ABAB Pedia

Erzhu Rong

Erzhu Rong (493–530), courtesy name Tianbao, was a powerful minister at the end of the Northern Wei, born into a family of Qihu (Jie) tribal chieftains in Northern Xiurong. He rose during the Six Garrisons RebellionSix Garrisons RebellionThe Six Garrisons Rebellion was a large-scale rising of the people of Northern Wei’s northern frontier garrisons at the end of the dynasty. Wei had set up garrisons south of the Yin Mountains to defend against the Rouran; the six principal ones, Woye, Huaishuo, Wuchuan, Fuming, Rouxuan and Huaihuang, were called the Six Garrisons, and their people lost standing after Emperor Xiaowen moved the capital to Luoyang and pursued Sinicization. The rising began, by one account, with a revolt of the Huaihuang garrison people in 523, by another with the rising of Poliuhan Baling of Woye in 524, and spread to the other garrisons, Guanzhong and Hebei, where Du Luozhou, Xianyu Xiuli, Ge Rong, Hu Chen and Moqi Chounu rose in turn. Erzhu Rong defeated Ge Rong in 528, and the rebellion was largely suppressed by 530. Gao Huan and Yuwen Tai, both men of the six garrisons, went on to control the Eastern and Western Wei, into which Northern Wei split in 534.Open the full entry by raising an army with his own wealth and suppressing risings; after Emperor Xiaoming was poisoned by Empress Dowager Hu’s faction in 528 he marched on Luoyang, enthroned Yuan Ziyou as Emperor Xiaozhuang and carried out the Heyin IncidentHeyin IncidentThe Heyin Incident was the slaughter at Heyin, on the thirteenth day of the fourth month of the first year of Wutai of the Northern Wei (528), of the princes and officials who had come to welcome the new sovereign, Emperor Xiaozhuang (Yuan Ziyou), carried out by the warlord Erzhu Rong; accounts put the dead at more than two thousand or at more than one thousand three hundred. On the same day the regent Empress Dowager Hu and the infant ruler she had enthroned, Yuan Zhao, were drowned in the Yellow River. Erzhu Rong then dominated the Northern Wei court until Emperor Xiaozhuang had him killed in 530; the dynasty was left with weak sovereigns and strong ministers and soon split into the Eastern and Western Wei.Open the full entry, killing the empress dowager, the child emperor and a great many court officials. Made Prince of Taiyuan, he controlled the government from his base at Jinyang, went on to defeat Ge Rong and Yuan Hao and was named pillar of heaven grand general; in 530 Emperor Xiaozhuang had him killed in the Mingguang Hall, and the Erzhu clan was later destroyed by Gao Huan.

Contents24 sections
Key facts

Birth and Origins

Erzhu Rong, courtesy name Tianbao, was born in the 17th year of the Taihe reign of the Northern Wei (493). He was of Jie stock and belonged to the Qihu; his family had for generations been tribal chieftains settled in Northern Xiurong (around present-day Shuo County, Shanxi), heading a powerful body of tribespeople, and were also great ranch owners.⁠[1][1][1][2][3]

Xiurong was a barren land of a single county, and Erzhu Rong’s following at first numbered only a few thousand.⁠[4][5]

The Erzhu’s forebears lived on the Erzhu River and took their surname from it, and for generations they led tribes as chieftains. Erzhu Rong’s great-great-grandfather Erzhu Yujian became a chief of tribespeople at the beginning of the Dengguo reign, led 1,700 Qihu warriors in the train of Taizu to take Jinyang and Zhongshan, and for his merit was made regular attendant cavalier; an edict granted him a tract three hundred li square on the Xiurong River to live on as a hereditary holding. Taizu at first wished him to settle on the fertile plain of Southern Xiurong, but Yujian replied that his family had long served at the ruler’s side and that Northern Xiurong lay inside the frontier and nearer the capital, so he would not move far away for the sake of better land, and Taizu agreed. At his settlement a dog once licked the ground, and digging there yielded a sweet spring, afterwards called the Dog-Licking Spring. Yujian died in the reign of Shizu.⁠[2][3]

Erzhu Rong’s great-grandfather was named Yude and his grandfather Daiqin, and they in turn served as chiefs of tribespeople. Daiqin was a maternal uncle of Empress Jing’ai of Shizu; as an imperial in-law he took part in many campaigns with distinction, was granted exemption from taxes and labor service for a hundred years and was made general who establishes righteousness. Once, while hunting in a ring around a hill, one of his tribesmen shot at an animal and hit him in the thigh by mistake; Daiqin merely had the arrow pulled out and never pursued the matter, saying it had been an accident and he could not bear to punish it, and his people were moved when they heard of this. At the end of Gaozong’s reign he was made acting general who pacifies the south and governor of Sizhou, and Gaozu gave him the title of Duke of Liang commandery. After he retired in old age the court gave him a hundred bolts of silk every year. He died at 91; the court granted five hundred bolts of silk and two hundred of cloth, posthumously named him general who guards the south and governor of Bingzhou, and gave him the posthumous name Zhuang; early in Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign, because of Erzhu Rong’s part in enthroning the emperor, he was further posthumously made grand preceptor, minister over the masses and overseer of the Department of State Affairs. By another account the tribesman was shooting at a tiger, and Daiqin died at over ninety.⁠[2][3]

Erzhu Rong’s father, Xinxing, succeeded as chieftain in the Taihe years; the family had long been powerful in its district and was rich in goods. Once, inspecting his horse herds, Xinxing saw a white snake with two horns on its head moving in front of the horses and said to it that if it had divine power it should make his herds flourish. From then on his herds grew day by day; his cattle, sheep, camels and horses were kept in separate herds by color and could only be measured by the valleyful, or by another account they filled the valleys beyond counting. Whenever the court went to war Xinxing presented horses of his own and provided grain and supplies for the army; Gaozu commended him and made him general of the right and grand master of splendid happiness. After the capital moved to Luoyang he was specially allowed to attend court in the capital in winter and return to his tribe in summer; each time he came to court the princes and grandees vied to give him rare treasures, and he gave fine horses in return. He was later made regular attendant cavalier, general who pacifies the north and first chief of tribespeople of Xiurong. Every spring and autumn he reviewed his herds by the rivers and marshes with his wife and children and amused himself with hunting. In Suzong’s reign, citing his age, he asked to pass his title to Erzhu Rong, and the court agreed. He died in the Zhengguang years at 74 and was posthumously made regular attendant cavalier, general who pacifies the north and governor of Hengzhou, with the posthumous name Jian; early in Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign he was further posthumously granted the yellow axe and made palace attendant, grand preceptor, chancellor of state and Prince of Xihe commandery.⁠[2][3]

Erzhu Rong was fair-skinned and handsome, quick-witted and decisive from childhood; as he grew up he loved archery and hunting, and whenever he set up a hunting ring he bound his men by oath and ran it by the rules of battle formation, with strict commands that no one dared to break. Within Xiurong there were three pools high in the mountains, clear and of unfathomable depth, traditionally called the Qilian Pools, which in the Wei language means Heavenly Pools. Once, when Xinxing and Erzhu Rong were at the pools, they suddenly heard the sound of pipes and drums; Xinxing told him that by old tradition anyone who heard this sound would rise to the highest offices of state, and that since he himself was now old it would come true for his son, who should strive for it.⁠[2][3]

Raising Volunteers and the Campaign against the Rouran

After Emperor Xiaoming took personal charge of the government the reign name was changed to Zhengguang. During the Zhengguang years Erzhu Rong, then a palace guard officer and general of roving cavalry, returned to Xiurong to raise volunteers. In the fourth year of Zhengguang the emperor granted him a tally of delegated authority and appointed him general of the capped army and detached commander under the commander-in-chief Li Chong in a northern campaign against the Rouran.⁠[4][2]

In the same year (the fourth year of Zhengguang, 523) the Northern Wei campaign against the Rouran failed and the northern frontier garrisons were struck by famine, and the garrison people rose in arms, marking the beginning of the Six Garrisons Rebellion; by another account the rebellion began in the fifth year of Zhengguang (524) with the rising of Poliuhan Baling of the Woye garrison, which spread to all six garrisons and reached Shaanxi and Gansu.⁠[6][6]

Erzhu Rong took up the posts of palace guard officer and general of roving cavalry after inheriting his father’s title, and when he gathered volunteers he supplied them with clothing and horses. On the northern campaign, when the Rouran ruler Anagui was raiding the northern frontier, Erzhu Rong pursued him with the 4,000 men he had newly raised, crossed the desert, failed to catch him and returned.⁠[2]

Rise during the Six Garrisons Rebellion

When the Six Garrisons Rebellion broke out, Erzhu Rong formed an army with his private wealth and campaigned against risings in many places; he distinguished himself in battle as a general, rose by force of arms and steadily grew in power.⁠[1][1][1][2][3]

He held palace-guard posts such as general of the palace gate and general of the martial guard, and was later promoted to general of the guard of the right; by one account the Northern Wei court, seeking to win him over, appointed him in turn general of roving cavalry, general of the capped army, general who pacifies the north and commander of the northern circuit, and then grand commander over the military affairs of the six provinces of Bing, Si, Fen, Guang, Heng and Yun.⁠[4][7][2]

In this period he submitted three memorials asking to march against the Six Garrisons rebels. As his power grew the court could no longer control him and came to fear him; some researchers think that “the court” here means Empress Dowager Hu.⁠[4][2]

Fei Mu, who had served under Li Chong in the Six Garrisons Rebellion, abandoned his town and joined Erzhu Rong at Xiurong; the two had known each other before. Gao Huan, a junior officer from the Huaishuo garrison who had taken part in the Six Garrisons Rebellion, joined Erzhu Rong after moving from one warlord to another and became one of his leading commanders; Heba Yue and Heba Yun joined him early.⁠[4][8][8][9][3]

In this period he put down a series of risings one after another: Qifu Moyu, of the Hu people who had submitted at Xiurong, stormed a commandery seat and killed its governor; Wanzi Qizhen, a herdsman of Southern Xiurong, rose and killed the chamberlain for the imperial stud, Lu Yan; and Suhe Polunxian, a herdsman of Bingzhou, also rose; Wanzi Qizhen was put down on the dingyou day of the eighth month of Zhengguang 5. He was then promoted to general of the palace gate and general of the capped army, remaining a detached commander. When Liu Aru and others of the Qibuluojian Hu, who had submitted and then rebelled, rose in the Guasi area, and Beilie Buruo of the Chile rose at Woyang, Erzhu Rong destroyed them all; for this he was made founding marquis of Anping county with a fief of 1,000 households, and soon also regular attendant cavalier with concurrent duties. When Jielü Luoyang of the Chile rose west of the Sanggan and acted in concert with the Feiyetou herdsmen, Erzhu Rong led cavalry to defeat Jielü Luoyang at Shenjing and drove the herdsmen west of the Yellow River; he was advanced to general who pacifies the north and grand master of splendid happiness and made acting general who secures the north and commander of the northern circuit. Soon after he became general of the martial guard and was further made commissioner bearing the tally, general who secures the north, commander of the forces against the rebels in Heng and Shuo, and acting general who comforts the army; he was raised to Duke of Boling commandery with an additional 500 households, and his former title of Duke of Liang commandery was allowed to pass to his second son.⁠[2][10]

When Erzhu Rong arrived at Sizhou with his troops, its governor, Wei Qingbin, fearing and disliking him, shut the gates against him; Erzhu Rong in his anger stormed the city, appointed his father’s cousin Erzhu Yusheng governor and took Wei Qingbin to Xiurong as a prisoner. This took place on the guisi day of the eighth month of Xiaochang 2. He was then made general who guards the north; when Xianyu Xiuli rose, he memorialized asking to campaign east and was advanced to general who campaigns in the east and acting general of chariots and cavalry, and on becoming grand commander of the six provinces he was also made grand master of splendid happiness with gold seal and purple ribbon.⁠[2][10]

Between Emperor Xiaoming and Empress Dowager Hu

Emperor Xiaoming was dominated by his mother, Empress Dowager Hu, and her favorites Zheng Yan and Xu He. In the first year of Xiaochang the empress dowager again took charge of the court and removed the emperor’s confidants, deepening the rift between mother and son. Erzhu Rong’s daughter was one of Emperor Xiaoming’s consorts.⁠[4]

Emperor Xiaoming once planned to lead a campaign in person against Du Luozhou with Erzhu Rong commanding the left army; after Ge Rong absorbed the remnants of Du Luozhou’s followers, Erzhu Rong asked to send 3,000 cavalry east to relieve Xiangzhou, but the emperor did not allow it. Three times the emperor intended to campaign in person against the Six Garrisons rebels, and each time the plan came to nothing.⁠[4][2]

Emperor Xiaoming detested Zheng Yan and Xu He but did not dare to act against them because of the empress dowager; by one account he secretly ordered Erzhu Rong to bring his army to the capital. The emperor summoned Erzhu Rong to Luoyang by private edict and then ordered him to halt at Shangdang, and Erzhu Rong obeyed both orders. Erzhu Rong plotted with Yuan Tianmu and Heba Yue to march on Luoyang, to kill the favorites at court and to suppress the bandits outside; Gao Huan and Heba Yue also urged him to enter the capital and end the empress dowager’s domination.⁠[4][4][11]

About four months before he marched into Luoyang he was appointed general of chariots and cavalry and grand master of splendid happiness of the right, with the rank of “equal in ceremony to the three excellencies”.⁠[4][2][10]

After Ge Rong had absorbed Du Luozhou, Erzhu Rong, fearing that the rebels east of the mountains would break out westward, sent troops to hold Fukou against them and submitted a plan: the court should send an envoy to persuade the Rouran ruler Anagui to send troops east straight to Xiakou and press on the rebels’ rear; the 20,000 men under Yuan Hao, Prince of Beihai, who had been sent to hold Xiangzhou, should keep strict guard and face them in front; and his own men would hold the strong points north of Jingxing and west of the passes and strike at the rebels’ flanks. Ge Rong, he argued, had absorbed Du Luozhou but had not yet won authority or loyalty, and his followers were of different kinds, so they could be split apart. He then put his own troops in strict order, called up volunteers on a wide scale, guarded Mayi in the north and blocked Jingxing in the east.⁠[2]

The Death of Emperor Xiaoming and the March on Luoyang

In 528 Emperor Xiaoming, aged 19, was poisoned by Empress Dowager Hu together with Zheng Yan and Xu He, and the empress dowager placed the three-year-old Yuan Zhao on the throne.⁠[4][12][1][10][11]

On hearing the news Erzhu Rong flew into a rage and declared that he would lead his armored cavalry to the imperial tomb, root out the traitors and set up an adult ruler. In a memorial he demanded that Xu He, Zheng Yan and others be handed over to the judicial officials and that a member of the imperial clan of mature age and proven virtue succeed to the throne; the ruler was to be virtuous, widely known for his good name and of mature age.⁠[4][2]

His force at the time numbered only some 3,000 horsemen, or by another account four to five thousand horsemen when he entered Luoyang; Fei Mu reminded him that his troops did not exceed 10,000. Erzhu Rong set out from Jinyang and marched south on Luoyang.⁠[4][4][4][9][11]

Emperor Xiaoming died in the Xianyang Hall on the guichou day of the second month of Wutai 1; the next day, jiayin, the daughter borne by the consort Pan, falsely announced as a son, was placed on the throne, and Empress Dowager Hu then set up Yuan Zhao, heir of Yuan Baohui, Prince of Lintao, the child ruler acceding on the yimao day. In his defiant memorial Erzhu Rong pointed out that the emperor had been in good health on the twenty-fifth of the previous month and died suddenly on the twenty-sixth, and that no physician had been summoned when he fell ill; the court had passed off Consort Pan’s daughter as a son and then set an infant who could not yet speak over the realm. He asked to come to the capital to take part in the deliberations and to inquire into how the emperor had died. On the yimao day he memorialized asking to come to the mourning and led his troops south; Empress Dowager Hu, greatly alarmed, appointed Li Shengui grand commander to hold him off.⁠[10][2][11]

Enthroning Yuan Ziyou

Erzhu Rong sent his nephew Erzhu Tianguang and Xi Yi to Luoyang to confer secretly with his cousin Erzhu Shilong, who was in the capital, about a candidate for the throne, and they made contact with Yuan Ziyou. Yuan Ziyou, the son of Yuan Xie, Prince of Pengcheng and a younger brother of Emperor Xiaowen, was then 22; he had attended Emperor Xiaoming in the palace, often stood night duty there and enjoyed the emperor’s confidence, but was later pushed aside by Empress Dowager Hu. On this basis some researchers count Erzhu Rong and Yuan Ziyou as members of an emperor’s party loyal to Emperor Xiaoming.⁠[4][4][2][11]

Erzhu Rong had images cast of the descendants of Emperor Xiaowen and of five princes including Yuan Xi, Prince of Xianyang, proclaiming that the one whose image came out whole would be made ruler; only Yuan Ziyou’s image was cast successfully.⁠[4][13]

Erzhu Rong met Yuan Ziyou at Heyang and, after crossing the Yellow River, asked him to take the throne; he became Emperor Xiaozhuang, and the officials came out bearing the imperial seals to welcome him. Empress Dowager Hu then cut off her hair and became a nun, and Zheng Yan and Xu He fled to their home districts. Erzhu Rong became palace attendant and grand general.⁠[4][7][14][15][16]

By one account Erzhu Rong had bronze images cast of the descendants of Emperor Xiaowen and of six princes including Yuan Xi, Prince of Xianyang; by another he had one cast for each of the grandsons of Emperor Xianwen; only the image of Yuan Ziyou, Prince of Changle, came out whole. Besides Erzhu Tianguang and Xi Yi, Erzhu Rong sent his household slave Wang Xiang to Luoyang; Tianguang met Yuan Ziyou, explained Erzhu Rong’s intentions in full, and Yuan Ziyou agreed. When Erzhu Rong’s army had reached Henei he sent Wang Xiang again to fetch him secretly, and Yuan Ziyou, with his elder brother Yuan Shao, Prince of Pengcheng, and his younger brother Yuan Zizheng, Prince of Shiping, slipped across the river at Gaozhu to join him, while Erzhu Rong’s officers and men shouted “Long live the emperor.” By one account this was on the ninth day of the fourth month of Wutai 1; by another Yuan Ziyou crossed north on the night of the bingshen day of the fourth month, met Erzhu Rong at Heyang on the dingyou day and crossed back south of the Yellow River to take the throne on the wuxu day. When Erzhu Rong crossed the river with his army, Empress Dowager Hu summoned all of Emperor Xiaoming’s palace women and ordered them to take religious vows.⁠[2][15][11][16]

The Heyin Incident

On the thirteenth day of the fourth month of the first year of Wutai, Erzhu Rong carried out the Heyin Incident. He assembled the officials who had come out to welcome the new emperor at the place of welcome, announced that he would sacrifice to Heaven, surrounded them with cavalry, accused them of causing Emperor Xiaoming’s death and of failing to curb the greed of the court, and ordered them killed; the dead included brothers of Emperor Xiaozhuang.⁠[5][4][2][15]

Empress Dowager Hu and the child emperor Yuan Zhao were taken to Heyin, and Erzhu Rong, ignoring the empress dowager’s pleas, had both of them thrown into the Yellow River; by one account he first sent troops into the Yongning Monastery and had the two taken from there to Heyin.⁠[4][5][12][7][16][11]

By one account more than 2,000 court officials were killed, by another more than 1,300; some researchers take the total number of dead to be about 2,000, of whom about 1,300 were officials.⁠[4][1][12][13][2][15][11]

Erzhu Rong followed the advice of Fei Mu, general of the martial guard, who warned him that his troops numbered fewer than 10,000 and that unless he carried out a great purge and promoted his own followers he would never be able to cross the Taihang Mountains. Murong Shaozong argued that although the empress dowager’s regency had been dissolute and cruel, killing the officials was not a sound plan; Erzhu Rong did not listen to him. Yuan Shun, who had been an outspoken critic of the court, fled and was killed by a tomb keeper, Xianyu Kangnu.⁠[4][4][7][11]

Those killed at Heyin included Yuan Shao, Prince Wushang; Yuan Zizheng, Prince of Shiping; the chancellor Yuan Yong, Prince of Gaoyang; the minister of works Yuan Qin; Yuan Hengzhi, equal in ceremony to the three excellencies; Yuan Lüe, Prince of Dongping (or, by another account, Prince of Yiyang), of the same rank; Yuan Ti, Prince of Guangping; Yuan Shao, Prince of Changshan; Yuan Chao, Prince of Beiping; Yuan Yi, Prince of Rencheng; Yuan Min, Prince of Zhao commandery; Yuan Shuren, Prince of Zhongshan; and Yuan Wen, Prince of Qi commandery. The officials were assembled northwest of the emperor’s traveling palace. Erzhu Rong had earlier told his confidant Murong Shaozong that the gentry of Luoyang were numerous, proud and extravagant and could never be controlled unless they were cut back, and that he meant to kill all the officials when they came out to welcome the emperor. Empress Dowager Hu was later buried by her younger sister at the Shuangling Monastery; only under Emperor Xiaowu was she given a burial with an empress’s rites and the posthumous name Ling.⁠[15][11][2][16]

The Failed Casting and His Plea for Pardon

Before the massacre he ordered that the officials who drafted the abdication edicts be spared and moved Emperor Xiaozhuang into his own camp. He then had a golden image of himself cast to determine whether he should take the throne, and four attempts in a row failed; when Liu Lingzhu, his trusted diviner, explained what this meant, he realized the gravity of his crime, kowtowed to Emperor Xiaozhuang to beg forgiveness and again acknowledged him as ruler.⁠[4][5][13][2][11]

Afterwards he was filled with remorse, knelt before the emperor’s horse and kowtowed, asking to be put to death; he admitted to Gao Huan and Sima Ziru that having erred so gravely he could only atone to the court with his life, and wrote to the emperor that even being ground to dust would not make up for his past offenses or console the dead.⁠[4][2][11]

He memorialized asking that posthumous honors be conferred on those who died at Heyin. On the evidence of the epitaphs of imperial clansmen killed there, a researcher concludes that the posthumous honors usually combined a general’s title with a provincial governor’s title, the general’s title being about two grades above the last one held in life; the scheme Erzhu Rong proposed was not carried out in this round and may have been kept in reserve to reward his own partisans, but by greatly widening the scope and content of posthumous honors it may have encouraged their later excess.⁠[4][17]

Erzhu Rong had the censor Zhao Yuanze draft a document of abdication and sent several dozen men to move Emperor Xiaozhuang to the river bridge, bringing him back to the camp in the fourth watch of the night. The emperor, distressed and helpless, sent word to Erzhu Rong that dynasties rise and fall and fortunes change; that the general had raised a righteous army and swept all before him, which was the will of Heaven; that he himself had come over only to save his life and had never dared to aspire to the throne, but had complied under the general’s pressure; and that if the mandate now rested with the general he should take the imperial title at once, or, if he declined it, might choose another worthy kinsman to support together. At this point the commander Gao Huan urged Erzhu Rong to declare himself emperor, and most of those around him agreed; while Erzhu Rong hesitated, Heba Yue argued that the general had been the first to raise a righteous army in order to destroy the wicked, and that harboring such a design before his great work was done would only hasten disaster. After the castings failed, Erzhu Rong said that if the omens were against him he would set up Yuan Tianmu instead, but Liu Lingzhu replied that Tianmu’s omens were no better and that only the Prince of Changle had the mandate of Heaven. Afterwards Heba Yue asked that Gao Huan be put to death as an apology to the realm; those around Erzhu Rong argued that although Gao Huan was foolish and careless in speech, the realm was in turmoil and military men were needed, and asked that he be spared to prove himself later, and Erzhu Rong let the matter drop.⁠[2][11]

In his memorial asking for posthumous honors for those who died at Heyin, Erzhu Rong proposed that Prince Wushang be honored as emperor; that princes and provincial governors be posthumously made equal to the three excellencies; that officials of the third rank be posthumously made director or vice-director of the Department of State Affairs, those of the fifth rank regional governors, and those of the sixth rank and below and commoners garrison commanders or commandery governors; and that those who died without heirs be allowed adopted successors who would receive titles; by one account the emperor approved this by edict. On the renyin day Erzhu Rong memorialized again asking that Prince Wushang be given the posthumous title of emperor. From then on posthumous honors were handed out to excess, mediocre and lowly men being raised to high office in death, which men of judgment held in contempt, until the Prince Wenxiang of Qi began to correct the abuse in the Wuding years.⁠[2][15]

Entering Luoyang and the Proposal to Move the Capital to Jinyang

After the Heyin Incident he hesitated to enter the capital, waited at Beimang and at one point proposed moving the capital north; Fan Li, general of the martial guard, persuaded him to go in. Once in Luoyang he formally proposed moving the capital to Jinyang, which alarmed the people of Luoyang. When Yuan Shen objected, Erzhu Rong angrily asked what business it was of his to be so stubborn and reminded him of what had happened at Heyin; Yuan Shen was saved only by Erzhu Shilong’s intercession. A few days later, after seeing the palaces of Luoyang, Erzhu Rong dropped the idea. Emperor Xiaozhuang swore an oath with him in the Mingguang Hall as a pledge of trust.⁠[4][9]

Emperor Xiaozhuang entered the palace on the fourteenth day of the fourth month of Wutai 1. Rumors spread that Erzhu Rong meant to move the capital to Jinyang, or that he would let his troops loose to plunder; the capital was gripped by fear, almost all the gentry fled into hiding and none dared to come out, and the palace guard posts and government offices stood empty. On learning of this Erzhu Rong asked the emperor to send envoys around the city to reassure the people, whereupon calm returned and the officials who had fled gradually came back to court. He also proposed that on the first and fifteenth of each month the three excellencies, the director and vice-directors of the Department of State Affairs, the ministers, the nine chamberlains, the governor of Sizhou, the intendant of Henan and the officials in charge at Luoyang and Heyin be received in turn to discuss affairs of state, as a regular practice. On the xinyou day of the fifth month he returned to Jinyang, and the emperor saw him off at Mangyin.⁠[2][15]

Prince of Taiyuan and His Offices

After Emperor Xiaozhuang’s accession Erzhu Rong was made commissioner bearing the tally, palace attendant, commander-in-chief of all military affairs inside and outside the capital, grand general with his own headquarters, acting director of the Department of State Affairs, general commanding the army and commander of the imperial guards, and was enfeoffed as Prince of Taiyuan with a fief of 20,000 households; later he was also made pillar of state grand general and acting overseer of the Department of State Affairs. With Jinyang as his base he controlled the government. By one account he was made Prince of Taiyuan in the fourth month of 528, having lived until then in the residence of Wang Chun in Jinyang county of Taiyuan commandery, and in the fifth month of the same year he became grand branch secretariat of the northern circuit.⁠[4][1][9][2][15]

Fei Mu was rewarded for his part at Heyin with the posts of general of the central army and minister of personnel, the title of founding marquis of Lu county with a fief of 800 households, and the office of grand rectifier of Xiazhou.⁠[4]

These offices were conferred on the eleventh day of the fourth month of Wutai 1 (by another reckoning the jihai day), when Erzhu Rong acknowledged Emperor Xiaozhuang as ruler; on the gengxu day of the fourth month his second son, Chaluo, was made Prince of Liang commandery. In the seventh month of that year an edict declared that his service in raising the emperor to the throne surpassed that of Yi Yin and Huo Guang and that the royal house owed its survival to him, and made him pillar of state grand general and acting overseer of the Department of State Affairs.⁠[2][15]

His Daughter Made Empress

Erzhu Rong’s daughter had been a consort of Emperor Xiaoming. Erzhu Rong wanted her made Emperor Xiaozhuang’s empress, and Zu Ying, pointing to precedent, urged the emperor to agree, to Erzhu Rong’s great satisfaction; by another account Erzhu Rong forced the emperor to make her empress.⁠[4][4][7][11]

Zu Ying, then gentleman of the yellow gate, cited the precedent of Huai Ying, who entered the service of Duke Wen of Jin while he was in Qin, arguing that the step departed from the norm yet accorded with right.⁠[11]

The Defeat of Ge Rong

Erzhu Rong then, from his base at Jinyang, put down the rising of Ge Rong; by one account he scattered Ge Rong’s host of a million. By one account he defeated Ge Rong near Xiangzhou in the ninth month of 528, leading the left army in concert with Yuan Tianmu’s forces. Hou Jing captured Ge Rong in the campaign and was afterwards promoted to grand branch secretariat and governor of Dingzhou; Ge Rong was sent to the capital, where Emperor Xiaozhuang wished to see him.⁠[1][4][9][4][2][15][11]

After Ge Rong’s defeat more than 200,000 of his followers drifted into Bingzhou and Sizhou. Han Lou, leader of Ge Rong’s remaining followers, held Youzhou and Pingzhou, and Erzhu Rong sent Hou Yuan to destroy him; by one account Hou Yuan disposed of Han Lou in the seventh month of 529. Hou Yuan had also fought against Ge Rong.⁠[5][4][9][2]

For defeating Ge Rong he was further made grand chancellor and commander-in-chief of military affairs north of the Yellow River and outside the capital region, and grand preceptor, and his fief was increased.⁠[4][2][15]

Ge Rong’s host, said to number a million, was advancing on the capital; Li Shengui, governor of Xiangzhou, shut his gates and stood on the defensive, the rebels’ vanguard had passed Ji commandery and the fortified villages along the way had all been plundered. Erzhu Rong asked to campaign against him, and in the ninth month he set out with 7,000 picked horsemen, each with a spare mount, and marched at double speed east through Fukou, with Hou Jing as his vanguard. Ge Rong, delighted at the news, told his men to bring long ropes to tie up the enemy when they arrived, and drew up his army in a line several dozen li long north of Ye, advancing with spread wings. Erzhu Rong hid troops in the valleys as a surprise force, posting commanders three to a place with several hundred horsemen each, and had them raise dust and beat drums everywhere so that the enemy could not tell their numbers; and since in close fighting a club was better than a sword, he secretly ordered every horseman to carry a club at his horse’s side, to strike with it and not to stop to take heads, so that the pursuit would not be slowed. He charged into the enemy line himself and broke out behind it; attacked front and rear, Ge Rong’s army was routed, Ge Rong was captured on the field and the rest of his followers all surrendered. Judging that so many people, if divided up at once, might take fright and band together again, Erzhu Rong announced that each could go where he pleased and settle with his kin wherever he wished; the several hundred thousand dispersed in a single day, and only when they were a hundred li away were they divided along separate routes under escort and settled where convenient, each suitably placed, while their leaders were promoted and given posts that suited their abilities; people of the time admired the speed and skill of his arrangements. After the battle at Fukou on the renshen day of the ninth month, an amnesty was proclaimed on the yihai day for the pacification of Ge Rong and the reign name was changed to Yong’an; on the dinghai day of the tenth month Ge Rong was brought to the capital in a cage cart and, with the emperor present at the Changhe Gate, kowtowed and begged forgiveness before being beheaded in the marketplace.⁠[2][15][11]

On the way to fight Ge Rong, while his army was camped at Xiangyuan, Erzhu Rong had his men form a ring for a great hunt; when two hares started up in front of his horse he spurred forward, drew his bow and vowed that if he hit them he would capture Ge Rong and if not he would fail; both fell at the twang of the bowstring, the whole army rejoiced, and after the victory he had a stele set up on the spot, called the Stele of the Two Hares. On the night before the battle he dreamed that a man demanded a qianniu sword from Ge Rong; Ge Rong at first refused, but the man said he was Emperor Daowu and asked how Ge Rong dared disobey, whereupon Ge Rong handed it over and the man gave it to Erzhu Rong, who woke delighted and sure of victory. After the victory the court made 10,000 households in each of seven commanderies, Changle in Jizhou, Nanzhao in Xiangzhou, Boling in Dingzhou, Fuyang in Cangzhou, Liaoxi in Pingzhou, Shanggu in Yanzhou and Yuyang in Youzhou, together with his earlier fief a full 100,000 households, the fief of the state of Taiyuan, and raised him to grand preceptor.⁠[2][15]

Ruling from Jinyang

Erzhu Rong controlled the Luoyang court from Jinyang and decided official appointments, while Yuan Tianmu and Erzhu Shilong managed affairs in Luoyang. Erzhu Zhongyuan, as grand branch secretariat of the three Xu provinces and governor of Xuzhou, sent all the taxes east of Xingyang to his own army.⁠[4][18][18][9][9][2][11]

He asked Emperor Xiaozhuang to appoint northerners as governors of the provinces south of the Yellow River and was angered when the emperor refused; he also appointed a magistrate of Quyang county without the consent of the minister of personnel, Li Shenjun.⁠[9][4][2]

He placed his relatives all around the emperor to watch what went on, so that nothing large or small escaped him; men seeking office by favor all went to wait on him, and whatever he requested was granted. Even his humblest envoys to the capital were fawned upon by the grandees of the court, and if one of them was not announced at once at the palace gate he would fly into a rage, relying on Erzhu Rong’s power.⁠[2]

Erzhu Rong was frivolous in manner and loved riding and shooting; when he came to court he did nothing but play at mounting and dismounting and hold shooting banquets in the Xilin Park, regularly asking the empress to come out and watch and gathering the princes, consorts and princesses together in one hall. Whenever the emperor hit the mark he would leap up, dance and shout, and the generals, ministers and officials all whirled around with him, even the consorts and princesses having to raise their sleeves and join in; when the wine was flowing he would sit upright and sing songs of the northern peoples, and when the party broke up at dusk he would leave hand in hand with his attendants, stamping and singing the Huibo song. He was harsh and violent by nature, unpredictable in his moods and never without his sword, lance or bow; whenever something displeased him he would shoot or strike at those around him, who lived in constant fear of death. Once, seeing two novice monks riding one horse, he ordered them to butt each other, and when they were too exhausted to move he had bystanders knock their heads together until they died.⁠[11]

Erzhu Rong was passionately fond of hunting in all seasons; when the ring advanced it had to keep a perfect line, no one might turn aside even before obstacles, and anyone through whose section a tiger or leopard escaped was put to death, so that his men suffered greatly. The grand steward Yuan Tianmu once calmly advised him that since his great deeds had saved the realm and all was quiet, he should attend to government, let the people recover and hunt only in season, rather than racing about in the height of summer and upsetting the harmony of nature. Erzhu Rong rolled up his sleeves and replied that the empress dowager, a woman ruler, had been unable to govern herself, so that supporting the Son of Heaven was simply a subject’s duty; that Ge Rong and his like were slaves who had taken advantage of the times, like runaway servants to be caught and done with; and that although he had lately received great favor from the state he had not yet extended its borders or unified the realm, so it was too early to speak of merit. He proposed that in the autumn he and Tianmu would muster their troops for a great hunt on the Song plain, making the corrupt grandees of the court enter the ring to fight tigers, then march out by Luyang through the three Jing provinces, take in the unsubdued Man tribes to fill the Six Garrisons in the north, and put down the Fen Hu on the way back; the following year they would pick their best horsemen and send them out across the Yangtze and Huai: if Xiao Yan submitted he could be made a marquis of ten thousand households, and if not a few thousand horsemen would cross the river and bring him back in bonds; once the realm was united and at peace, the two of them would escort the Son of Heaven on tours of the four quarters to observe customs and spread good government, and only then could they speak of merit. If he stopped hunting now, he said, his soldiers would grow slack and become useless.⁠[2]

Yuan Hao in Luoyang and the Recovery of the Capital

The Liang dynasty in the south sent Chen Qingzhi with 5,000 troops to escort Yuan Hao north; Yuan Hao advanced on Luoyang with a light force and Emperor Xiaozhuang hurriedly took leave of the ancestral temple and fled. Yuan Hao depended on Chen Qingzhi’s troops to resist Erzhu Rong. Gao Daomu advised the emperor to cross the Yellow River northward rather than flee into Guanzhong, to summon Yuan Tianmu to Xingyang and Hulao and to ask Erzhu Rong to come to Henei. Fei Mu went over to Yuan Hao, who later executed him over the Heyin massacre.⁠[5][4][4]

By one account Erzhu Rong left Jinyang in the fifth month of 529 to campaign against Yuan Hao, summoned Heba Sheng to deal with him and left Erzhu Tianguang in charge of the branch secretariat of nine provinces; Yuan Hao was driven out of Luoyang in the seventh month of the same year. Erzhu Rong in the end put Yuan Hao to death and also killed Xing Gao, and for these deeds was made pillar of heaven grand general, a title without precedent; Emperor Xiaozhuang later refused to grant him the nine bestowals.⁠[18][9][9][4][4][2][15]

Yuan Hao, Prince of Beihai, had fled south to Xiao Yan at the beginning of the Jianyi reign, and Xiao Yan made him ruler of Wei and gave him troops and generals; at the time Xing Gao had risen in the three Qi regions in concert with him, but the court thought Yuan Hao isolated and weak and paid him little attention. The court ordered the grand general Yuan Tianmu first to pacify the Qi lands and then turn back against Yuan Hao; taking advantage of the main army’s absence, Yuan Hao took Liang commandery and marched west, Xingyang and Hulao both fell, and in the fifth month the emperor left for the region north of the Yellow River. On hearing the news Erzhu Rong hurried by post relay to the emperor’s traveling palace at Zhangzi in Shangdang and took charge of the dispositions; the emperor then turned south with Erzhu Rong as his vanguard, and within ten days troops, provisions and weapons had gathered one after another; Yuan Tianmu, having put down Xing Gao, also crossed the river to join them. Zongzheng Zhensun, Yuan Hao’s commander, and Yuan Xi, governor of Henei, held out and refused to surrender; Erzhu Rong took Henei and beheaded both as a warning. Facing Yuan Hao across the Yellow River, where Yuan Hao had his commander Yuan Yanming, Prince of Anfeng, hold the bank, Erzhu Rong had no boats and could not cross, and proposed withdrawing north to try again later, but the gentlemen of the yellow gate Yang Kan and Gao Daomu insisted that withdrawing would lose the realm’s confidence. Then members of the Yang family of Mazhu said they had several small boats and offered to act as guides, and Erzhu Rong sent the commander Erzhu Zhao and others across by night with picked horsemen; landing, they attacked and routed the 5,000 foot and horse led by Yuan Hao’s son Yuan Guanshou, general commanding the army, capturing him on the field; Yuan Yanming’s men then scattered and Yuan Hao fled south with his followers. The emperor crossed the river and took up residence in the Hualin Park.⁠[2][15]

Along with the title of pillar of heaven grand general Erzhu Rong received front and rear units of feathered canopies, drums and wind music, and an additional 100,000 households, bringing his fief to 200,000; the edict acknowledged that the office was unknown in antiquity and cited the precedent of such a title having been created before Taizu. The emperor then feasted Erzhu Rong, Yuan Tianmu, Prince of Shangdang, and the commanders who had come from the north at the Duting pavilion. In this war Erzhu Shicheng, younger brother of Erzhu Shilong, was captured by Yuan Hao and cut to pieces; after the emperor returned to the palace he was posthumously made commissioner bearing the tally, commander of the military affairs of Jizhou, general of agile cavalry, minister over the masses and governor of Jizhou, and Duke of Zhao commandery.⁠[2][15][19]

Pacifying the Northwest

Erzhu Rong sent Erzhu Tianguang with Heba Yue and Houmochen Yue into Guanzhong against Moqi Chounu, and had Tianguang beaten for advancing too slowly. By one account Tianguang set out in the second month of 530 and defeated Moqi Chounu in the fourth month of that year. Moqi Chounu and Xiao Baoyin were captured and sent to the capital in cages; Tianguang also captured Wang Qingyun and Moqi Daoluo, and it was said that the great disorder of the realm was now at an end.⁠[4][4][9][2]

By 530 Erzhu Rong had largely brought the Six Garrisons Rebellion to an end; by another account he had already put it down in the first year of Wutai (528).⁠[6][1][6]

Erzhu Tianguang had been made governor of Yongzhou. On reaching Yongzhou he held back because his troops were too few, and Erzhu Rong, enraged, sent his cavalry adjutant Liu Gui by post horse to the army to have Tianguang caned; Tianguang and the others, badly frightened, then advanced and won one victory after another.⁠[2]

Killed in the Mingguang Hall

Emperor Xiaozhuang resented Erzhu Rong’s high-handedness, saw him as a threat and likened him to Dong Zhuo at the end of the Eastern Han, and plotted with his close officials to remove him. The plotters included imperial clansmen and Han officials such as Yuan Hui, Prince of Chengyang, the palace attendant Yang Kan, Li Yu and the right vice-director of the Department of State Affairs Yuan Luo, as well as Wen Zisheng; Yuan Hui held that even if Erzhu Rong did not rebel, he was not to be endured.⁠[1][1][4][9][2][20]

On the fifteenth day of the ninth month of the third year of Yong’an, Yuan Tianmu arrived in the capital; on the eighteenth day the emperor summoned Wen Zisheng and asked him about how Wang Yun had killed Dong Zhuo. On the twenty-fifth day Erzhu Rong and Yuan Tianmu entered the palace, and the emperor had Erzhu Rong killed in the Mingguang Hall; Yuan Tianmu was killed with him. The tablet Erzhu Rong carried bore the names of people he intended to remove.⁠[4][1][20]

The emperor had been unable to act earlier because Yuan Tianmu was stationed in Bingzhou. In an edict issued after the killing the emperor wrote that Erzhu Rong’s merits could be weighed against his faults.⁠[4][4][2][15]

Over the matter of appointing northerners to the provinces south of the Yellow River, Yuan Tianmu came in and told the emperor to his face that since the pillar of heaven general had done such great service, even if he asked to replace every official in the realm the emperor could probably not refuse him, let alone a request for a few provincial posts. The emperor replied sternly that if the pillar of heaven general would not remain a subject, then even the emperor himself would have to be replaced, but if he still kept a subject’s loyalty there was no reason to replace all the officials of the realm. Hearing this, Erzhu Rong was furious and said, “Through whom did the Son of Heaven gain his throne? And now he will not heed my words.” Pressed from outside by Erzhu Rong, the emperor was constantly unhappy; mindful of what had happened at Heyin, he feared he could not survive in the end, and Yuan Hui, Prince of Chengyang, the palace attendant Li Yu and others, who wanted power for themselves and feared Erzhu Rong would harm them, kept sowing discord, so that the emperor secretly resolved to do away with him.⁠[2]

The empress, Erzhu Rong’s daughter, was jealous by nature and often flew into rages; when the emperor sent Erzhu Shilong to reason with her, she said that the Son of Heaven had been set up by her family and now behaved like this, and that her father could have made himself emperor in the first place and could still decide to do so. Shilong said that Erzhu Rong had simply chosen not to, for had he done so, Shilong himself would already be a prince. Pressed by Erzhu Rong from outside and by the empress within, the emperor was constantly unhappy and took no pleasure in being Son of Heaven. Erzhu Rong’s youngest daughter was married to the emperor’s nephew Yuan Kuan, Prince of Chenliu, and Erzhu Rong once pointed at Yuan Kuan and said that in the end he would get the benefit of this son-in-law; Yuan Hui told the emperor that Erzhu Rong feared the emperor would eventually threaten him, so that if there were a crown prince he would surely want to set up the infant, and if the empress bore no son he would set up the Prince of Chenliu. The emperor once dreamed that he cut off his own ten fingers with a knife, and it troubled him. Erzhu Rong asked to come to court to see the empress give birth, and Yuan Hui and the others urged the emperor to have him stabbed when he came, using the birth of a prince as the pretext to bring him in; the emperor objected that the empress was only nine months pregnant, but Yuan Hui said that many women gave birth before their time and that Erzhu Rong would not suspect anything.⁠[20]

In the ninth month of Yong’an 3 Erzhu Rong asked to come to court; the officials feared he would cause trouble, and the emperor too dreaded and disliked him. Erzhu Shilong wrote urging him not to come, and his wife, the Grand Princess of Beixiang commandery, also urged him not to go, but he would not listen to either. After he reached Luoyang someone warned him that the emperor meant to strike at him; he reported this to the emperor, who answered that people also said Erzhu Rong wanted to harm him, and asked how he could believe such talk; Erzhu Rong then put aside his suspicions, and each time he went to see the emperor he took no more than a few dozen attendants, all unarmed. Erzhu Rong and Yuan Tianmu came from Jinyang to court on the xinmao day of the ninth month; on the wuxu day the emperor hid soldiers in the eastern gallery of the Mingguang Hall, announced that a prince had been born, sent Yuan Hui riding to Erzhu Rong’s residence with the news, and called in Erzhu Rong with his eldest son, Erzhu Puti, and Yuan Tianmu. When they were seated, Lu An, vice-chamberlain for attendants, and the steward Li Kanxi came in with drawn swords; Erzhu Rong leapt up and lunged toward the emperor’s seat, but the emperor, who had laid a sword across his knees beforehand, stabbed him with his own hand, and Lu An and the others hacked at him; Erzhu Rong, Yuan Tianmu and Erzhu Puti died together. Erzhu Rong was 38. Erzhu Yangdu, general of chariots and cavalry, and some thirty others who had followed him into the palace were also killed by the hidden soldiers. The emperor said that had the fellow lived past this day he could never have been controlled. Cries of joy rose inside and outside the palace and filled the city of Luoyang, and an amnesty was proclaimed.⁠[2][15][20]

The edict issued afterwards granted that Erzhu Rong had not been without merit when he first raised his army and that putting down Ge Rong and coming to the emperor’s aid against Yuan Hao could make up for his faults, but charged that at Heyin he had been ruthless and without regard for kin, leaving princes, ministers and officials dead in a single morning; that once he stood at the summit of office he credited his success to himself rather than to Heaven, gave and took away at will and acted as though he had no sovereign; and that he was secretly plotting usurpation. It also charged Yuan Tianmu, a distant member of the imperial clan of little standing, with abandoning his loyalty to become Erzhu Rong’s chief counsellor.⁠[15]

The Erzhu Revenge and the Death of Emperor Xiaozhuang

After Erzhu Rong’s death Erzhu Shilong refused the iron pledge offered by Emperor Xiaozhuang and called for revenge; he broke out of the capital and then attacked Luoyang again with reinforcements from Erzhu Zhao. Erzhu Zhao took Luoyang, carried Emperor Xiaozhuang off to Jinyang and killed him there; Gao Huan was unable to prevent it. Husi Chun first joined Yuan Yue, Prince of Runan, who was backed by the Liang, and returned to Erzhu Zhao after Zhao entered Luoyang.⁠[4][4][5][9][21][15]

On the night Erzhu Rong was killed, the vice-director of the Department of State Affairs Erzhu Shilong and the Grand Princess of Beixiang commandery led Erzhu Rong’s retainers in burning the Xiyang Gate and left the city to camp at Heyin; on the jihai day they attacked the river bridge, captured and killed the general of the martial guard Xi Yi and others on the road, seized the Northern Central Fortress and threatened the capital from the north. The court made Erzhu Tianguang palace attendant and equal in ceremony to the three excellencies. On the wushen day of the tenth month a son was born to the emperor and an amnesty was proclaimed; on the yimao day the commander Li Miao burned the river bridge with fire ships and Erzhu Shilong withdrew. On the renshen day Shilong halted at Gaodu in Jianxing, where Erzhu Zhao came from Jinyang to join him, and together they set up Yuan Ye, Prince of Changguang, governor of Taiyuan and acting governor of Bingzhou, as ruler, with the reign name Jianming; Erzhu Zhongyuan, governor of Xuzhou, also marched on the capital. On the bingzi day of the eleventh month the court gave Erzhu Tianguang his own headquarters and raised him to prince; on the dingchou day Erzhu Zhongyuan took Western Yanzhou and captured its governor, Wang Yan, and later defeated Heba Sheng east of Huatai, after which Heba Sheng went over to him. On the jiachen day of the twelfth month Erzhu Zhao and Erzhu Dulü forded the Yellow River with cavalry at Fupingjin and fell on the capital; the palace guard was taken by surprise, the emperor left by the Yunlong Gate, and Erzhu Zhao forced him to the Yongning Monastery, where Zhao killed the emperor’s son as well as the minister over the masses Yuan Yu, Prince of Linhuai, and the left vice-director Yuan Hui, Prince of Fanyang. On the jiayin day Erzhu Zhao moved the emperor to Jinyang, and on the jiazi day the emperor died in the Three-Storied Buddhist Monastery inside the city, aged 24; Yuan Kuan, Prince of Chenliu, was killed at the same time.⁠[15]

The Fall of the Erzhu Clan

Erzhu Zhao and Erzhu Shilong set up first Yuan Ye, Prince of Changguang, and then Yuan Gong (Emperor Jiemin), replacing Yuan Ye with Yuan Gong, and also discussed enthroning Yuan Baoju. After Erzhu Rong’s death Erzhu Tianguang became grand branch secretariat west of the passes, and in 531 he killed Yang Chun.⁠[4][9][9][15]

Gao Huan, a former subordinate of Erzhu Rong, became after Rong’s death the commander of more than 200,000 former rebels held captive by the Erzhu, and obtained more than 100,000 Six Garrisons soldiers from Erzhu Zhao. In the sixth month of the first year of Putai he rose at Xindu in alliance with Han magnates of Hebei such as Gao Qian and Li Yuanzhong of the Bohai commandery, under the banner of avenging Emperor Xiaozhuang; Erzhu Yusheng was killed at Yinzhou and his head was sent to Li Yuanzhong and Gao Qian.⁠[8][8][5][4][21][22]

At the battle of Hanling the troops of Erzhu Dulü fell back after Erzhu Zhao lost confidence in him, and the Erzhu suffered a crushing defeat; Hou Yuan, Husi Chun and others surrendered to Gao Huan after Hanling. The Erzhu were driven out of Luoyang in the fourth month of 532; Heba Yue and Houmochen Yue took Chang’an and absorbed the Wuchuan troops; Hou Jing surrendered to Gao Huan at Dingzhou in 532. Erzhu Zhao was defeated by Gao Huan in the first month of 533, which ended the Erzhu house; by another account the Erzhu were destroyed by Gao Huan in 532.⁠[21][21][18][4][9][1][22][19]

Gao Huan then took control of the Northern Wei and set up Emperor Xiaowu; in 534 Emperor Xiaowu fled to Yuwen Tai in Guanzhong, and Gao Huan enthroned Emperor Xiaojing and moved the capital to Ye, so that the Northern Wei split into the Eastern and Western Wei.⁠[14][8][23]

After the battle of Hanling in Zhongxing 2 the Erzhu leaders fell one after another. Husi Chun, unable to enter the city, tricked the officer Shu Yuan by telling him that Erzhu Tianguang’s men were all westerners who meant to plunder the capital and move it to Chang’an, and that he should let Husi Chun in first to prepare against them; Shu Yuan believed him and let him in. On reaching the bridge Husi Chun killed all of Erzhu Shilong’s partisans and sent the branch secretariat Zhangsun Zhi to report to the court, while the commanders Jia Zhi and Zhang Quan took horsemen to seize Erzhu Shilong and his elder brother Erzhu Yanbo by surprise; both were beheaded outside the Changhe Gate, and their heads were hung on a tree at Husi Chun’s gate and then sent to Gao Huan. Shilong was 33. They were beheaded on the jiazi day, the first of the fourth month of Zhongxing 2, by another account in the city streets.⁠[19][22]

Erzhu Dulü fled west and was captured at the Leibo ford, and Erzhu Tianguang, unable to cross the river, fled northwest, was halted by rain and seized. Husi Chun sent both as prisoners to Gao Huan, who sent them on to Luoyang, where they were beheaded in the marketplace on the yisi day of the sixth month of Taichang 1; Tianguang was 37. Erzhu Zhongyuan, defeated at Hanling, fled south to Dong commandery, went over to Xiao Yan on the yihai day of the fourth month of Zhongxing 2 and died south of the Yangtze. On the same day Erzhu Bi, governor of Qingzhou, was killed by Feng Shaolong, a commander on his staff whom he trusted: after Feng Shaolong had spoken with him, Erzhu Bi sat on a folding chair and had Feng Shaolong hold a knife to “open his heart”, and Feng Shaolong drove the blade in and killed him; his head was sent to the capital. Erzhu Zhao, defeated at Hanling, fled back to Jinyang and plundered the city of Bingzhou; when Gao Huan marched against him from Ye he fled to Xiurong, and on the dingyou day of the first month of Yongxi 2 Gao Huan routed him at the Chihong ridge; his followers surrendered or scattered, and Erzhu Zhao fled into the mountains, killed the horse he was riding and hanged himself from a tree; Gao Huan had him buried.⁠[19][22]

The two rulers the Erzhu had set up also died soon after: the Former Deposed Emperor, Yuan Gong, died in the outer office of the Chancellery on the bingshen day of the fifth month of Taichang 1, aged 35, and Yuan Ye, who had been re-enfeoffed as Prince of Donghai, died on the jiachen day of the eleventh month of Taichang 1, implicated in an affair.⁠[22]

Wife, Children and Relatives

Erzhu Rong’s wife was a lady of the Yuan clan with the title Grand Princess of Beixiang commandery; he was the son-in-law of Yuan Zhen, Prince of Nan’an. The princess held Lady Wei, the wife of Wang Chun, in great honor. His daughter was first a consort of Emperor Xiaoming and later became Emperor Xiaozhuang’s empress.⁠[9][4][4][2][11]

Erzhu Shilong was his cousin and held various posts in the palace army; Erzhu Zhongyuan, Shilong’s brother, was likewise his cousin. Erzhu Zhao was his nephew. Erzhu Tianguang is described as his nephew, or by another account as the son of a second cousin. Yuan Tianmu was his sworn brother.⁠[9][4][4][4][19][2]

Erzhu Rong’s eldest son, Erzhu Puti, became director of the Yulin guards at the end of Suzong’s reign and soon general of the palace gate; early in Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign, because of his father’s part in enthroning the emperor, he was promoted over the usual grades to regular attendant cavalier, general who pacifies the north and director of the Secretariat, then chamberlain for ceremonials, general of agile cavalry and equal in ceremony to the three excellencies with his own headquarters, and was further made palace attendant and specially advanced; he was killed with his father at the age of 14, and early in the reign of the Former Deposed Emperor he was posthumously made palace attendant, general of agile cavalry, minister over the masses and governor of Jizhou, with the posthumous name Hui. Puti’s younger brother Erzhu Chaluo became regular attendant cavalier and general of the martial guard early in Emperor Xiaozhuang’s reign; he first inherited the title of Duke of Liang commandery and was then raised to prince, but died soon after and was posthumously made palace attendant, general of chariots and cavalry, minister of works and governor of Yongzhou. Chaluo’s younger brother Erzhu Wenshu was made founding duke of Pingchang commandery at the beginning of the Jianyi reign and raised to prince; early in Emperor Xiaojing’s reign he inherited his father’s title of Prince of Taiyuan instead, and he died at Jinyang at the age of nine. Wenshu’s younger brother Erzhu Wenchang was first made founding duke of Changle commandery with 2,000 households, was raised to prince with another 1,000 households for his father’s defeat of Ge Rong, was promoted over the usual grades to regular attendant cavalier and general who comforts the army, and was later made governor of Sizhou with his own headquarters and the rank of equal in ceremony to the three excellencies; in the spring of Wuding 3 he was put to death for plotting rebellion with a former governor of Dong commandery and others, aged 18. Wenchang’s younger brother Erzhu Wenlüe inherited the title of Prince of Liang commandery and at the end of the Wuding reign was general who comforts the army and grand master of splendid happiness.⁠[2][15]

Erzhu Rong’s daughter, Emperor Xiaozhuang’s empress, was later taken by Gao Huan as a secondary consort; he treated her with greater respect than Lady Lou, always fastened his sash before seeing her and called himself “your servant”. When Gao Huan brought home a Rouran princess as his bride, she went out north of Mujing to meet them, riding apart from the Rouran princess so that the two did not see each other; the princess drew a horn bow and shot down a soaring kite, and she drew a long bow and brought down a flying crow with a single slanting shot, and Gao Huan said with delight that both his wives were fit to fight the enemy. She later became a Buddhist nun, and Gao Huan built a monastery for her. While in his favor she bore Gao Huan a son, You. At the beginning of the Tianbao reign of the Northern Qi she was honored as grand consort (Grand Consort of Pengcheng); when Emperor Wenxuan, crazed with drink, tried to force himself on her, she refused him and met her ruin. The daughter of Erzhu Rong’s nephew Erzhu Zhao, known as the younger Lady Erzhu, had first been the Jianming empress; Gao Huan also took her, and she bore him the Prince of Rencheng, but soon afterwards, having had an affair with Chen, Duke of Zhao commandery, she was banished to Lingzhou, and she later married Lu Jingzhang of Fanyang.⁠[24]

Erzhu Zhao’s courtesy name was Wanren. Erzhu Yanbo was also a cousin of Erzhu Rong, and Erzhu Zhongyuan, Erzhu Shilong, Erzhu Shicheng and Erzhu Bi were his successive younger brothers; Shilong’s courtesy name was Rongzong and Bi’s was Fubo. Erzhu Dulü was a paternal cousin of Erzhu Rong.⁠[19]

Followers and Subordinates

As a Qihu chieftain Erzhu Rong gathered the former commanders who had fought the Six Garrisons rebels. Gao Huan, who had earlier plotted an uprising with like-minded men such as Hou Jing, went over to Erzhu Rong and urged him to march against Zheng Yan and Xu He to “clear the emperor’s side”, arguing that this would make him hegemon. The Heba brothers, Heba Yue and Heba Sheng, also served him, and Erzhu Rong said that with them the realm could easily be pacified; by one account Heba Sheng became grand commander of Dingzhou in the twelfth month of 528 and later commanded 5,000 men at Jingxing.⁠[5][5][8][9]

Yuwen Tai moved south after the Six Garrisons Rebellion and joined the force the Northern Wei sent into Guanzhong to suppress rebels, serving under Heba Yue; when Heba Yue was killed the commanders chose Yuwen Tai to succeed him. Husi Chun was also once a subordinate of Erzhu Rong.⁠[25][5]

When Erzhu Rong was giving away his herds and wealth to gather brave men and make friends with powerful local figures, Hou Jing, Sima Ziru, Jia Xiandu, Duan Rong of Wuyuan and Dou Tai of Tai’an all came to join him. Hulü Jin, a Chile chieftain, had served as a troop commander under Yang Jun, garrison general of Huaishuo; he moved his troops in the Xiongnu manner and could tell the number of horse and foot from their dust and the distance of an army by smelling the ground. When Poliuhan Baling rose, Hulü Jin brought his followers over to him and was given the title of prince, but seeing that Baling would come to nothing he surrendered at Yunzhou; later, defeated by Du Luozhou, he escaped alone to Erzhu Rong, who made him a detached commander.⁠[3]

Posthumous Treatment

When Erzhu Shilong and his kinsmen held power they had Erzhu Rong honored with a place in the temple of Emperor Xiaowen, over the objection of Liu Jiming; earlier it had been proposed to place him in the temple of Emperor Xiaoming. In the debate on the matter he is referred to as Prince of Jin.⁠[4][4][2]

Early in the reign of the Former Deposed Emperor, when Erzhu Shilong and the others were in power, an edict posthumously granted Erzhu Rong the yellow axe and made him chancellor of state, overseer of the Department of State Affairs and governor of Sizhou, keeping his tally, palace attendant’s office, generalship and princely title; a further edict gave him the posthumous title of Prince of Jin with the nine bestowals, a state carriage with nine-tasseled banners, three hundred tiger guards with sword bearers and a hearse, following the precedent of Prince Xian of Anping, grand steward of the Jin dynasty, with the posthumous name Wu, and gave him a place as sacrificial companion in the temple of Gaozu.⁠[2]

Spellings of His Name

His surname is also written with a variant form of its first character, and his name is also romanized as Er-Ju Rong.⁠[26][13][2]

Assessments

Erzhu Rong set out to purge the government but, by killing a great many court officials along with the empress dowager, provoked fierce hostility. Traditional historical judgments credit him with putting down the risings across the country while condemning the crime of Heyin; Yuan Tianmu compared him to Yi Yin and Huo Guang.⁠[1][4][5][2]

From the Southern Song onward some historical judgments blamed Emperor Xiaowen’s Sinicization reforms for Erzhu Rong’s rise and the Heyin Incident, and some scholars have linked the massacre to hostility toward Sinicization. Other researchers argue that Erzhu Rong and Yuan Ziyou were both loyal to Emperor Xiaoming, which allowed them to work together to overthrow Empress Dowager Hu; that Fei Mu’s proposal sprang from personal ambition rather than opposition to Sinicization; and that the Erzhu clan, the powerful families of the Six Garrisons and the ordinary garrison people should be considered separately, their cooperation in suppressing the anti-Sinicization Six Garrisons rebels resting on a shared support for the Wei house.⁠[26][4]

Some researchers regard Erzhu Rong as the principal enemy of the Six Garrisons rebels; by not taking the throne himself he created a pattern of weak ruler and strong minister that Gao Huan and Yuwen Tai inherited and that became the basic political structure of the Eastern and Western Wei. Gao Huan and Yuwen Tai both came from the Six Garrisons, and the division of the Northern Wei into east and west can be seen as an outcome of the Six Garrisons Rebellion.⁠[4][26][4][6]

Traditional historical judgment holds that Erzhu Rong, rising from the ranks of commanders and relying on the strength of his tribal following, conceived at the moment of Suzong’s sudden death, amid popular resentment and divine anger, the aim of rescuing a tottering state, setting up a ruler and driving out the wicked; he captured Ge Rong and put an end to Yuan Hao, Xing Gao, Han Lou, Moqi Chounu and Xiao Baoyin, men who held capitals or usurped titles and each sought an empire of his own, and had he not exerted himself to overcome these great troubles, “who knows how many would have called themselves emperor, and how many king.” Yet the same judgment holds that at first he coveted what was not his and eyed the throne, and in the end Empress Dowager Ling and the young ruler were sunk in the river never to return and the officials were cut down at Heyin, so that he offended both men and spirits and was killed at last; had he avoided treachery and cruelty and cultivated virtue, Peng, Wei, Yi Yin and Huo Guang would not have compared with him, and his fall under suspicion, pressed too close to the throne, was what Kuai Tong had once warned the Prince of Han of.⁠[2]

Sources26 sources

  1. 爾朱栄 [Erzhu Rong] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  2. 魏書 卷七十四 [Book of Wei, juan 74] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  3. 資治通鑑 卷一百五十 [Zizhi Tongjian, juan 150] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  4. 河陰之變新探:以尒朱榮為中心的討論 [A New Interpretation of the He Yin Incident: A Discussion Centered upon Er-Ju Rong] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)ah.lib.nccu.edu.tw↑
  5. 「君臣大義」與東、西魏政權的建立和穩固 [On “The Great Duty between the Monarch and the Subject” and the Establishment and Stabilization of the East and West Wei Regimes] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)history.nccu.edu.tw↑
  6. 六鎮の乱 [Six Garrisons Rebellion] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kotobank.jp↑
  7. 上千朝臣遭斬殺!北魏胡太后毒殺親兒 卻遭部落酋長團滅 [More than a thousand court officials slain: Northern Wei Empress Dowager Hu poisoned her own son but was wiped out by a tribal chieftain] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)setn.com↑
  8. 高歓 [Gao Huan] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  9. 北魏孝荘帝代爾朱氏軍閥集団再論(4)-王都-覇府体制を焦点にして- [The Erzhu Military Clique under Emperor Xiaozhuang of the Northern Wei Reconsidered (4)] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)u-ryukyu.repo.nii.ac.jp↑
  10. 魏書 卷九 [Book of Wei, juan 9] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  11. 資治通鑑 卷一百五十二 [Zizhi Tongjian, juan 152] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  12. Wei dynasty (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  13. 漢制與胡風:重探北魏的「皇后」、「皇太后」制度 [Han Institutions and Xianbei Customs: Reexamining the Northern Wei Institutions of “Empress” and “Empress Dowager”] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)www2.ihp.sinica.edu.tw↑
  14. 北魏 [Northern Wei] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  15. 魏書 卷十 [Book of Wei, juan 10] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  16. 北史 卷十三 [History of the Northern Dynasties, juan 13] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  17. 河陰之變受害北魏宗室墓誌所見的追贈現象與意義 [The Phenomenon and the Significance of the Posthumously Conferred Titles in Royals’ Epitaphs in the Hoyin Rebellion] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)lawdata.com.tw↑
  18. 北魏孝荘帝代爾朱氏軍閥集団再論(1)-王都-覇府体制を焦点にして- [The Erzhu Military Clique under Emperor Xiaozhuang of the Northern Wei Reconsidered (1)] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)u-ryukyu.repo.nii.ac.jp↑
  19. 魏書 卷七十五 [Book of Wei, juan 75] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  20. 資治通鑑 卷一百五十四 [Comprehensive Mirror to Aid in Government, juan 154] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  21. 斛斯椿與高氏聯盟:尒朱氏政權崩壞的兩條線索 [Hu Sichun and the Gao Confederacy: Two Clues to the Collapse of the Erzhu Regime] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)ejournals.lib.hkbu.edu.hk↑
  22. 魏書 卷十一 [Book of Wei, juan 11] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  23. 東魏 [Eastern Wei] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  24. 北史 卷十四 [History of the Northern Dynasties, juan 14] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  25. 宇文泰 [Yuwen Tai] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  26. 河陰之變新探:以尒朱榮為中心的討論 [A New Interpretation of the He Yin Incident: A Discussion Centered upon Er-Ju Rong (repository record)] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw↑