this advice in pursuit of fame and power rather than out of the palace guards’ resentment of sinicization. That Fei Mu was the chief instigator of the Heyin Incident was widely known at the time.[4][7]
Erzhu Rong also privately sought the view of Murong Shaozong, telling him that the people of Luoyang were numerous and had grown arrogant and extravagant, and that unless they were cut down they would be hard to control. Murong Shaozong replied that the Empress Dowager’s rule had been licentious and cruel, so that the whole realm resented it and had abandoned her; but since Erzhu Rong commanded a divine army and held to loyalty, a sudden slaughter of so many officials was no long-term policy, and he begged him to think it over three times.[4][7]
Fei Mu also told Erzhu Rong that his troops numbered under ten thousand, that no one had drawn up against him on his long march to Luoyang so that he had no prestige of victory, and that people had never truly accepted him; the crowds of the capital and its many officials, once they knew his real strength, would come to despise him, and unless he carried out great executions there would be an uprising at court before he had even crossed the Taihang Mountains on his way north. Erzhu Rong agreed in his heart and told his confidant Murong Shaozong that he meant to kill all the officials when they came out to welcome the emperor. Murong Shaozong further pointed out that the Empress Dowager’s debauchery and the power of her favorites were the reason Erzhu Rong had raised troops to cleanse the court, and that to wipe out a great number of officials without cause, making no distinction between the loyal and the treacherous, would cost him the confidence of the realm. Erzhu Rong did not listen.[7]
528The Massacre at Heyin
On the thirteenth day of the fourth month of the first year of Wutai of the Northern Wei, Erzhu Rong led the officials who had come to welcome the emperor to a spot northwest of the traveling palace, saying that he intended to sacrifice to Heaven; when the court officials had gathered, he had cavalry form ranks around them, reproached them for the disorder of the realm, and then slaughtered them at Heyin.[4][9][7]
Accounts of the number killed differ: one gives more than two thousand dukes and ministers killed, another more than one thousand three hundred dead. One reconstruction takes about 1,300 to be the number of officials killed and more than 2,000 to be the total including their attendants. Another account puts the number of courtiers murdered at 2,000. Emperor Xiaozhuang’s elder brother and younger brother were also killed in the incident.[4][3][10][9][7][11]
Yuan Shun fled on hearing of the slaughter and was killed by Xianyu Kangnu, a tomb-household attendant. Among those killed was also Li Renyao, the son-in-law of Wei Zijian.[4][12][13]
The massacre took place on the gengzi day. That day Erzhu Rong asked Emperor Xiaozhuang to go west along the Yellow River to Taozhu, and, confident that military power was in his hands, he harbored designs on the throne; it was barbarian cavalry that surrounded the officials, and he blamed the disorder of the realm and the sudden death of Emperor Xiaoming on the officials’ greed and cruelty and their failure to correct and assist the throne, and the princes, ministers and officials submitted to slaughter without resistance. Erzhu Rong’s cavalry then escorted the emperor to a temporary tent.[10][7][9]
Those killed were, in order, the Empress Dowager and the infant ruler; then Yuan Shao, the Unsurpassed Prince, and Yuan Zizheng, Prince of Shiping; and then the chancellor Yuan Yong, Prince of Gaoyang; Yuan Qin, minister of works; Yuan Hengzhi, of rank equal to the three ministers; Yuan Lue, Prince of Dongping, of the same rank; Yuan Ti, Prince of Guangping; Yuan Shao, Prince of Changshan; Yuan Chao, Prince of Beiping; Yuan Yi, Prince of Rencheng; Yuan Min, Prince of Zhaojun; Yuan Shuren, Prince of Zhongshan; and Yuan Wen, Prince of Qijun, together with ministers and officials below them. Another list gives Yuan Lue as Prince of Yiyang, of rank equal to the three ministers, and adds that the former gentleman of the yellow gate Wang Zunye and his brothers, who were in mourning for their father, came out to welcome the emperor because their mother was his maternal aunt, and were all killed; Wang Zunye was a grandson of Wang Huilong.[10][7]
Since the Xiping era Yuan Yong had held the highest offices as a senior kinsman but had failed to uphold the right and correct the court, merely assenting to whatever was done. At the start of Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign, Erzhu Rong, wishing to kill the court officials, claimed that Yuan Yong was plotting rebellion; Yuan Yong was killed at Heyin and posthumously given the yellow battle-axe and the office of chancellor of state, with the posthumous name Wenmu. His principal son, Yuan Tai, courtesy name Chang, who had served as attendant gentleman of the secretariat, cavalier attendant-in-ordinary, general who guards the east and chief minister of ceremonials, was killed at the same time and posthumously made palace attendant, specially advanced, general of agile cavalry, grand commandant, governor of Wuzhou and Prince of Gaoyang, with the posthumous name Wenxiao. Yuan Duan, treated in the same biography, had been general who guards the army and governor of Yanzhou, had held the provincial city with its civil and military officials when Xiao Yan’s forces besieged it and was made Founding Duke of Ande County for this, and after returning to court became minister of the capital office; he too was killed with Yuan Yong and posthumously made general of chariots and cavalry, of rank equal to the three ministers, and governor of Xiangzhou, his son Yuan Jun inheriting the title, which was reduced as a matter of course when the Qi took the throne. Yuan Tai’s younger brother Yuan Rui, courtesy name Zizhe, cared little for honors, loved the zither and books, served as cavalier gentleman, vice minister of the guard and vice minister of the household, and was made Prince of Jibei; he was likewise killed with Yuan Yong and posthumously made general of chariots and cavalry, minister of works and governor of Yongzhou.[6]
Erzhu Rong was married to Yuan Lue’s paternal aunt; Yuan Lue had always looked down on him and had also sided with Zheng Yan and Xu He, so Erzhu Rong bore him a grudge, and when Erzhu Rong entered Luoyang Yuan Lue was killed at Heyin and posthumously given his own offices with the addition of grand guardian, minister of works and governor of Xuzhou, with the posthumous name Wenzhen. Yuan Lue had earlier gone over to the Liang and later returned to the Northern Wei, where he was first made Prince of Yiyang and then Prince of Dongping, and was promoted to director of the Department of State Affairs, of rank equal to the three ministers, and libationer of the state academy, remaining palace attendant. Another account gives his posthumous honor as grand guardian with the posthumous name Wenzhen, and says that his heir, Yuan Jingshi, gave his residence to become the Zhuiguang Monastery.[13][14]
Yuan Qin, minister of works and Duke of Juping County, was killed at Heyin and posthumously given the yellow battle-axe and made grand preceptor and grand commandant. Yuan Yi, courtesy name Zilun, the fourth son of Yuan Cheng, Prince of Rencheng, born to his second wife Lady Feng, inherited the title and served as cavalier attendant-in-ordinary; ashamed to attach himself to the regent Yuan Yi when the latter held power, he never received high office; he was killed at Heyin at the start of Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign and posthumously made general of chariots and cavalry, of rank equal to the three ministers, and governor of Qingzhou, with the posthumous name Wen. Yuan Shuren, a son of Yuan Xi, had been spared for his youth when his father and brothers were killed and was moved with his mother, Lady Yu, to Shuozhou; early in the Xiaochang era Empress Dowager Ling recalled him to the capital, restored his property and residence and let him inherit his father’s title, and he served as general who subdues the barbarians and cavalier attendant-in-ordinary; he was killed at Heyin at the start of Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign and posthumously made general of the guard, of rank equal to the three ministers, and governor of Bingzhou. Yuan Yixing, Yuan Xi’s half-brother, had been adopted as heir to his uncle Yuan Bingluo and so escaped punishment when Yuan Xi was killed; he later became general who supports the state and cavalier attendant-in-ordinary, was killed at Heyin at the start of Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign and was posthumously made general of the central army and governor of Yingzhou, and later also cavalier attendant-in-ordinary and general who campaigns in the east. Yuan Zhan, courtesy name Zhenxing, younger brother of Yuan Ning, served as gentleman of the imperial library, left assistant director of the Department of State Affairs and vice minister of justice; he was killed at Heyin at the start of Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign and posthumously made general who campaigns in the east and governor of Qingzhou and created Prince of Yuyang with a fief of five hundred households.[13][13][13]
When Erzhu Rong, in Emperor Xiaozhuang’s name, summoned the officials to Heyin, he had long heard of Yuan Shun’s repeated frank remonstrances and, valuing his uprightness, told Zhu Rui to let “Vice Director Yuan” know that he should stay in the Department of State Affairs and need not come; Yuan Shun did not grasp the meaning and, hearing that the officials were being killed, fled. His house had nothing but bare walls and nothing with which to shroud his body except several thousand books, and Wang Caida, a clerk of his office, tore his own clothes to cover him. When Emperor Xiaozhuang returned to the palace he sent Shan Wei, gentleman of the yellow gate, to reassure the capital; Shan Wei wept without restraint at Yuan Shun’s bier and on his return explained why to the emperor, who instructed the palace attendant Yuan Zhi that, since so many of the imperial clan had died, not all could be provided for, but that Vice Director Yuan’s integrity in poverty shone the more in death: he was specially granted a hundred bolts of silk, which was not to serve as a precedent for others, and was posthumously made general of agile cavalry, director of the Department of State Affairs, minister over the masses and governor of Dingzhou, with the posthumous name Wenlie. Yuan Shun had written the Dilu in twenty juan and several dozen poems, rhapsodies, memorials and eulogies, most of them since lost. His eldest son, Yuan Lang, then seventeen, lay in wait for years with his weapon at hand and at last killed Xianyu Kangnu with his own hands, offered the head at Yuan Shun’s grave and then went to the court to ask for punishment; the court commended him and took no action.[13]
528The Drowning of Empress Dowager Hu and Yuan Zhao
On the same day Erzhu Rong had Empress Dowager Hu and the infant ruler Yuan Zhao taken to Heyin and, ignoring the Empress Dowager’s attempts to explain herself, rose and swept out, and had both of them sunk in the Yellow River. Another account says only that the two died suddenly that day.[4][3][5][9][7]
When Erzhu Rong crossed the river, Empress Dowager Hu ordered all the consorts of Emperor Xiaoming’s palace to enter religious life. After her death her younger sister, Lady of Pingyi, recovered her body and buried it at the Shuangling Buddhist Monastery; only under Emperor Chu was she reburied with the rites of an empress and given a posthumous name. The monk Baogong had once told her, “Holding out grain to the chickens, call ‘zhu, zhu,’” words that no one at the time could understand; when she was killed by Erzhu Rong in the first year of Jianyi, they were taken to have come true.[5][14]
528Erzhu Rong’s Abortive Bid for the Throne
At the time of the massacre Erzhu Rong did contemplate seizing the throne: he ordered court officials to draft a document of abdication, sparing those who drafted it, moved Emperor Xiaozhuang into his own camp tent, and had a golden image of himself cast, which failed four times. After Liu Lingzhu pointed out the meaning of this, Erzhu Rong came to his senses, kowtowed to Emperor Xiaozhuang to beg forgiveness and offered to atone to the court with his life, and later apologized again in the Mingguang Hall. Heba Yue also warned him that usurpation would only hasten disaster.[4][9][7]
One view holds that Erzhu Rong had not originally intended to usurp the throne and that the massacre left him remorseful, which explains much of his later conduct; another holds that he delayed entering Luoyang because the massacre had broken his tacit understanding with Emperor Xiaozhuang.[4]
After the massacre more than a hundred court officials arrived late; Erzhu Rong again had them surrounded by barbarian cavalry, and Zhao Yuanze, attendant censor, volunteered to draft the abdication document. Erzhu Rong then had his soldiers shout, “The Yuan are finished, the Erzhu rise,” and all cried “Ten thousand years.” He also sent several dozen men with drawn swords toward the traveling palace; the emperor came out of his tent with Yuan Shao and Yuan Zizheng, and Guo Luocha of Bingzhou and Chilie Shagui of the western Gaoju, whom Erzhu Rong had earlier posted at the emperor’s side under the pretext of guarding him, carried the emperor back into the tent, while the others killed Yuan Shao and Yuan Zizheng. Moved to the river bridge, the emperor, grieving and helpless, sent word to Erzhu Rong that emperors rise and fall in turn and fortune is never constant; the realm was falling apart and the general had risen and carried all before him, which was the will of Heaven, not the work of men; he himself had come only to seek refuge and save his life and dared not covet the throne; if Heaven’s mandate had passed to the general he should take the imperial title at once, and if he declined it and preserved the altars of Wei he should choose another worthy kinsman to support. Gao Huan, then a commander, urged Erzhu Rong to proclaim himself emperor and most of those around him agreed, but Erzhu Rong hesitated. Liu Lingzhu of Yan Commandery, an adjutant skilled in divination whom Erzhu Rong trusted, told him that neither the time nor the affairs of men allowed it; when Erzhu Rong said that if he himself was unlucky he would set up Yuan Tianmu, Liu Lingzhu replied that Yuan Tianmu was unlucky too and only the Prince of Changle had the mandate. After Erzhu Rong came to his senses, Heba Yue asked that Gao Huan be killed to make amends to the realm, but those around Erzhu Rong argued that, foolish though Gao Huan was, generals were needed while the realm was in turmoil, and asked that he be spared, and Erzhu Rong let the matter drop. At the fourth watch of that night he brought the emperor back to his camp and, seeing the head of the emperor’s horse, kowtowed and asked to die.[7]
By another account those who dissuaded Erzhu Rong were Gao Huan and Sima Ziru, Erzhu Rong’s adjutant for external troops, among others, who earnestly set out why usurpation was impossible; Erzhu Rong said that having erred so badly he could only atone to the court with his life, and asked what should be done at this moment of danger, and Gao Huan and the others advised him to turn back and serve the Prince of Changle so as to bring peace to the realm, whereupon Erzhu Rong again acknowledged Emperor Xiaozhuang.[9]
528The Proposed Move of the Capital and the Capital–Headquarters System
Directly after the Heyin Incident, and before entering Luoyang with Emperor Xiaozhuang, Erzhu Rong intended to move the capital from Luoyang to his own base at Jinyang in Bingzhou. After entering the city he proposed the move several times; Yuan Chen of the imperial clan opposed it firmly, and Erzhu Rong in a rage threatened him by invoking Heyin, but Yuan Chen did not yield. A few days later, having seen the splendor of the Luoyang palaces, Erzhu Rong accepted Yuan Chen’s view and the plan was dropped.[12][4][7]
Immediately after the Heyin Incident the Erzhu military clique set up a dual system of a royal capital at Luoyang and a military headquarters at Jinyang, and the arrangement of offices made at that time was largely kept in place until Erzhu Rong’s death. Though away from the capital, Erzhu Rong constantly controlled the court from afar, while Emperor Xiaozhuang was constantly resentful.[15][12][16]
Because his barbarian cavalry had killed so many officials, Erzhu Rong did not dare enter Luoyang and wanted to go straight north and plan a move of the capital; he wavered for a long time, and Fan Li, general of the martial guard, firmly remonstrated with him. Yuan Chen, who opposed the move, was then minister of the capital office. Erzhu Rong said angrily, “What business is this of yours, that you are so stubborn? And you must know what happened at Heyin.” Yuan Chen answered, “The affairs of the realm should be discussed with the realm; why try to frighten Yuan Chen with the cruelty of Heyin!” He added that as a member of the imperial clan holding a high palace office he would not be afraid even if his skull were shattered and his entrails spilled. Erzhu Rong, furious, wanted to punish him and desisted only when Erzhu Shilong firmly remonstrated; all who saw it trembled, but Yuan Chen kept his composure. A few days later the emperor and Erzhu Rong climbed to a height and saw the splendid palaces and the rows of trees, and Erzhu Rong sighed that he had foolishly thought of moving north the day before, but now, seeing the grandeur of the imperial residence and reflecting on Minister Yuan’s words, he knew they could not be gainsaid. On the xinyou day of the fifth month Erzhu Rong went back to Jinyang, and the emperor gave him a farewell banquet north of Mount Mang.[7][7]
528Relief for the Victims and Posthumous Honors
Erzhu Rong petitioned for the ranks of the officials killed at Heyin to be raised, so that his grace might reach the living and the dead and console both, and asked that the three dukes, the director and vice directors, the ministers and the nine chief ministers be received on the first and fifteenth days of each month to discuss affairs of state as a standing practice. He also sought to have his daughter made Emperor Xiaozhuang’s empress, with the support of Zu Ying. The edict on posthumous honors extended them as far as commoners, who were to receive commandery or garrison posts, or to those of the seventh rank and below and commoners.[4][9][10][7]
Members of the Northern Wei imperial clan killed in the Heyin Incident left epitaphs that supplement the dynastic history and Erzhu Rong’s memorial on posthumous titles. The epitaphs show that the posthumous honors usually combined a general’s title with the title of a provincial governor, that the posthumous general’s title was about two grades above the last one the deceased had held, and that the other honors were tied to that rank. Erzhu Rong’s proposal does not match these patterns and was probably not applied in this round, perhaps being kept for his favorites; by broadly loosening eligibility it may have led to the excessive grants of titles that followed.[17]
Replying to Erzhu Rong’s memorial, Emperor Xiaozhuang said that his own virtue had been too slight to move men, so that such cruelty and excess had come about, that he was pained to the heart in recalling what had happened, and that the requests were approved. Thereafter posthumous honors were granted without restraint, men of no worth and low standing often receiving high posthumous office, which the discerning deplored, until in the Wuding era Prince Wenxiang of Qi ended the abuse and posthumous honors again followed rules. At Erzhu Rong’s request envoys were also sent through the city to comfort the people, after which feelings calmed and officials who had fled gradually returned to court. Yuan Shao was posthumously honored as Emperor Xiaoxuan and his wife Lady Li as Empress Wengong; his son Yuan Shao, courtesy name Shizhou, was made Prince of Pengcheng and inherited the title, became governor of the capital province at the end of the Wuding era and had his title reduced as a matter of course when the Qi took the throne. Yuan Zizheng was posthumously given the yellow battle-axe and made palace attendant, commander-in-chief of all armies inside and outside the capital, grand general and overseer of the Department of State Affairs, keeping his princely title.[9][6][7]
528–530Yuan Hao in Luoyang and Erzhu Rong’s Domination
When Yuan Hao advanced on Luoyang with Liang support, Gao Daomu proposed summoning Yuan Tianmu and Erzhu Rong to the rescue as the surest course, and both Yang Kan and Gao Daomu hoped that Erzhu Rong would support the throne as Duke Huan of Qi and Duke Wen of Jin had done. Fei Mu surrendered to Yuan Hao, who, holding that the excesses at Heyin had begun with him, called him in, rebuked him, and had him killed as he left. Erzhu Rong answered the summons and put down Yuan Hao, after which Emperor Xiaozhuang gave him the specially created title of Heavenly Pillar Grand General, though the emperor refused him the nine bestowments. After Yuan Hao’s defeat Yuan Yanming fled south with his wife and children to Xiao Yan’s Liang, where he died in the second year of Zhongdatong of the Liang (530).[4][1]
On a hunt Erzhu Rong insisted on campaigns against Xiao Yan and on resettling the six garrisons in the north, and criticized the laxity of the officials since Emperor Xiaoming; when Yuan Tianmu urged him to regulate the government and nourish the people, he rebuffed him. Erzhu Rong interfered in appointments and was repeatedly overruled by Emperor Xiaozhuang, who said that if the Heavenly Pillar would not remain a subject, he too would have to be replaced, words that enraged Erzhu Rong.[4]
528Emperor Xiaozhuang Enters the Palace and Proclaims the Jianyi Era
On the fourteenth day (xinchou) of the fourth month of the first year of Wutai, Emperor Xiaozhuang, escorted by Erzhu Rong, entered Luoyang, took his seat in the Taiji Hall and issued an edict describing himself as “falling short of Shaokang in virtue and unworthy of his forebears in the Way,” proclaiming a general amnesty and changing the era from Wutai to the first year of Jianyi. The officers and men who had followed Erzhu Rong, Prince of Taiyuan, were all raised five grades, civil officials in the capital two grades and military officials three, and the common people were excused tax and labor service for three years. Almost all the officials had perished and the survivors were in hiding; only Shan Wei, cavalier attendant-in-ordinary, came to bow before the palace gate to receive the amnesty. The people of Luoyang were in turmoil, some saying that Erzhu Rong would let his troops loose to plunder, others that he would move the capital to Jinyang; the rich abandoned their houses and the poor fled carrying their children, so that not one or two in ten remained, the palace guard posts stood empty and the offices were deserted.[10][9][7][11]
On the guimao day the emperor made the former grand commandant Yuan Ji, Prince of Jiangyang, grand preceptor and governor of the capital province; Yuan Hao, Prince of Beihai, general of agile cavalry with the right to open a headquarters and governor of Xiangzhou, grand tutor with a headquarters while remaining governor; Li Yanshi, general who pacifies the east, grand master of the palace and Founding Marquis of Qingyuan County, grand guardian, raised to Prince of Yangping and soon moved to grand tutor; Yuan Tianmu, general who pacifies the south and governor of Bingzhou, grand commandant and Prince of Shangdang; Yang Chun, palace attendant and general of chariots and cavalry, minister over the masses; Mu Shao, general of chariots and cavalry and Founding Duke of Dunqiu Commandery, minister of works and acting director of the Department of State Affairs, raised to prince; Zhangsun Zhi, governor of Yongzhou and Duke of Shangdang, general of agile cavalry with a headquarters, raised to prince and soon re-enfeoffed as Prince of Pingyi; Yuan Chen, general of the central army and palace minister, left vice director of the Department of State Affairs and Prince of Weijun; Yuan Tian, general of the central army and gentleman of the yellow gate, Prince of Donghai; and Yuan Gong, Prince of Guangling, grand master of the palace with gold seal and purple ribbon, of rank equal to the three ministers. Li Yanshi, a son of Li Chong, was promoted over others because he was the emperor’s maternal uncle, and countless others rose suddenly to high rank at this time. On the jiachen day the titles of the late Yuan Yuan, Prince of Guangyang, and the late Yuan Jian, Prince of Le’an, were restored; Yuan Tan, Prince of Fucheng, was made Prince of Xianyang, Yuan Guiping Prince of Donglai, Yuan Su Prince of Lujun and Yuan Ye Prince of Changguang, and Yuan Shaojing, Feng Jiong, Lu Zizhang, Zhangsun Yue and others recovered their former princely titles. On the dingwei day an edict lifted the state of alert inside and outside the capital. On the gengxu day Erzhu Rong’s second son, Yiluo, was made Prince of Liangjun.[10][7]
528Imperial Princes and Provincial Officials Flee to the Liang
In the fourth month of the first year of Wutai, Yuan Yue, Prince of Runan, Yuan Hao, Prince of Beihai, and Yuan Yu, Prince of Linhuai, went over one after another to Xiao Yan’s Liang; Yuan Yue and Yuan Yu, then branch secretariat of the Eastern Circuit, both fled south on hearing of the disorder at Heyin. Northern Wei defectors to the Liang had until then all referred to Wei offices as “false,” but Yuan Yu alone styled himself “Prince of Linhuai of Wei” in his memorials, and Emperor Wu of Liang, understanding his long-standing refinement, did not reproach him.[10][11][7]
Yuan Hao, just appointed grand tutor while remaining governor of Xiangzhou, had reached Jijun on his way to Xiangzhou when he heard of Ge Rong’s advance south and of Erzhu Rong’s violence; secretly looking to his own safety, he lingered and did not advance, and had his maternal uncle Fan Zun, governor of Yinzhou, take charge of Xiangzhou and hold Ye in place of the former governor Li Shen. The branch secretariat official Zhen Mi, seeing that Yuan Hao had other designs, led the others in removing Fan Zun, restored Li Shen to run the province and sent troops to meet Yuan Hao and watch what he would do; on learning of this, Yuan Hao fled with his attendants to the Liang. In the same month Yuan Shijun, governor of Northern Qingzhou, and Li Zhi, governor of Southern Jingzhou, surrendered their whole provinces to the Liang, and Yuan Xianda, governor of Yingzhou, also asked to surrender.[10][7]
In the seventh month of the first year of Jianyi, Yuan Yu, Prince of Linhuai, returned to the Northern Wei court from south of the Yangtze. In the tenth month of the first year of Yong’an, Xiao Yan made Yuan Hao King of Wei with the era name Xiaoji, and Yuan Hao occupied Zhicheng in Southern Yanzhou; on the bingzi day of the fifth month of the second year of Yong’an, Yuan Hao entered Luoyang.[10]
530Emperor Xiaozhuang Kills Erzhu Rong
Emperor Xiaozhuang planned to do away with Erzhu Rong but hesitated several times; Yuan Hui reminded him that even if Erzhu Rong did not rebel, he could not be endured. The emperor asked Wen Zisheng about how Wang Yun had killed Dong Zhuo, likening Erzhu Rong to Dong Zhuo. On the twenty-fifth day of the ninth month of 530 Erzhu Rong entered the palace and was cut down by Emperor Xiaozhuang himself east of the Mingguang Hall, at the age of 38. The plotters included members of the imperial Yuan clan and Han literati such as Yang Kan; Yuan Tianmu was also later killed by Emperor Xiaozhuang.[4][12]
An edict of Emperor Xiaozhuang acknowledged Erzhu Rong’s merit in putting down rebellions but condemned the affair at Heyin as ruthless and pitiless, concluding that his merit might at best make up for his offense. After Erzhu Rong was killed, the families of those who had died at Heyin exchanged condolences and congratulations; Wei Zijian, although his son-in-law Li Renyao had also been killed at Heyin, did not rejoice, because the Erzhu remained powerful, the plans after the assassination had failed and the Li family who led the plot met disaster, and he expressed his fears to his cousin Lu Daoyu.[4][12][10]
After Erzhu Rong’s death Erzhu Shilong refused the iron tablet of pardon offered by Emperor Xiaozhuang and rose in arms to avenge the Prince of Taiyuan; Erzhu Shilong and his allies first set up Yuan Ye and then deposed him in favor of Yuan Gong, Emperor Jiemin. Both Emperor Xiaozhuang and Emperor Jiemin were sons of Emperor Xiaowen’s brothers.[4][16]
Mindful of what had happened at Heyin, Emperor Xiaozhuang had long feared that in the end he would not be safe. On the xinmao day of the ninth month of the third year of Yong’an, Erzhu Rong and Yuan Tianmu, Prince of Shangdang, came to court from Jinyang; by one account, on the wuxu day the emperor killed Erzhu Rong, Yuan Tianmu and Erzhu Rong’s son Erzhu Puti, of rank equal to the three ministers, together in the Mingguang Hall. The emperor then mounted the Changhe Gate and issued an edict saying that at the end of the Xiaochang era “a woman ruler had thrown the government into disorder,” that Erzhu Rong had raised troops from Jinyang and assembled the allies at Mengjin and was at first not without merit, but that soon “the voice of the jackal was heard,” and that the affair at Heyin had left “princes, ministers and officials ruined in a single morning, no kinsman spared, all within and without destroyed,” while in the haste of the moment there had been no time to call him to account.[9][10]
534–535The Division of the Northern Wei
The empire was then divided between two rival army factions into the short-lived Eastern Wei and Western Wei, and the Northern Wei came to an end in 534 or 535. After Erzhu Rong’s death, Gao Huan and Heba Yue both changed sides within the Erzhu regime; neither Gao Huan nor Yuwen Tai abandoned the dynastic name of Wei.[3][4]
Consequences
The Heyin Incident marked a major turning point in the last years of the Northern Wei and is regarded as one of the events that divide periods in medieval Chinese history. One view holds that its consequence was that Erzhu Rong gave up usurpation and inaugurated a pattern of a weak sovereign and strong ministers, which Gao Huan and Yuwen Tai inherited and which became the basic framework of politics in the Eastern and Western Wei.[4]
Erzhu Rong’s posthumous standing was also disputed: Erzhu Shilong insisted that he be honored with a place in the temple of Emperor Xiaowen, over the objection of Liu Jiming, and under the Northern Qi Feng Longzhi opposed honoring him in the temple of Emperor Xiaoming on the grounds that he had personally committed regicide.[4]
After the Heyin affair the princes of the imperial Yuan clan were almost wiped out, and many of the mansions of princes and nobles in Luoyang’s Shouqiu Ward were renamed as Buddhist monasteries, so that their pagodas faced one another across the lanes.[14]
Historiography
Traditional commentary since the Southern Song mostly explained the Heyin Incident by Emperor Xiaowen’s sinicizing reforms: Ye Shi of the Southern Song held that the disaster of Erzhu Rong was brought on by the reforms themselves; Wang Fuzhi faulted the reforms for fostering empty display, mocking them as a monkey in a cap; and Hu Sanxing of the Yuan was likewise especially alert to the distinction between Chinese and non-Chinese. The Zizhi Tongjian, compiled under the Northern Song, is regarded as representing a different historiographical tradition.[4]
The biography of Erzhu Rong in the Book of Wei compiled by Wei Shou of the Northern Qi credits him in its closing assessment with putting down Ge Rong, Yuan Hao and other rebellions, and, invoking Kuai Tong’s advice to Han Xin, explains the suspicion he incurred by merit that overshadowed his sovereign; Zhao Yi of the Qing criticized the biography as slanted writing, while a modern view holds that its assessments are not simple flattery.[4][9]
In modern scholarship, an influential view treats the Heyin Incident as a reaction by the people of the six garrisons and the palace guards against Emperor Xiaowen’s sinicization policy, with Erzhu Rong and Fei Mu merely its instruments, Fei Mu having the court officials killed at the hands of Jie warriors, and holds that the eastern and western states founded later by refugees from the six garrisons reversed sinicization into barbarization. Many studies follow this framework. Other studies interpret the Six Garrisons Rebellion and the Heyin Incident in terms of class struggle, see the Six Garrisons Rebellion as a revolt of garrison people against aristocratic principles, or regard the Heyin Incident as having the character of a clash between two cultures.[4]
Another line of research distinguishes the strongmen and chieftains of the garrisons from the lower-ranking garrison people, regarding Erzhu Rong as a tribal aristocrat within the Northern Wei state and the fiercest enemy of the garrison people, with both the garrison strongmen and the Erzhu holding to the Wei dynasty; yet another notes that Emperor Xiaozhuang and Erzhu Rong both came from the palace guard and sees the incident as a planned action by the Luoyang guards, Emperor Xiaozhuang and the Erzhu group to clear out the dukes and ministers of Luoyang.[4]
A study published in 2012 argues that Erzhu Rong and Yuan Ziyou both belonged to a party loyal to Emperor Xiaoming and shared the aim of avenging him; that the Heyin Incident was not a continuation of the Six Garrisons Rebellion but an unplanned event; that the palace guards themselves were killed or scattered afterwards and were unlikely to have joined the massacre out of opposition to sinicization; and that the Erzhu distinguished the arrogant and extravagant officials of Luoyang, whom they eliminated, from Emperor Xiaowen himself, whom they revered.[4]
The closing assessment of the biography of Erzhu Rong in the Book of Wei also holds that Erzhu Rong at first coveted the throne, that Empress Dowager Ling and the young emperor “sank in the stream and did not return” and that at Heyin “the officials of the court were trampled into the earth,” and that this is why he offended men and spirits and ended by being put to death; had he been free of treachery and cruelty and cultivated virtue and righteousness, the famous ministers of antiquity who upheld their sovereigns would not have been worth mentioning beside him.[9]
Sources17 sources
- 理想人生的新向度──北朝隋代在家女性墓誌中的信仰描述 [New dimensions of the ideal life: descriptions of faith in epitaphs of lay women of the Northern Dynasties and Sui] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)www2.ihp.sinica.edu.tw↑
- 從政治史看北魏毆主傷胎案 [Viewing the Northern Wei case of assaulting a ruler and causing miscarriage through political history] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)lib.eduhk.hk↑
- Wei dynasty (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
- 河陰之變新探:以尒朱榮為中心的討論 [A New Interpretation of the He Yin Incident: A Discussion Centered upon Er-Ju Rong] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)ah.lib.nccu.edu.tw↑
- 魏書 卷十三 [Book of Wei, juan 13] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 魏書 卷二十一 [Book of Wei, juan 21] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 資治通鑑 卷一百五十二 [Zizhi Tongjian, juan 152] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 洛陽伽藍記 卷一 [Record of the Buddhist Monasteries of Luoyang, juan 1] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 魏書 卷七十四 [Book of Wei, juan 74] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 魏書 卷十 [Book of Wei, juan 10] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 北史 卷五 [History of the Northern Dynasties, juan 5] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 北魏孝荘帝代爾朱氏軍閥集団再論(4)-王都-覇府体制を焦点にして- [The Erzhu Military Clique under Emperor Xiaozhuang of the Northern Wei Reconsidered (4)] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)u-ryukyu.repo.nii.ac.jp↑
- 魏書 卷十九 [Book of Wei, juan 19] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 洛陽伽藍記 卷四 [Record of the Buddhist Monasteries of Luoyang, juan 4] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
- 北魏孝荘帝代爾朱氏軍閥集団再論(1)-王都-覇府体制を焦点にして- [The Erzhu Military Clique under Emperor Xiaozhuang of the Northern Wei Reconsidered (1)] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)u-ryukyu.repo.nii.ac.jp↑
- 孝文崇拜與東魏政治 [Worship of Emperor Xiaowen and the Politics of the Eastern Wei] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)history.nccu.edu.tw↑
- 河陰之變受害北魏宗室墓誌所見的追贈現象與意義 [The Phenomenon and the Significance of the Posthumously Conferred Titles in Royals’ Epitaphs in the Hoyin Rebellion] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)lawdata.com.tw↑