ABAB Pedia

Guo Songling

Guo Songling (1883–1925), courtesy name Maochen, was a soldier of the late Qing and early Republic of China from Fengtian (now Shenyang), a general of the Fengtian clique and Zhang Xueliang’s teacher at the Three Eastern Provinces Military Academy. An early member of the Tongmenghui and a graduate of the Army University, he held senior commands in the Fengtian army; in November 1925 he rose at Luanzhou against Zhang Zuolin, and Lin ChangminLin ChangminLin Changmin (1876–1925), courtesy name Zongmeng, was a politician, diplomat, educator and calligrapher of the late Qing and early Republic of China and the father of Lin Huiyin. He studied at Waseda University in Japan, served in the early Republic as a member of parliament and as Minister of Justice among other posts, and in 1919 published “A Diplomatic Warning to Our Citizens” in the Chenbao, an article credited with setting off the May Fourth Movement; in 1925 he joined Guo Songling’s revolt against Zhang Zuolin and was killed by a stray bullet at Sujiatun.Open the full entry joined him. In December his army was defeated on the Liao River, Lin Changmin was killed by a stray bullet, and Guo and his wife, Han Shuxiu, were captured and killed on December 25.

Contents20 sections
Key facts

Born in Yuqiaozhai Village outside Fengtian

Guo Songling was born in Yuqiaozhai village on the eastern outskirts of Fengtian (now Shenyang); his courtesy name was Maochen. His adoptive grandson Guo Tailai recalled that Guo’s father had three sons: Guo Songling, Guo Rensheng and Guo Daming. From the age of 13 to 19 Guo could not attend school and worked on the farm; in the spring of 1903 he entered the academy founded by Dong Hanru at Wangzhai, south-east of Fengtian.⁠[1][2]

His family came originally from Fenyang in Shanxi; his great-grandfather’s generation is said to have settled as farmers around Benxi. Another account gives his year of birth as 1884.⁠[3][4]

Graduates from the Army Rapid-Training School

In the summer of 1907 Guo graduated from the Army Rapid-Training School.⁠[1]

His family was poor and he worked as a hired labourer; having seen the suffering the Russo-Japanese War brought to China, he chose a military career, entering the Fengtian Army Rapid-Training School in 1906, and the next year he was sent to the Third Division of the Beiyang Army. Back in Fengtian he was posted to the guard of the Shengjing military governor’s office, where he won the regard of the army commander Zhu Qinglan.⁠[3]

Joins the Tongmenghui and Serves in Sichuan

Guo took up arms early in life against the Qing court and the warlords, and in 1910, the year before the Revolution of 1911 broke out, he formally joined the Tongmenghui. In the spring of 1911 he was appointed commander of the second battalion of the 68th regiment of the army in Sichuan; on November 27 that year the Great Han Sichuan Military Government was founded. In early 1912 he was arrested at the West Gate of Fengtian by Zhang Zuolin’s men.⁠[2][1]

In 1909 he followed Zhu Qinglan to Sichuan and was stationed at Chengdu. When Sichuan rose in response to the Wuchang Uprising he took part, backing Zhu Qinglan and others in setting up the Sichuan military government; at the end of the year he was driven out in factional strife and returned to Fengtian, where he dealt directly with Zhang Rong, leader of the revolutionary United Radical Society, and was suppressed by the viceroy Zhao Erxun and by Zhang Zuolin, then commander of the Fengtian Front Route Patrol and Defence Battalions. In 1912 he entered the Officers’ Research Institute in Beijing.⁠[3]

Studies at the Army University

Returns to Fengtian

In May 1918 Sun Yat-sen’s Constitution Protection military government was reorganized and Sun lost the struggle for power within it. With the collapse of the Constitution Protection regime in Guangdong, Guo returned in 1918 to his home ground of Fengtian.⁠[1]

When Sun Yat-sen convened the Extraordinary Parliament in Guangzhou in August 1917 and launched the Constitution Protection Movement, Guo rallied to it and, through Zhu Qinglan, by then governor of Guangdong, held staff and other posts in Guangdong. When he returned to Fengtian at the end of 1918 he is said to have resolved to enter the Fengtian clique, quietly gain control of troops and build up strength, with a view to reforming it from the root.⁠[3]

Teaches Zhang Xueliang at the Three Eastern Provinces Military Academy

In March 1919 Zhang Xueliang, Zhang Zuolin’s eldest son, entered the artillery department of the Three Eastern Provinces Military Academy, where Guo was an instructor. Guo, eighteen years older than Zhang Xueliang, was his teacher at the academy; once they met, the two found they shared the same aims and became as close as kin. Seeing Zhang Xueliang as a patriotic and enterprising young man, Guo kept urging on him the idea of “training crack troops to resist foreign insult” and encouraged him to train a new army, hoping to use Zhang’s position and strength to realize his own long-held wish to reform the Fengtian army. When Zhang Xueliang graduated and Zhang Zuolin gave him command of troops, he asked for instructor Guo as his assistant, and Zhang Zuolin agreed. Zhang Xueliang recalled in old age that when the post of chief of staff fell vacant he recommended “my teacher Guo Songling” for it.⁠[1][2][5]

Back in Fengtian, Guo was recommended by Qin Hua, his classmate at the Army University and chief of staff of the Fengtian military governor’s office, and became a lieutenant-colonel staff officer there; from February 1919 he taught tactics at the Three Eastern Provinces Military Academy. In the spring of 1920, when Zhang Xueliang became commander of the guard brigade of the inspector-general’s office, Guo became the brigade’s chief of staff and commander of its second regiment, in effect guiding Zhang Xueliang.⁠[3]

Bandit Suppression and Brigade Command

In the autumn of 1920 Zhang Xueliang and Guo, on Zhang Zuolin’s orders, attacked the mounted bandits who held Jiamusi in Jilin and took the town. On February 16, 1921, Guo telegraphed that the bandits were plotting a rising; that spring, after pacifying the bandits of Jilin and Heilongjiang, he returned to Fengtian, and Zhang Zuolin appointed him commander of the 8th Mixed Brigade. After the reorganization of 1922 he was appointed a training instructor.⁠[1]

When the Anhui–Zhili War broke out in July 1920, Guo entered China proper with the Fengtian army and defeated Anhui troops at Tianjin, winning Zhang Zuolin’s trust. After the Fengtian army’s defeat in the First Zhili–Fengtian War in April 1922 he called for protecting the borders and keeping the people at peace and for reform of internal administration, and pressed Zhang Zuolin to carry them out, but was blocked by Yang Yuting’s faction.⁠[3]

Takes Jiumenkou in the Second Zhili–Fengtian War

The Second Zhili–Fengtian War began on September 17, 1924. On Zhang Xueliang’s orders Guo led three infantry regiments and a mountain-artillery battalion in a surprise attack on Jiumenkou, took it at dawn on the 29th and broke through at Shanhaiguan.⁠[1]

Zhang Xueliang recalled in old age that the Third Army Group of that campaign was “me and Guo Songling”; that Guo, having fallen out with Han Linchun, once led troops he had already taken up the hill back down again, and that Zhang searched for more than an hour, until daybreak, before finding him asleep in a small inn; and that Guo later telephoned him: “Commander, hurry to the front, we have taken more than twenty thousand prisoners!” After the war Guo was aggrieved, and when Zhang urged him not to take things to heart, Guo replied: “You are the Marshal’s son; what am I? Just my bad luck to be your subordinate.”⁠[5]

Withdrawing to Japan and Resolving to Join Feng Yuxiang against Zhang Zuolin

That year the May Thirtieth Movement broke out and the tide of the National Revolution was rising, yet between May and September Zhang Zuolin sent troops to occupy the lower Yangtze region. Guo opposed this and argued for protecting the borders and keeping the people at peace in the north-east; overruled, he withdrew to Japan on October 6. There he secretly resolved to join Feng Yuxiang in overthrowing Zhang Zuolin, and on October 24 he returned to Fengtian.⁠[3]

As deputy commander of the Third Front Army under Zhang Xueliang he moved to Tianjin, where, entrusted by Zhang Xueliang, he set up the army’s headquarters; his force of some 60,000 to 70,000 men faced the Guominjun. In November he refused to carry out Zhang Zuolin’s orders to attack and urged on Zhang Xueliang a reform of the political situation in the north-east; on November 19, at the Guomin Hotel in Tianjin, he decided to rise against the Fengtian leadership.⁠[4][3][6]

Rises against Zhang Zuolin at Luanzhou

Guo called a military conference at Luanzhou, openly turned against Zhang Zuolin, issued a circular telegram calling for peace and an end to the fighting, and renamed his force, formerly the Third Front Army of the Fengtian army, the Northeast National Army. He was one of Zhang Zuolin’s “five tiger generals,” and his rising and his declaration against the Fengtian clique left Zhang Zuolin at a loss for a time. On November 23, representatives of Li Jinglin and of Guo concluded an agreement in Beijing with the Guominjun; the same day Guo’s army began to advance east.⁠[1][7][8]

On November 25 the American minister in Peking, John Van A. MacMurray, cabled the Secretary of State that the Japanese Legation had confirmed reports that Zhang Zuolin and his chief of staff, Yang Yuting, were confined at Mukden on Guo’s orders; that Li Jinglin at Tianjin had declared independence of Zhang; and that the railway was cut at Luanzhou, with trains running only to Tangshan.⁠[9]

Zhang Xueliang recalled in old age that after rising, Guo brought his army back, demanded that Zhang Zuolin step down and wanted Zhang Xueliang to take over his father’s post; Zhang Xueliang and Zhang Zuoxiang went to the front by train to find him and asked to meet at Qinhuangdao, but Guo refused and sent word that any meeting would have to be in Tianjin. On November 25 Zhang Xueliang set off for Qinhuangdao, where Guo was. On the same day the Fengtian general Jiang Dengxuan was shot on Guo’s orders; Zhang Xueliang recalled that four army commanders joined Guo’s rising and that Guo killed the one who refused.⁠[5][1]

The telegram against the Fengtian leadership called for protecting the borders and keeping the people at peace in the north-east, and for the removal of the evil men around Zhang Zuolin.⁠[3]

On November 28 MacMurray cabled again that his earlier report was partly wrong: there had been no coup at Mukden and Zhang Zuolin was still in control there, while Yang Yuting had fled to Dairen; it appeared that Guo and the Fengtian forces between Tianjin and the Great Wall, having reached an agreement with Feng Yuxiang, had tried to march on Mukden to oust Zhang, and had been blocked at Shanhaiguan by forces loyal to him.⁠[10]

Lin Changmin Leaves Beijing to Join Guo

After rising, Guo wished to draw on the prestige of Lin Changmin and sent intermediaries to persuade him to come beyond the Great Wall. Lin answered Guo’s invitation and went secretly to Yingkou; grateful to Guo for valuing him, he left Beijing secretly on the evening of November 30 aboard Guo’s special train.⁠[8][11][12]

The Battles on the Liao River and the Kwantung Army’s Intervention

After crossing Shanhaiguan on November 27, Guo’s army pursued Zhang Zuoxiang’s Fifth Army; on December 5 it attacked at Lianshan. On December 8 Japan’s Kwantung Army delivered its first warning to both Zhang’s and Guo’s armies; on December 13 Guo planned to send Ma Zhongcheng’s 12th Brigade to occupy Yingkou but was stopped by the Kwantung Army. The fighting on the Liao River lasted more than ten days, from December 13 to December 24; by the 24th all of Guo’s troops had been disarmed. With Japan’s armed intervention, the revolt against the Fengtian clique failed on the verge of success.⁠[1][2]

Zhang Xueliang recalled in old age that in the standoff at the Juliu River “he was my teacher, and he wanted to stop me crossing”; when Guo’s troops attacked, Zhang soon defeated them, his men all crossed the river, and Guo and his wife fled. He also recalled thinking as the fighting began: “Sister-in-law Guo, I won’t be able to dance with you any more!”⁠[5]

Guo’s decisive victory at Lianshan on December 4–5, where his forces defeated the Jilin army, left Zhang Zuolin preparing to step down, unsettled the Fengtian army and set off defections to Guo. On December 15, however, the Japanese government, through the commander of the Kwantung Army, warned both armies that fighting within 12 kilometres on either side of the South Manchuria Railway zone was forbidden, which in effect blocked Guo’s advance across the Liao River towards Fengtian. On December 21 Guo’s army launched a general attack on Zhang Zuolin’s forces on the east bank of the Juliu River, but by the 23rd it had lost the upper hand.⁠[3][6]

On December 24 the American consul at Mukden, Sokobin, cabled the Secretary of State that Zhang Zuolin was reported to have completely defeated Guo, that most of Guo’s forces had surrendered and that Guo had fled.⁠[13]

Death of Lin Changmin

Han Shiru, chief of staff of the Second Army of Guo’s forces, recalled that shortly before dawn on December 23 Guo, his wife and Lin Changmin slipped away in secret in ten vehicles, with some fifty attendants and under the cover of an infantry company; by his account Lin Changmin had been named by Guo as premier of the three north-eastern provinces and governor of Fengtian province, and Guo and his wife were captured on the road by cavalry of Wang Yongqing’s brigade. On December 24 Lin Changmin was killed by a stray bullet amid the fighting at Sujiatun, at the age of 49; his party was attacked on the way by the Fengtian troops of Wang Yongqing, and he was hit after getting out of the vehicle to take cover.⁠[1][11][12][8]

Captured and Killed

Guo and his wife were captured and shot. A situation report in the archives of the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, headed “On the End of Guo Songling,” records that at about 3 p.m. on the 25th Guo, his wife and his secretary were seized at Sujiawopeng in Xinmin County and that Guo, who resisted with his pistol, was shot on the spot. On the afternoon of the 25th the bodies of Guo and his wife were taken to Fengtian and laid out at the sports ground at Xiaoheyan (Wanquan River). By one account, before he was shot Guo wrote a last letter to Zhang Xueliang, asking him to have Lu Muting, Shen Zhenrong and Zhang Zhenlu wind up the movable and immovable property he had managed for years and, once his debts were paid, to give all that remained to the Tongze Middle School.⁠[1]

As soon as Zhang Xueliang learned that Guo had been captured, he had a telegram drafted ordering that Guo and his wife be brought to his headquarters, intending then to send them abroad to study. Zhang recalled in old age that he had meant to bring Guo to his own camp and let him go, had even proposed that Guo train the army, and had sent men after him, but too late; Zhang Zuolin insisted on bringing Guo to Fengtian so that he could say everything he wanted to say, and Yang Yuting, afraid that Guo would reveal too much, had him killed on the way.⁠[2][5]

By another account Guo and his wife were arrested in Xinmin County on the 24th and executed on the 25th after being taken to Liaozhong County.⁠[3]

Memorials in Tokyo and Beijing

On January 4 the General Association of Chinese Students in Japan held a memorial meeting in Tokyo for Guo and his wife; on January 27 a Beijing rally of citizens against Japan’s dispatch of troops to the north-east also mourned Guo, and Feng Yuxiang and others sent wreaths. Li Dazhao called Guo a brave fighter in the war against the Fengtian clique, that is, in the war against Japanese imperialism.⁠[3]

Guo Tailai Meets Zhang Xueliang in the United States

In August 2001 Guo Tailai, Guo Songling’s adoptive grandson and chairman of the Beijing Gongmei Group, came to the United StatesUnited StatesThe United States is a federal country in North America made up of 50 states, the District of Columbia as the seat of government, and territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam; its capital is Washington, D.C. The Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776. The 2020 census (April 1, 2020) counted a resident population of 331,449,281, and the 435 seats of the House of Representatives are apportioned among the states on the basis of the census.Open the full entry on business and met Zhang Xueliang at a nursing home. In 1993 he had bought a bronze mirror for Zhang and kept it at home; not expecting to see Zhang on this trip, he had not brought it. Guo Tailai recalled that after Guo Songling’s death Zhang Xueliang came to the Guo family home, knelt before his great-grandparents and said in tears: “I am sorry, I failed to protect Brother Guo.”⁠[2]

Family

Guo’s wife, Han Shuxiu (1891–1925), was a graduate of the Fengtian Women’s Normal School and a member of the Tongmenghui. Guo once had a young daughter, who died of illness; as he had no son, Zhang Xueliang personally presided over the adoption into Guo’s line of Guo Hongzhi, the eldest son of Guo’s brother Guo Rensheng, then about six years old. Guo Hongzhi’s son, Guo Tailai, is Guo Songling’s adoptive grandson.⁠[1][2]

Relationship with Zhang Xueliang

Zhang Xueliang described their relationship at the time in the words “I am Guo Maochen, and Guo Maochen is me.” More than half a century later, in an interview with Phoenix Television of Hong Kong, he counted Guo among the few people who “influenced my whole life.” He often missed Guo, saying, “If Guo Songling were here, I would not be in such a difficult position now,” and in 1981 he said, “If Guo Songling had been there then, Japan would not have dared to launch the September 18 Incident.” Recalling Guo in old age, Zhang said: “Guo Songling was a bit wild; he was likeable, laughable and pitiable all at once.”⁠[2][5]

Assessments

It has been argued that the most important cause of Guo’s rebellion was the divergence in strategic thinking between Guo and Zhang Zuolin, and the rebellion has been compared with Zhang Xueliang’s later “remonstrance by force” and called Guo Songling’s version of the Xi’an Incident; on this view the main reason for its defeat was that Zhang Zuolin and Zhang Xueliang, father and son, stood together and fought Guo’s army to the end, Zhang Xueliang’s standing apart left the rising with the stigma of “a rebellion without a just cause,” and Guo’s army was far from acting as one.⁠[1]

The Fengtian army of the time held three groupings: graduates of the Imperial Japanese Army Academy promoted by Yang Yuting, such as Jiang Dengxuan and Han Linchun (the Shikan faction); the graduates of the Chinese Army University and the Baoding Military Academy gathered around Guo (the Army University faction); and Zhang Zuolin’s old subordinates (the old faction). Zhang Xueliang, too, came under the Army University faction’s influence.⁠[3][4]

Guo’s defeat is often attributed to Japanese intervention: Japan saw a victory for Guo as a threat to its interests in Manchuria and Mongolia and threw its weight behind Zhang Zuolin. It has also been argued that, although Soviet and Japanese intervention mattered, military factors and Guo’s own strategic mistakes were no less important.⁠[4][6]

Sources13 sources

  1. 郭松齢の叛乱と張学良の軍事思想―「東北易幟」への道― [Guo Songling’s rebellion and the military thought of Zhang Xueliang: the road to the Northeast Flag Replacement] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kitakyu.repo.nii.ac.jp↑
  2. 郭松龄孙子回忆张学良:我后悔没有带上那面铜镜 [Guo Songling’s grandson remembers Zhang Xueliang: I regret not bringing that bronze mirror] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)news.sina.com.cn↑
  3. 20世紀中国東北地域史と個人史:張作霖・張学良をめぐる政治家群像 [Regional History of Northeast China in the 20th Century and Biography: Short Essays of Politicians around Zhang Zuolin and Zhang Xueliang] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)ir.library.osaka-u.ac.jp↑
  4. 郭松齢(カクショウレイ) (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kotobank.jp↑
  5. 张学良口述身世录音大披露 [Zhang Xueliang’s recorded oral account of his life revealed] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinanews.com.cn↑
  6. 郭松齡事件新探 [The Guo Songling Incident of 1925 Revisited] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)airitilibrary.com↑
  7. 旧军阀笃信风水 [The old warlords’ faith in feng shui] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)paper.people.com.cn↑
  8. 林徽因的父亲林长民 [Lin Changmin, the father of Lin Huiyin] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)gmw.cn↑
  9. 893.00/6788: Telegram (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
  10. 893.00/6791: Telegram (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
  11. 林长民:兼容中西、立足民本 [Lin Changmin: combining Chinese and Western learning, rooted in the people] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)chinawriter.com.cn↑
  12. 《林长民集》百年来首次出版,披露诸多林徽因早年生活细节 [Collected Works of Lin Changmin published for the first time in a century, revealing many details of Lin Huiyin's early life] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)thepaper.cn↑
  13. 893.00/6876: Telegram (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑