ABAB Pedia

Battle of Yamen

The Battle of Yamen (also called the Battle of Yashan) was the last naval battle between the Southern SongSong dynastyThe Song dynasty (960–1279) was the Chinese dynasty founded by Zhao Kuangyin, divided into the Northern Song (960–1127) and the Southern Song (1127–1279) and counting 18 emperors. The Northern Song capital was Bianjing (Kaifeng); after the Jingkang incident of 1127 the court moved south to Lin’an (now Hangzhou) and ruled only South China. Commerce grew to an unprecedented extent and the dynasty’s cultural achievements were rich and varied; it was ended in 1279 by the Mongol Yuan dynasty.Open the full entry refugee court and the Yuan, fought in 1279 in the waters off Yashan in Xinhui, Guangdong; the decisive day was the sixth day of the second month of the second year of Xiangxing (March 19, 1279). After the surrender of Lin’an in 1276, Chen Yizhong, Zhang Shijie, Lu Xiufu and others enthroned in turn Duanzong, Zhao Shi, and Zhao Bing, fled along the coasts of Fujian and Guangdong and in 1278 moved to Yashan; Zhang Shijie held his position with about a thousand large ships lashed together, but after a blockade of more than twenty days the Yuan forces under Zhang Hongfan and Li Heng broke the Song fleet. Lu Xiufu leapt into the sea with the 8-year-old Zhao Bing on his back, Empress Dowager Yang drowned herself, and Zhang Shijie, who had broken out, drowned in a storm, ending the Song dynasty. The captive Wen Tianxiang witnessed the battle from a Yuan ship.

Contents30 sections
Key facts

The Siege of Xiangyang and the Growth of the Yuan Navy

In 1234 the Mongols, in alliance with the Southern Song, destroyed the Jin; the Yuan dynasty was founded in 1271 and from the following year attacked the Song by land and by sea. Aided by Chinese auxiliaries and technical specialists, the Mongols besieged Xiangyang, a fortress on the Han River that controlled access to the Yangtze, for five years (1268–1273); in 1273, the ninth year of Xianchun, its commander surrendered after the Mongols promised to spare the population, and he then took office under his former enemies.⁠[1][2][3]

Liu Zheng, a Song general who had gone over to the Yuan, urged the Yuan emperor to build warships, pointing to the strength of the Song navy, and the Yuan built up a large navy during the siege of Xiangyang; after the battle of Jiaoshan the Song had lost its superiority on the rivers and at sea. Another study holds that under the emperors Lizong and Duzong the Southern Song fought a long war of attrition with the Mongols in the Huai region that ended in the loss of Xiangyang and opened the Yangtze to a Mongol advance downstream, and that the navy, which should have been the last line of defense, suffered heavy losses at the decisive moment through tactical errors; when the Yuan army neared Lin’an the Song forces could no longer fight, and after the capital fell the Southern Song also lost its command of the sea.⁠[1][4]

In Zhiyuan 6 the Yuan mustered troops from the circuits to besiege Xiangyang, and Zhang Hongfan took part; he built a “single-line wall” outside Xiangyang to press the city and broke through the outer walls of Fancheng.⁠[5]

Wen Tianxiang Raises Troops and Zhang Shijie Relieves Lin’an

In 1275, the first year of Deyou, Wen Tianxiang answered an imperial call to defend the throne, raised a volunteer army and gave his family wealth to pay for it; more than 30,000 volunteers joined. The peace faction dominated the court and his strategy found little support; Changzhou and Pingjiang fell, and the Mongols surrounded Lin’an, the Southern Song capital. In the same year Zhang Shijie led troops to the relief of Lin’an and was promoted to military commissioner of Baokang for his services.⁠[6][3][7][7][8][9]

Of the commanders summoned to defend the throne most failed to come, and only Zhang Shijie arrived with his troops, to general admiration; on his way to the capital he recovered Raozhou, and then came to court. When the court summoned Wen Tianxiang to defend the capital, it made Zhang Shijie military commissioner of Baokang and prefect of Pingjiang; soon he too was called in to defend the capital and was given the additional title of acting junior guardian.⁠[8]

The Surrender of Lin’an

From December 1275 to February 1276 the Southern Song court negotiated repeatedly with the Yuan army. The grand empress dowager, née Xie, was determined at all costs to avoid fighting in the capital and made one concession after another: first vassal status with tribute, then the status of a grandson, and finally a conditional surrender that would preserve a small state for the imperial family; Bayan, the Yuan commander, camped in the Gaoting hills about 30 li northeast of Lin’an, rejected each offer. In January 1276 she ordered Wen Tianxiang and other generals to stop fighting and disband their recruits. Wen Tianxiang and Wu Jian were appointed chief ministers and sent to resume talks at the Yuan camp; Wen reviled the Yuan generals and the defectors and was detained, while the other envoys returned.⁠[10][9][11]

Mongol troops reached Lin’an in January 1276, last-minute peace efforts failed, and the city fell in February. On February 21, 1276 the boy emperor Gongdi, Zhao Xian, assembled what remained of his officials to make obeisance to the north; the act of surrender asked only that the people of Hangzhou and the imperial family be spared. Edicts then ordered the whole empire to stop fighting, ordered Li Tingzhi to surrender the Huai commanderies, and demanded that the two fleeing princes be brought back. By one account the chief minister Chen Yizhong decided to surrender and handed over the imperial seal that symbolized the throne; another study holds that Chen Yizhong and Zhang Shijie in fact led the faction that favored continued resistance and preparations for the loss of the capital.⁠[2][10][12][1]

The Yuan takeover of Lin’an was orderly: Dong Wenbing first inventoried the troops, civilians, cash and grain, after which the palaces, seals, art and archives were collected and the vessels of the ancestral temple were shipped north or stored; Wen Tianxiang’s volunteers were sent home, the regular Song forces were absorbed into the Mongol army, weapons were confiscated, Song offices were dissolved, and a pacification bureau for western and eastern Zhejiang was staffed with Song officials who had submitted, under the supervision of Fan Wenhu and Mangqutai. There were reports of bandits and of soldiers demanding bribes, and Kublai Khan issued an amnesty assuring former officials that they would not be punished. The Yuan court announced the conquest to Heaven, Earth and the ancestors and regarded it as complete in February 1276; commanders such as Xia Gui and Fang Hui stopped fighting and surrendered on hearing that Hangzhou had fallen, and it was generally believed that the Song had come to an end.⁠[10]

The imperial family was sent north in accordance with precedents for defeated rulers. The first party left on February 25, 1276; Wen Tianxiang escaped after three weeks, Jia Yuqing died soon after arriving, and Gao Yingsong starved himself to death. On March 28 Gongdi, his mother the empress dowager née Quan, the Prince of Fu, princesses and palace staff left Hangzhou under Bayan’s escort; the grand empress dowager Xie, who was seriously ill, set out several months later, arrived in November 1276, received the title Lady of Shoucheng and died in 1282. At Shangdu Gongdi was formally stripped of his imperial title and made Duke of Yingguo, and Kublai later had him become a monk. By another account the empress dowager and the boy emperor were taken to Dadu and granted an audience by Kublai Khan. The student Xu Yingbiao killed himself together with his family rather than witness the surrender; at Yangzhou, Jiang Cai, acting on Li Tingzhi’s orders, tried to rescue the emperor and the empress dowager but failed. Some palace women hanged themselves rather than remarry, and others were married to northern craftsmen.⁠[10][12][2][9]

On the jiashen day of the first month of Deyou 2 the Yuan army reached Gaoting Hill, and the Song court sent the investigating censor Yang Yingkui to hand over the imperial seal and an act of surrender that opened with the words “Xian, your subject and ruler of the state of Song, reverently bowing a hundred times, presents this memorial”; that night the chief minister Chen Yizhong fled, and Zhang Shijie, Su Liuyi and Liu Shiyong each left with their troops. On the yiyou day Wen Tianxiang was appointed chief minister of the right, military affairs commissioner and commander-in-chief, and on the bingxu day he was sent with Wu Jian as envoy to the Yuan army. On the xinchou day of the second month Gongdi led the officials in presenting a memorial of submission in the Xiangxi Hall.⁠[9]

When Wen Tianxiang first arrived at the Yuan camp he spoke with such vehemence that the whole camp was shaken; he was held and not allowed to return, and from then on the affairs of the Song state were beyond saving.⁠[11]

The Flight of the Two Princes and the Enthronement of Duanzong

A day or two before the surrender of Lin’an, Chen Yizhong, Zhang Shijie, Lu Xiufu and Chen Wenlong left the capital; Duzong’s two sons, Zhao Shi, Prince of Yi, and Zhao Bing, Prince of Guang, were escorted by their maternal uncles by way of Wuzhou to Wenzhou, which they reached less than two months later. Consort Yang went with her two sons. At the Jiangxin monastery in Wenzhou, Zhao Shi was proclaimed commander-in-chief of the empire’s infantry and cavalry, with Zhao Bing as his deputy. Under Yuan pressure the grand empress dowager Xie sent envoys to call the princes back; Chen Yizhong ignored her, had the envoys drowned, and sailed with his party to Fuzhou.⁠[10][1][13][14][9]

In June 1276 Zhao Shi was proclaimed emperor at Fuzhou, becoming Duanzong, with the reign name Jingyan; his mother, née Yang, acted as regent. Chen Yizhong became commander-in-chief and chief minister of the left, Li Tingzhi chief minister of the right, Zhang Shijie vice-commissioner of military affairs and Lu Xiufu a signatory official of military affairs, and Su Liuyi also held office at court. Duanzong was 8 years old at his enthronement. Wen Tianxiang was made military governor over all the armies and raised regional forces in Fujian and Guangdong.⁠[10][3][15][1][13][6][9][16]

Wen Tianxiang, who was being taken north, escaped at Zhenjiang. Suspected by Song officials of having gone over to the enemy, he narrowly escaped being killed, and endured hunger, cold and pursuit as he made his way south through Zhenzhou, Yangzhou, Gaoyou, Taizhou, Tongzhou and other cities.⁠[6][11]

Zhao Shi and Zhao Bing were both sons of Duzong by secondary consorts: the elder, Zhao Shi, Duke of Jianguo, was born to Consort Yang, and the youngest, Zhao Bing, Duke of Yongguo, to Lady Yu, a consort of the rank of xiurong. After Duzong’s death Zhao Xian was placed on the throne, and Zhao Shi was made Prince of Ji and Zhao Bing Prince of Xin. Consort Yang had entered the palace as a meiren and was raised to the rank of shufei in the third year of Xianchun.⁠[9][16]

In the first month of Deyou 2 Wen Tianxiang, then prefect of Lin’an, asked that the two princes be sent to hold Fujian and Guangdong, but his request was refused; the court later re-enfeoffed Zhao Shi as Prince of Yi, governor of Fuzhou and pacification commissioner of Fujian, and Zhao Bing as Prince of Guang, governor of Quanzhou and of the southern branch of the imperial clan office, with the imperial son-in-law Yang Zhen, Yang Liangjie and Yu Rugui as their superintendents; on the bingzi day of the first month the princes were ordered out to their posts. When the Yuan army reached Gaoting Hill, Yang Zhen and the others took the princes to Wuzhou. After Bayan entered Lin’an he sent Fan Wenhu with troops to Wuzhou to summon Yang Zhen to bring the princes back; Yang Zhen left as soon as he received the order, saying that he would go there to meet his death and so slow the pursuers.⁠[9][9]

After the princes reached Wenzhou, Lu Xiufu and Su Liuyi caught up with them, Chen Yizhong came to pay his respects, and Zhang Shijie was summoned from Dinghai. The Jiangxin monastery at Wenzhou had been visited by Emperor Gaozong during his flight south and still held his throne; there the group proclaimed Zhao Shi commander-in-chief of the empire’s armies with Zhao Bing as his deputy.⁠[9]

At Zhao Shi’s enthronement Zhao Bing was made Prince of Wei, and Chen Wenlong and Liu Fu became assistant chief ministers. Wen Tianxiang, having escaped from Zhenjiang, was summoned to Fuzhou as academician of the Guanwen Hall and imperial reader and on the gengchen day was appointed chief minister of the right; soon, disagreeing with Chen Yizhong and others, he left the court in the seventh month as co-commander-in-chief. Lu Xiufu was at this time made academician of the Duanming Hall.⁠[9][17][8]

Pu Shougeng Goes Over to the Yuan at Quanzhou

Pu Shougeng, a merchant of Arab descent, was superintendent of maritime trade at Quanzhou. Bayan had invited him to surrender in February 1276, and he did not reply at once. In December 1276 the refugee court sailed from Fuzhou to Quanzhou; Pu invited the court to land, but Zhang Shijie declined, and when Pu refused to supply grain and ships Zhang seized his property. Pu then massacred the members of the imperial clan, the officials and the Huai soldiers in Quanzhou and formally surrendered to the Mongols in January 1277. By another account Pu had at first offered to help restore the dynasty and went over to the Yuan only after Song soldiers seized his ships. In August 1277 Zhang Shijie attacked Quanzhou; by October he had been defeated, and Mongol forces relieved the city.⁠[10][12][3][9][8]

Fuzhou fell in 1277 and the court went into exile at sea. From May 1277 Wen Tianxiang set about recovering Jiangxi, but his regional forces collapsed under raids by Yuan cavalry, and only three members of his family survived.⁠[6][17][18]

In the eleventh month of that year the Yuan assistant governors Arqan and Dong Wenbing reached Chuzhou with their troops; on the jiachen day the Prince of Xiu met them in battle at Rui’an, where the surveillance commissioner Li Shida was killed; on the yisi day Zhao Shi put to sea; on the guichou day the Yuan army reached Fu’an prefecture and its prefect Wang Gangzhong surrendered the city. After the episode with Pu Shougeng at Quanzhou, Zhao Shi moved on to Chaozhou, and in the same month Fuzhou and Xinghua had submitted to the Yuan. On the wuchen day of the twelfth month Pu Shougeng and Tian Zhenzi, prefect of Quanzhou, surrendered the city.⁠[9]

On the yisi day of the seventh month of Zhiyuan 14 Zhang Shijie laid siege to Quanzhou, and the forces of Lady Xu and other units joined the attack on Pu Shougeng without taking the city; the Yuan marshal Sogetu came to its relief, the Song forces withdrew, and Zhang Shijie returned to Qianwan. Sogetu’s relief is dated by one account to the ninth month and by another to the tenth.⁠[9][8]

In the first month of Zhiyuan 14 the Yuan army broke through the Ting pass and Wen Tianxiang withdrew to Zhangzhou; in the third month he took Meizhou and in the fourth Xingguo county, in the fifth he marched from Meizhou into Jiangxi and entered Huichang county, and on the xinyou day of the sixth month he took Yudu; in the eighth month the troops of all his commanders were defeated. At Kongkeng his soldiers scattered and his wife, concubines and children were captured; the Yuan general Li Heng, pursuing him to Kongkeng, took his wife and daughters and seized a pacification commissioner.⁠[9][17][18]

Guangzhou Changes Hands

On the bingzi day of the sixth month, after Zhao Shi’s enthronement at Fuzhou, Liang Xiongfei entered Guangzhou and its governor Xu Zhiliang abandoned the city and fled. In the ninth month Xiong Fei attacked Liang Xiongfei at Guangzhou; on the renyin day Liang fled, and Xiong Fei went on to recover Shaozhou; on the renzi day Zhao Jin entered Guangzhou. In the tenth month Zeng Fenglong joined Xiong Fei in resisting the Yuan army at Nanxiong and was killed.⁠[9]

In the fourth month of Zhiyuan 14 Zhang Zhensun, military commissioner of Guangdong, took Guangzhou by surprise; in the tenth month the Yuan general Tachu besieged the city, and on the gengyin day Zhang Zhensun surrendered it. In the first month of Zhiyuan 15 the Yuan army razed the walls of Guangzhou.⁠[9]

Li Heng advanced on Guangzhou and the commanderies and counties submitted one after another; when Ling Zhen and others later attacked Guangzhou again, Li Heng defeated them, taking three hundred ships and capturing more than two hundred officers and officials from Song Mai down.⁠[18]

The Refugee Court in the Hong Kong Area

The refugee court moved along the coast of Guangdong: Duanzong stopped in turn at Meiwei Shan (today Mui Wo), Guanfu Shan (the Kowloon hills, near Sung Wong Toi), Qianwan (by one identification Tsuen Wan), Xiushan (today Humen), and Jing’ao and Xinüxia (in the Zhongshan area). The general account has the court reaching Kowloon in April 1277 and staying about six months; by another the two emperors stayed on the Kowloon coast for about ten months. In the eleventh month of the second year of Jingyan, Qianwan fell and the court moved on. Zhang Shijie had at one point defeated the Yuan forces and retaken Qianwan.⁠[14][10][9]

In the eleventh month of the second year of Jingyan, Chen Yizhong, Zhang Shijie and Su Liuyi, commander of the palace guard, decided to leave the Hong Kong area; by way of Shachong (now part of Zhongshan) they reached Xiangshan, where the house of a local man, Ma Nanbao, served as the court’s residence.⁠[13]

The Storm at Jing’ao and Chen Yizhong’s Departure for Champa

In the twelfth month of the second year of Jingyan, Duanzong learned that Guangzhou had fallen and withdrew to Jing’ao below Hengqin Mountain (today Dahengqin Island in Zhuhai). A hurricane scattered the Song fleet; four or five in every ten of the men died, and Duanzong was swept into the sea by the waves and fell ill. Zhang Shijie drove off an attack by the Yuan general Liu Shen, and the two princes moved their boats to Xienüxia (today Xiaohengqin); Liu Shen pursued them to the Qizhou sea, took about 200 Song ships and carried off Duanzong’s maternal uncle Yu Rugui as a prisoner. After the Song and Yuan forces met at Jing’ao in Xiangshan, a naval battle followed at Shizimen in which the Song suffered heavy losses. Another study gives this sequence: in December 1277 the court returned to Qianwan and moved to Xiushan, reaching Jing’ao in January 1278.⁠[19][13][20][10][9][8]

Early in 1278 Chen Yizhong proposed taking the young ruler to Champa (in what is now southern Vietnam) and went ahead to investigate; Ma Nanbao predicted that he would never return. Chen did not come back and died in Siam a few years later. By another account he fled to Champa in January 1278.⁠[13][10][10][12][17][21]

After the storm at Jing’ao it was more than ten days before the scattered soldiers began to reassemble. Once Chen Yizhong had gone to Champa, the two princes sent for him repeatedly, but he never returned; when the Yuan invaded Champa in Zhiyuan 19 he fled to Siam, where he later died. By another account he went to Champa to ask for troops and stayed away for a long time.⁠[9][17][21]

The Death of Duanzong and the Enthronement of Zhao Bing

In the third month of the third year of Jingyan the court stopped at Gangzhou, and in the fourth month Duanzong died, only 10 years old; two days later the 7-year-old Zhao Bing was enthroned, the reign name was changed to Xiangxing, and Gangzhou was raised to the status of Xianglong county. Duanzong had nearly drowned during the flight at sea and died of the shock; by another account he died of illness. By yet another account Zhao Bing was 8 when he was enthroned. Duanzong was buried in the Yongfu mausoleum.⁠[13][14][1][10][12][22][9][21]

When the officials were about to disperse, Lu Xiufu persuaded them to continue the resistance. The posthumous edict he drafted for Duanzong declared that Heaven had not abandoned the Song, a view held only by a few senior officials at court. After Zhao Bing’s enthronement Lu Xiufu became chief minister of the right and directed the government, and he and Zhang Shijie jointly placed Zhao Bing on the throne. Zhang Shijie, as grand tutor, used his spare time to teach Zhao Bing to read.⁠[10][10][15][20]

In the third month of Zhiyuan 15 Zhao Shi had wished to go and live in Champa but could not, and so stopped at Gangzhou. On the wuchen day of the fourth month he died there, and his ministers gave him the temple name Duanzong; on the gengwu day they enthroned the Prince of Wei, Zhao Bing. By another account the late emperor’s testamentary edict was issued on the sixteenth day of the fourth month, the Xiangxing emperor ascended the throne on the seventeenth, and on the twenty-first officials were sent to announce the accession to Heaven and Earth.⁠[9][23]

After Duanzong’s death many officials wanted to disperse, but Lu Xiufu asked what would become of the one son of Emperor Duzong who was still alive, and recalled that men of old had restored their dynasties with no more than a single brigade and a single walled town; together with the others he enthroned the Prince of Wei. By one account Lu Xiufu became chief minister of the left after Zhao Bing’s enthronement. At the refugee court he still stood every day holding his tablet of office as if at court in peaceful times, sometimes weeping and wiping his tears with his court robe, and he wrote out passages of the Great Learning by hand to teach the boy emperor.⁠[8][9]

The Court Moves to Yashan

Accounts of when the court reached Yashan differ: one gives June 1278, another July 1278, and a third the fifth month of that year. Yashan, also written with a variant character, was then an island near the mouth of the Pearl River south of Xinhui county in Guangdong, about 50 km west of Macau; Yamen lies on the west bank of the Pearl River estuary about 40 km south of the Xinhui county seat and takes its name from the gap between Yashan to the east and Tangping Shan to the west, inside which lie the waters of Yinzhou Lake where the Tan River reaches the sea. The tides there are strong. Guangzhou and Qiongzhou were still in Song hands and not far away, and the choice of Yamen has been called a choice made for lack of any alternative.⁠[1][10][13][24][24][24][25][19][12]

Zhang Shijie was ordered to hold Yashan to the death and had trees felled to build a temporary palace and barracks for the imperial retinue and the troops, a project in which many local inhabitants took part; the court stayed at Yashan for nine months. The Song side was then said to have more than 200,000 troops; by one account about 200,000 officials and civilians could not all be accommodated on the island and remained on their boats, while another gives the Song side about 100,000 people, most of them civil officials, palace women, eunuchs and other non-combatants.⁠[20][10][10][13][12][1][21]

On the jisi day of the sixth month of Zhiyuan 15 Zhao Bing moved to Yashan, and in the same month Guangzhou was raised to the status of Xianglong superior prefecture. Zhang Shijie judged that Gangzhou could not be held and moved the court to Yashan in Xinhui; in the eighth month he was made Duke of Yue, and he drew grain from Qiongzhou to supply the army. At Yashan the court cut timber in the hills and built a thousand barrack rooms and a temporary palace of thirty rooms; officials, civilians and soldiers still numbered two hundred thousand, not counting those who had fled or died.⁠[9][8][21][23]

The Yuan Sends Zhang Hongfan and Li Heng South

In the seventh month of 1278 Kublai Khan appointed Zhang Hongfan chief marshal of the Mongol and Han armies and Li Heng his deputy, and sent them south from Yangzhou by water and by land. Zhang Hongfan came from the north with about 20,000 men and Li Heng came from Guangzhou to join him; together they had more than 500 ships. Zhang Hongfan was supreme commander in the battle of Yashan.⁠[13][1][26][5]

On his appointment Zhang Hongfan asked that a trusted Mongol official be made chief commander; he declined the gifts offered to him and asked instead for a sword and armor. Before setting out he recommended Li Heng as his deputy, which was approved. At Yangzhou he selected officers and twenty thousand land and naval troops and marched south by separate routes, with his younger brother Zhang Hongzheng commanding the vanguard.⁠[5]

On the jimao day of the sixth month of Zhiyuan 15 the Yuan sent a thousand Mongol troops with Zhang Hongfan, pacification commissioner of Jiangdong, to attack the remaining Song forces by sea; by one account on that same day the chief marshals Zhang Hongfan and Li Heng were ordered to attack Yashan. In the seventh month the Yuan made Li Heng, assistant governor of Jiangxi, chief marshal to lead the Mongol and Han armies against Guangdong; by one account his title was likewise chief marshal of the Mongol and Han armies.⁠[27][9][18]

The Fall of Guangzhou and Wen Tianxiang’s Capture at Wupoling

Guangzhou fell in the eleventh month of the third year of Jingyan. Wen Tianxiang was captured by the Yuan general Zhang Hongfan at Wupoling in Haifeng, Guangdong; one account dates the capture to the twelfth month of that year, another to the eleventh month, and a third to January 1279. He swallowed poison but did not die, and later regretted not having ended his life at Guangzhou. Zhang Hongfan kept him on board ship as the fleet sailed for Yashan.⁠[1][13][10][10][28][28][19][17][5][23]

In the second month of the third year of Jingyan Wen Tianxiang advanced to Haifeng county in Huizhou, and in the third month he encamped at Lijiangyong; in the eighth month he was made junior guardian and Duke of Xin. In the ninth month his mother, Lady Zeng, died; disease spread through his headquarters, killing several hundred men, and in the tenth month his eldest son Daosheng died, so that both his mother and his only son were dead. In the eleventh month he advanced to Chaoyang county in Chaozhou; on the fifteenth day of the twelfth month he moved toward Haifeng, and on the twentieth, as he was eating at Wupoling, Zhang Hongfan’s land and naval forces arrived suddenly, before his men could form up, and he was captured.⁠[23][17]

After his capture Wen Tianxiang swallowed camphor, which kills only when taken with cold water, and so he survived. Brought before Zhang Hongfan, he refused to kneel when ordered to, and Zhang received him with the courtesy due to a guest, remarking that killing him would give the fame to Wen, whereas treating him as a guest would give it to himself. By another account, on the jiazi day of the intercalary month of Zhiyuan 15 the Yuan learned that Wen Tianxiang was encamped at the port of Chaoyang and sent the vanguard under Zhang Hongzheng after him; they caught up with him at the foot of Wupoling, routed his army, took more than seven thousand heads and seized Wen Tianxiang and four of his officers.⁠[23][17][27]

The Fighting for Leizhou

In the first month of Zhiyuan 15 Zhang Shijie sent troops against Leizhou but failed to take it; in the fifth month he sent Zhang Yingke and Wang Yong to take Leizhou, and on the dingsi day of the sixth month Zhang Yingke fought again at Leizhou and was killed.⁠[9]

Zhang Shijie’s Deployment and the Yuan Blockade

Instead of guarding the mouth of the bay, Zhang Shijie burned the court’s makeshift market town and lashed about a thousand large ships together in a line inside the bay, fighting with his back to the sea; by one account the line was meant to prevent desertion. The Song hulls were coated with sea mud against fire, and long poles were used to fend off fire ships. Another account gives the Song more than a thousand large ships plus a thousand Wudan boats.⁠[1][10][13][9][8][18]

Zhang Hongfan reached Yamen in the first month of the following year; by another account Li Heng and Zhang Hongfan arrived at Yashan in early March 1279 with about 500 smaller, faster ships. Yet another account gives the Yuan about 600 ships of all sizes. The Yuan first sent small fire ships, which failed, and then blockaded the bay, occupied Yashan and cut the Song fleet off from routes to the south and west and from its land supplies to the north. The Song forces ran short of water and firewood, and the two sides confronted each other for twenty-three days, or by another account about three weeks.⁠[1][10][13][5][9][8]

Zhang Hongfan’s fleet sailed from the port of Chaoyang on the gengxu day of the first month and reached Yashan on the xinyou day; by another account the Yuan arrived on the renxu day of the first month, and by a third they began their attack on Yashan on the xinyou day. Li Heng’s force joined them, by one account, on the gengwu day of the first month, and by another arrived from Guangzhou on the jiaxu day, when Zhang Hongfan gave him warships to command. Wen Tianxiang, held aboard a Yuan ship, left Chaoyang on the sixth day of the first month, passed Guanfuchang on the eighth and reached Yashan on the thirteenth.⁠[5][9][21][23]

The Song fleet of more than a thousand ships lay at anchor in the sea with towers built on the decks, like a solid rampart. At Yashan the heights faced each other east and west, and to the north the water was so shallow that ships ran aground and could advance only on the incoming tide, so Zhang Hongfan went round the east of the mountain and entered the open sea to the south before he could close with the Song ships; he also sent a surprise force to cut the Song off from their water supply and burned their palace buildings. With firewood and water cut off, the Song soldiers lived on dry rations for more than ten days; desperate with thirst, they scooped up seawater to drink, and the salt water made them vomit and suffer diarrhea, leaving the army in great distress. Zhang Shijie, with Su Liuyi and Fang Xing, fought major battles against the Yuan every day.⁠[5][8][18]

Zhang Hongfan found a nephew of Zhang Shijie surnamed Han, gave him an official post and sent him three times to urge Zhang to surrender. Zhang Shijie recited the names of loyal ministers of the past and replied that he knew surrender would bring life, wealth and rank, but that he would not waver from dying for his lord. On the first day (wuyin) of the second month Zhang Shijie’s subordinate commander Chen Bao surrendered.⁠[8][5][9]

Wen Tianxiang’s Poem “Crossing the Lingding Sea”

Zhang Hongfan ordered Wen Tianxiang to write to Zhang Shijie urging him to surrender; Wen refused and wrote the poem “Crossing the Lingding Sea,” on mortality and loyalty, whose last line asks that his loyal heart be left to shine in the pages of history. The Lingding Sea, between Neilingding and Wailingding islands in the Pearl River estuary, became a historical and cultural landmark because of the poem.⁠[10][6][1][19][17][29]

Zhang Hongfan sent Marshal Li across to Wen Tianxiang’s ship to ask him to write to Zhang Shijie urging surrender; Wen replied that, having failed to protect his own parents, he could hardly teach another man to betray his. He wrote out “Crossing the Lingding Sea” and handed it over; the poem opens by recalling the hardships that began with his success in the classics examination and his four years amid war. Zhang Hongfan smiled and let the matter drop.⁠[17][29][23]

The Decisive Battle at Yashan

The decisive battle was fought on the sixth day of the second month of the second year of Xiangxing. The Yuan forces divided into four squadrons around the Song line, with Zhang Hongfan taking the southern sector to exploit the rising tide. In the morning Li Heng attacked from the north on the ebb, using high-sterned ships carrying archers, and at noon the northwest corner of the Song line gave way. In the afternoon the tide rose and Zhang Hongfan attacked from the south, while Zhang Shijie shifted forces from the north to reinforce the south. The Yuan bombarded the Song fleet with fire weapons, and in the afternoon broke the Song line and charged its center; seeing the flags at the center fall, Zhang Shijie broke out with a squadron of ships.⁠[1][10][30][13][9][18]

On the guiwei day of the second month, as the Yuan prepared to fight, someone proposed opening with catapults (pao), but Zhang Hongfan held that fire would scatter the Song ships and that it was better to fight. By one account, on the following day he divided his army into four, took command of one division himself and told his commanders that the Song ships would certainly flee east on the incoming tide, that they must attack at once and let none escape, and that no one was to engage until they heard music from his ships, on pain of death. During the fighting Li Heng and the others at one point fell back with the tide. When the music began, the Song commanders thought the Yuan were feasting and relaxed their guard. The Yuan had built fighting towers on the sterns of their ships, screened with cloth, and ordered that no one rise to fight before the gong sounded, on pain of death; the Song arrows gathered on the screens like the quills of a hedgehog. In a moment the Yuan broke seven Song ships at once, and the Song forces were routed.⁠[5]

On the guiwei day of the second month a black vapor rose west of the mountain, and Li Heng, taking advantage of the ebbing morning tide, attacked from the north; the Song commander Zhai Guoxiu and the militia commissioner Liu Jun, among others, took off their armor and surrendered. By the time the Yuan reached the Song central command it was dusk, with wind and rain and fog on every side. Li Heng’s force, drawn up at the sterns of its ships, advanced against the current from the north and broke the ropes binding the Song ships; Zhang Shijie fought on desperately from morning until late afternoon, when Zhang Hongfan led the southern divisions in a combined attack and routed the Song. Zhang Shijie cut his moorings and forced his way out of the harbor with more than ten warships; Li Heng pursued him into the open sea but could not catch him.⁠[9][18][8][5]

Lu Xiufu Carries Zhao Bing into the Sea

In the evening, amid wind and rain, Lu Xiufu, knowing that escape was impossible, ordered his wife, née Zhang, and their children into the sea at sword point, declared to Zhao Bing that the state had come to its end, tied the gold seal to the 8-year-old emperor’s waist and leapt into the sea with him on his back. Lu Xiufu jumped from the imperial boat, not from a cliff. Zhao Bing was the ninth and last emperor of the Southern Song. Members of the palace and officials who followed them into the sea numbered in the tens of thousands, among them the Hanlin academician Liu Dingsun, the minister of rites Xu Zongren, the vice-minister of war Mao Xiang, the vice-minister of personnel Zhao Qiao and the commissioner of military affairs Gao Gui. Zhao Bing’s body was found the next day, weighed down with gold and the imperial seals.⁠[1][12][10][10][13][24][15][8][9][21]

One account says that Zhao Bing may have been thrown into the water by a Song official. The Hong Kong scholar Lo Hsiang-lin argued that Zhao Bing died on board ship during the breakout rather than in the sea with Lu Xiufu; another researcher accepts Gong Kai’s account that he died together with Lu Xiufu.⁠[30][13][10][5]

Seeing that escape was impossible, Lu Xiufu drove his wife and children into the sea with his sword; by one account his wife clung to the side of the boat and would not go, and he told her to go ahead and not fear that he would fail to follow. He then boarded the Prince of Wei’s boat and told Zhao Bing that, with the state come to this, His Majesty must die for it, since the grand empress dowager had already been humiliated enough and he must not suffer humiliation in turn; he then leapt into the sea with Zhao Bing on his back. He was 44.⁠[8][21]

Liu Dingsun likewise drove his family into the sea and sank his baggage, but did not die himself; captured and beaten until no part of his skin was whole, he escaped one night and in the end drowned himself in the sea. Liu Dingsun had passed the jinshi examination. The Yuan captured the Song gold seal, the women of the palace and the civil and military officials; after the ships that had burned or sunk, more than eight hundred vessels still fell into Yuan hands. By another account Zhao Bing and his officials died in the sea on the jiaxu day of the first month, and the Yuan took his gold and treasure and presented it to the throne.⁠[8][18][27]

Zhang Shijie’s Breakout and the Death of Empress Dowager Yang

Zhang Shijie broke out with 16 large ships, guarding Empress Dowager Yang, in the hope of re-establishing the court. When the empress dowager learned that Zhao Bing was dead, she drowned herself. Deng Guangjian was rescued from the sea and forced to serve as tutor in Zhang Hongfan’s household. By one account Su Liuyi was captured and killed; by another he went with Zhang Shijie to join Chen Yizhong and died on the way. The Song official Xie Ao escaped during the battle of Yashan.⁠[1][10][10][10][9][16][21]

When Empress Dowager Yang learned that Zhao Bing was dead, she beat her breast and wept, saying that she had endured death and hardship to come this far only for this one scrap of Zhao flesh, and now there was no hope; she then threw herself into the sea, and Zhang Shijie buried her on the shore. By another account she said that she had borne all this only for the sake of the Zhao family’s ancestral sacrifices, and that since Heaven’s mandate had come to this there was nothing more to say. Zhang Shijie had intended to take her with him, find a descendant of the Zhao family and enthrone him.⁠[9][16][8]

The Death of Zhang Shijie

After the breakout Zhang Shijie headed for Nan’en prefecture, by one account intending to go on to Champa. A hurricane at sea (by one account a storm in fog) capsized his ship and he drowned: by one account below Pingzhang Shan (in the waters near today’s Hailing Island, Yangjiang); by another at Hailing harbor about three months after the battle; by a third at Xinhui. Yet another account holds that he was killed by his subordinate Zhou Wenying. With his death the Southern Song came to an end.⁠[1][13][10][10][7][7][20][8][5]

By one account Zhang Shijie fled toward Jiaozhi, his ship was wrecked by the wind and he died at Hailing harbor. By another, after four days at sea, close to the shore, he said that he had done all he could for the Zhao family, having seen one ruler die, set up another, and now seen him die too, and prayed that if Heaven did not wish him to preserve the Zhao sacrifices, a great wind should overturn his ship; the ship then capsized. The Yuan general Li Heng had at first believed that the fleeing ships carried the Prince of Wei, and only learned from men who surrendered that the prince was already dead and that the fugitive was Zhang Shijie.⁠[5][21][18]

The Dead and Wen Tianxiang’s Testimony

Accounts of the dead differ: one estimates that over 100,000 lives were lost out of a figure believed to be 200,000; another that more than 100,000 bodies floated on the sea; another that nearly 100,000 people drowned; and another that nearly 200,000 Song soldiers and civilians were killed or drowned and the Song army was wiped out.⁠[10][12][31][19][9][18]

Wen Tianxiang, held aboard a Yuan ship, witnessed the battle and wrote the poem “The Great Battle at Sea on the Sixth Day of the Second Month,” which contains a line describing floating corpses and drifting blood muddying the waters of the sea. By another account the story of Wen watching the battle from a boat is local tradition.⁠[13][1][10][29][23]

Seven days after the battle more than a hundred thousand corpses had surfaced in the sea; by another account the drowned numbered several tens of thousands.⁠[9][21]

Wen Tianxiang, sitting in a Yuan ship, wept facing south and wrote a lament whose title says that the state’s cause had failed and that he, a lone servant of the throne, sat in a northern ship weeping toward the south; it contrasts the southern ships that had filled the sea off Yashan the day before with the northern ships that alone remained.⁠[29][23]

Zhang Hongfan’s Inscription and Death

After the battle Zhang Hongfan had a twelve-character inscription carved on a rock at Yamen meaning “Here Zhang Hongfan, Grand General Guarding the State, destroyed the Song”; the Ming scholar Chen Baisha later added the character for Song in front, turning it into “Here the Song’s own Grand General Guarding the State, Zhang Hongfan, destroyed the Song.” Zhang Hongfan died of illness soon after the conquest of the Song and received the posthumous name Xianwu. Deng Guangjian later said that Zhang Hongfan treated Wen Tianxiang with courtesy and on his deathbed pleaded with the Yuan emperor to spare Wen’s life.⁠[31][26][10][5]

Zhang Hongfan smoothed the cliff on the south side of Yashan, carved an inscription recording his achievement and returned north; in the tenth month he came to court and was feasted in the inner palace. Soon afterwards he fell ill with a malarial fever; when the illness grew grave he bathed, changed his clothes, was helped out to the central courtyard, bowed twice toward the palace and told his son that his father had won merit with these, and that he should wear them and never forget. Having spoken, he died sitting upright, aged 43. He was posthumously named grand master of silver and blue glory and manager of governmental affairs, with the posthumous name Wulie; in the fourth year of Zhida he was further honored as a meritorious minister, and in the sixth year of Yanyou he was given a further meritorious title, raised to Prince of Huaiyang and renamed Xianwu.⁠[5]

Wen Tianxiang in Dadu and His Execution

Wen Tianxiang was taken to Dadu (Beijing), refused to serve the Yuan and was held in prison for three years, where in 1281 he wrote the “Song of the Righteous Spirit.” In all he spent three years and two months in captivity without yielding. He was executed in the nineteenth year of Zhiyuan (1282), at the age of 47; by another account he was executed early in 1283 after a plot to rescue him leaked. Deng Guangjian was also taken to Dadu with Wen, lived for several years in Zhang Hongfan’s household, was released in 1281 and returned to his home of Luling, where he wrote a biography of Wen Tianxiang and a record of the refugee court.⁠[28][28][28][6][10][10][10][17]

After the battle the Yuan held a great feast, at which Zhang Hongfan told Wen Tianxiang that, with the state fallen, the chief minister had fulfilled every duty of loyalty and filial piety. Wen replied that a minister who had failed to save his state deserved more than death, and that he would never dare to escape death by becoming disloyal. Zhang respected his integrity and had him escorted to the capital. On the thirteenth day of the third month Wen returned to Guangzhou with the Yuan fleet; on the twenty-second of the fourth month he set out north from Guangzhou together with Deng Guangjian, an official of the Yashan court; he reached Nan’an commandery on the twenty-fifth of the fifth month and Jizhou on the first of the sixth, crossed the Yangtze northward on the twenty-fourth of the eighth month and arrived at Yanjing on the first of the tenth month. On the way he refused food for eight days, and when he did not die he began eating again.⁠[17][23]

Knowing that Wen Tianxiang would never submit, Kublai Khan discussed with his chief ministers whether to release him, and at an audience asked him what he wished for; Wen answered that he had received the favor of the Song as its chief minister and could not serve a second dynasty. At his execution he was calm, told the guards that his work was done, bowed toward the south and died. Some days later his wife, née Ouyang, recovered his body, whose face looked as if he were alive. In his sash was found a eulogy: “ConfuciusConfuciusConfucius (personal name Qiu, courtesy name Zhongni) was a man of the state of Lu in the Spring and Autumn period and the founder of Confucianism, born in 551 BCE (by another account 552 BCE) and died in 479 BCE. From a declining aristocratic family and poor in his youth, he served Lu as governor of Zhongdu, minister of works and grand minister of justice; around 498 BCE he left Lu and wandered for some fourteen years through Wei, Song, Chen, Cai and other states, returning in 484 BCE to devote himself to teaching and to putting the ancient texts in order, with some three thousand disciples by tradition. His sayings and deeds were compiled by his disciples and their followers as the Analects. He was buried north of Qufu; successive dynasties heaped titles on him, his direct descendants held the hereditary title of Duke Yansheng, and the temple, cemetery and family mansion at Qufu are a World Heritage Site.Open the full entry spoke of fulfilling humaneness, Mencius of choosing righteousness; only when righteousness is exhausted is humaneness attained. In reading the books of the sages, what else was I learning?”⁠[17]

Principal Figures on Both Sides

Lu Xiufu (1236–1279), courtesy name Junshi, was a native of Yancheng in Chuzhou (in today’s Jiangsu). He became a presented scholar in the first year of Jingding (1260), served as aide in the Court of Agriculture, vice-director of the Court of the Imperial Clan and acting court diarist, and vice-minister of rites, was sent to negotiate with the Yuan army, and later served the refugee court as chief minister of the right. He had been sent away to Chaozhou in 1276, and a son left there carried on his line. Lu Xiufu entrusted his diary to Deng Guangjian.⁠[15][15][10][10]

Zhang Shijie (died 1279) was a native of Fanyang. He first served under Zhang Rou, who had submitted to the Mongols, then went over to the Song and fought the Yuan under Lü Wende and Jia Sidao, winning victories at Ezhou and Huangzhou. He held the posts of deputy pacification commissioner along the Yangtze, military commissioner of Baokang and prefect of Pingjiang, signatory official of military affairs, acting junior guardian, junior tutor and vice-commissioner of military affairs, and was made Duke of Yue. In the thirteenth year of Zhiyuan he was defeated by Zhang Hongfan at Jiaoshan and lost 80 warships. When Lin’an fell he took his remaining forces to Qingyuan.⁠[7][7][26][10][8]

Zhang Hongfan (1237–1279), courtesy name Zhongchou, was a native of Dingxing (northeast of today’s Xushui county, Hebei), born in Mongolia, the ninth son of Zhang Rou, one of the four great hereditary lords of Hebei. For his part in suppressing the rebellion of Li Tan he became civil administrator of Shuntian circuit in the first year of Zhiyuan (1264); from the sixth year of Zhiyuan he took part in the war against the Song, and after his victory at Jiaoshan in the thirteenth year he was appointed myriarch of Bozhou and the following year Grand General Guarding the State and pacification commissioner of Jiangdong, becoming chief marshal of the Mongol and Han armies in the fifteenth year of Zhiyuan. He was an accomplished poet and left the collection Huaiyang ji.⁠[26]

Wen Tianxiang was born in 1236 (by one account 1230) and at 21 placed first in the imperial examination of 1256; by another account he became a presented scholar in the third year of Baoyou (1255). His writings, among them the Jinian lu and the Zhinan lu, were the main source for the loyalist biographies in the History of Song, and his collected works fill 20 juan.⁠[28][28][28][6][10]

When Lu Xiufu was three his father moved the family to Zhenjiang. Li Tingzhi, commanding in Huainan, heard of him and took him onto his staff; in the tenth year of Xianchun, when Li became military commissioner of eastern Huai, he promoted Lu to consultant. Later Lu went as vice minister of rites to the Yuan front to ask for peace and returned without success. At Fuzhou Chen Yizhong had him impeached and dismissed; Zhang Shijie rebuked Chen, asking what kind of time this was for such things, and Chen, alarmed, hastily recalled Lu to court.⁠[8]

As a young man Zhang Shijie served under Zhang Rou in the garrison at Qi; after committing an offense he fled to the Song and was enrolled among the Huai troops. Ruan Sicong, seeing something unusual in him, recommended him to Lü Wende, and through repeated merit he rose to commander-in-chief of the Wuding armies at Huangzhou and governed Gaoyou commandery and Andong prefecture in turn; he fought at Huangzhou under Jia Sidao and distinguished himself in the relief of Ezhou. At the battle of Jiaoshan he anchored his ships in the river in squares of ten; the Yuan marshal Aju attacked with fire arrows, the Song troops fell into disorder, no one dared weigh anchor, more than ten thousand men died in the river and the Song suffered a great defeat. As the Yuan neared Lin’an he asked that the three palaces be moved out to sea; after the Yuan reached Gaoting Hill he took his troops into Dinghai, and when Shi Guoying sent the commander Bian Biao to persuade him to surrender, Zhang in his fury cut out Bian Biao’s tongue and had him dismembered on Jinzi Hill.⁠[8]

Zhang Hongfan was skilled with the mounted lance and wrote a good deal of verse. Early in the Zhongtong era he was made director of the imperial workshops, in the third year of Zhongtong a field army commander, and he fought against Li Tan at Jinan; as civil administrator of Shuntian circuit he bore a gold tiger tally. By one account the battle of Jiaoshan was fought in Zhiyuan 12.⁠[5]

The Location of Gangzhou

Where Gangzhou, the place where Duanzong died, actually lay is disputed. In the 1950s the Hong Kong scholars Chien Yu-wen, Lo Hsiang-lin and Jao Tsung-i debated the route of the refugee court and its relics in Hong Kong and Kowloon. Chien and Lo followed traditional historians in identifying Gangzhou with Lantau Island (Tai Yu Shan) in Hong Kong; Jao placed it farther west, near Leizhou and Huazhou. Chien and Lo relied chiefly on Chen Zhongwei’s Erwang benmo, which Jao showed to have been heavily edited, while Jao based his case on the writings of Deng Guangjian, the notes of Zhou Mi and the Yuan History. Another researcher finds Jao’s arguments strong and suggests that the other two were not persuaded perhaps because they wished to enhance the region’s cultural history.⁠[10]

Among modern works, some identify Gangzhou as present-day Lantau Island, others as today’s Naozhou Island off Zhanjiang, southeast of the city. One study notes that Gangzhou belonged to Dongguan commandery in Guangdong circuit and comprised 36 islands, known as the thirty-six islets of Daxishan; some scholars hold that the name broadly covered a greater Hong Kong area including Kowloon and the New Territories, the thirty-six islets being the Hong Kong islands from Fat Tong Mun to Kap Shui Mun.⁠[20][1][13][14]

By one account Gangchuan, the Gangzhou where Duanzong died, belonged to Dongguan county in Guangzhou.⁠[21]

Late Song Relics in Hong Kong

Sung Wong Toi, the “Song Emperors’ Terrace,” in the Ma Tau Wai area of today’s Kowloon City in Hong Kong, is Hong Kong’s oldest documented historical monument and the first antiquity in Hong Kong gazetted for preservation, and before the Pacific War it was regarded as the most important Chinese antiquity in the territory. It is linked to Duanzong’s escape through the Kowloon hills from the pursuing Mongols. The inscribed boulder originally stood on a seaside hill known as Sacred Hill; by one account the character for “king” was used in place of the homophone “emperor” so as not to provoke the Yuan. The present inscription was carved in 1807, and earlier carvings had been recorded over the centuries, the first dating from the early Ming. Another view holds that the terrace may originally have been the remains of a lookout post.⁠[32][33][19][10][14]

The site was recognized as historically significant as early as 1899, and appeals to the British authorities saved it from development. In 1941, during the Japanese occupation, the rocks of Sacred Hill were blasted to extend Kai Tak airport, and the inscribed section survived by chance; after the liberation of Hong Kong in 1945 the government built a garden west of the hill and moved the inscribed rock, cut into a rectangle, into it—today’s Sung Wong Toi Garden at the junction of Ma Tau Chung Road and Sung Wong Toi Road. In 1958 the Zhao clan association asked Chien Yu-wen to write a volume on the Song relics of Kowloon and Hong Kong. Legend credits the name Kowloon, “Nine Dragons,” to the eight peaks surrounding the area plus the ninth on which Duanzong sat.⁠[10][33][34]

There are Hou Wong temples at Sha Tsui Tau in Tung Chung on Lantau Island and in Kowloon City, dedicated to Marquis Yang; by one account the marquis was a kinsman of Empress Dowager Yang, whose brother Yang Liangjie is said to have come south with the court, and a bell in the Tung Chung temple inscribed with the thirtieth year of Qianlong suggests the temple was built around 1765. By another view the Hou Wong temple and the tomb of Lady Jin in Kowloon have no real connection with the Song refugee court. Kowloon also has a rock said to have been Empress Dowager Yang’s dressing table and a place called Erwang Dian, the Hall of the Two Kings.⁠[14][10]

Later Commemoration

An early map of the Yamen area appears in the Yashan ji printed in the Hongzhi reign of the Ming. The Ciyuan Temple is the only site with any connection to the court’s temporary palace: originally a Ming shrine to Empress Dowager Yang, it was rebuilt on the same site in the 1980s. Also called the Hall of the Mother of the Nation, it houses the Ciyuan Temple stele written by the Ming scholar Chen Baisha with a brush made of white thatch grass. The Dazhong Shrine holds statues of the three loyalists Lu Xiufu, Zhang Shijie and Wen Tianxiang, and the Yishi Shrine honors the many who resisted the Yuan, eight of them by name.⁠[1][1][31]

Descendants of the imperial family and of the loyalists recorded their connections with the refugee court in genealogies. The genealogy of the Zhao clan of Fushi village in Taishan, compiled in 1685 and revised in 1903, contains an early map. The Zhao clan claims descent from the Song emperors and has branches in Hong Kong, Xinhui, Taishan, Dongguan and the United StatesUnited StatesThe United States is a federal country in North America made up of 50 states, the District of Columbia as the seat of government, and territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam; its capital is Washington, D.C. The Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776. The 2020 census (April 1, 2020) counted a resident population of 331,449,281, and the 435 seats of the House of Representatives are apportioned among the states on the basis of the census.Open the full entry; a genealogy of the Huang family of Taishan records a woman who cured Empress Dowager Yang of an illness, and genealogies of Wen Tianxiang’s descendants and of the Xie family also survive. Kept up to date out of family pride, such genealogies are prone to exaggeration and myth. A tradition preserved in a Zhao clan genealogy holds that Zhao Bing’s body drifted to Chiwan, where birds covered it; an old monk from a temple at the foot of the hill found it and buried it with due rites on the sunny side of the hill, the site of today’s tomb of the young Song emperor at Chiwan in Nanshan district, Shenzhen.⁠[1][10][19]

Some local sites at Yashan rest on folklore rather than evidence, such as the cliff from which Lu Xiufu is supposed to have jumped and the island from which Wen Tianxiang is said to have watched the battle; nevertheless the place is still recognized as historically significant. The Song loyalist Zhao Bixiang would lament the fall of the Song at the sites of the resistance battles and prostrate himself and wail in the direction of Yashan.⁠[10][10]

The Site Today

The ancient battlefield of Yamen lies in today’s Xinhui, Guangdong, where the Song–Yuan Yamen Naval Battle Cultural Scenic Area stands near Yinzhou Lake and the Yamen Bridge at a strategic maritime chokepoint. Its entrance is a ship-shaped gate called the “ancient warship,” with a giant anchor and chain on the lawn, and inside the ship is a hall that re-enacts the naval battle; the area also has a red jade sculpture of the imperial seal 5 meters high and 3 meters on each side, a Nine-Dragon Wall, the Yashan Shrine (Ciyuan Temple), a sleeping palace, the Wangya Tower and a poetry wall of white marble carved with poems by visitors over the centuries, including calligraphy attributed to Tian Han and Mao Zedong. A memorial hall to the battle of Yamen also stands at the site.⁠[1][31][19]

The nearby old Yamen fort is semicircular, with two levels and 43 gun positions; it was built in the Kangxi reign of the Qing and was used against foreign ships and pirates. The boulder bearing Zhang Hongfan’s inscription lies inside a naval base and is closed to visitors.⁠[31]

When the Song Ended, and How It Was Written

The battle of Yashan in 1279 is generally taken as the end of the Southern Song: the Southern Song began in 1127 and lasted 153 years until it was destroyed by Kublai Khan in 1279, when the Yuan completed its conquest and unified China, and the Northern and Southern Song together lasted 18 generations and 320 years, or about 300 years by another count. One researcher regards dating the end of the Song to 1279 as a distortion: edicts of February 1276 had already ordered the empire to submit, the imperial family had been taken north, the Yuan had taken over the Song archives and treasures, and the Yuan emperor had formally ended the Song with sacrifices and thereafter called it the “vanquished Song”; only a few senior officials held that Heaven had not withdrawn its mandate from the Song.⁠[35][35][35][36][36][12][22][10]

Most Ming scholars were dissatisfied with the History of Song, wanted to merge the three dynastic histories, and recognized the two princes as legitimate emperors, and many moved the end of the Song from 1276 to 1279; Wang Zhu went further and denied the legitimacy of the Yuan altogether. In the Qing, Bi Yuan’s chronological history kept 1276 as the end, while Wan Sitong’s Songji zhongyi lu recognized the legitimacy of the two princes and the three years of resistance; most modern works use 1279.⁠[10]

The record of Yashan rests chiefly on eyewitnesses. Deng Guangjian’s Tianhai lu was based on Lu Xiufu’s diary, now lost, and Deng’s family withheld it from the Yuan history office until the History of Song had been completed; Wen Tianxiang’s writings were the main source for the loyalist biographies of the History of Song. The loyalist section of the History of Song contains biographies of 77 loyalists, edited to reflect the official Yuan view.⁠[10]

The detailed account of the two princes that Lu Xiufu wrote at sea was entrusted to Deng Guangjian, vice minister of rites, who took it home to Luling after Yashan fell; after Deng’s death nothing more was known of the manuscript, so that the events at sea could not be known in detail.⁠[8]

Assessments

After Yashan organized resistance ceased and, for the first time, foreign conquerors ruled the whole of China; the Yuan quickly stamped out the remaining resistance. Lu Xiufu’s leap into the sea with the emperor, which closed three centuries of Song rule, has been likened to the end of the Taira clan at the battle of Dan-no-ura. Later accounts placed the entire blame for conceiving and executing the Yashan strategy, which ended in a crushing defeat for the Song, on Zhang Shijie.⁠[2][30][15][10]

The thirteenth of the Ming loyalist Qian Qianyi’s “Later Autumn Meditations” portrays China after Yashan as China no more, and the saying “after Yashan there was no more China” has been widely repeated; some attribute the idea to the Japanese scholar Naito Konan, who saw the fall of the Song as the end of classical Chinese culture.⁠[1]

The appraisal closing the annals of the two princes in the History of Song, compiled under the Yuan, holds that the signs of the Song’s fall had been long in the making and that the succession had passed to a new ruler, so that those who enthroned the two princes could be said not to have understood Heaven’s mandate; yet that ministers loyal to those they served should have come to this was, it concludes, a matter for sorrow.⁠[9]

Sources36 sources

  1. 中國古代海戰史 [A History of Naval Warfare in Ancient China] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)jointpublishing.com↑
  2. Invasion of the Song state (opens in a new window)britannica.com↑
  3. 宋の時代(年表) [The Song period (chronology)] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kotobank.jp↑
  4. 南宋的海權概念與實際 [Sea power concept and it's actual during Southern Song Dynasty] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)airitilibrary.com↑
  5. 元史 卷一百五十六 [History of Yuan, juan 156] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  6. Wen Tianxiang (opens in a new window)chiculture.org.hk↑
  7. 張世傑 [Zhang Shijie] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  8. 宋史 卷四百五十一 [History of Song, juan 451] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  9. 宋史 卷四十七 [History of Song, juan 47] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  10. Loyalist Personalities and Activities in the Sung to Yuan Transition, ca. 1273-1300 (opens in a new window)openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au↑
  11. 文山先生全集 卷十三 [Complete Works of Master Wenshan, juan 13] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  12. 厓山の戦い [Battle of Yashan] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)y-history.net↑
  13. 宋元崖山之戰與宋遺民遷徙海外 [The Song–Yuan Battle of Yashan and the Overseas Migration of Song Loyalists] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)icm.gov.mo↑
  14. 宋元時期|960 ─ 1368 年 [The Song and Yuan Periods, 960–1368] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)jointpublishing.com↑
  15. 陸秀夫 [Lu Xiufu] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  16. 宋史 卷二百四十三 [History of Song, juan 243] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  17. 宋史 卷四百十八 [History of Song, juan 418] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  18. 元史 卷一百二十九 [History of Yuan, juan 129] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  19. 穿越大灣區|珠江西岸 大宋皇朝 最後的庇護之地 [Across the Greater Bay Area: The West Bank of the Pearl River, the Last Refuge of the Song Dynasty] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)stheadline.com↑
  20. 宋末三傑 – 張世傑 [The Three Heroes of the Late Song: Zhang Shijie] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)edb.gov.hk↑
  21. 宋季三朝政要 卷六 [Essentials of Government of the Last Three Song Reigns, juan 6] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  22. 崖山の戦 [Battle of Yashan] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kotobank.jp↑
  23. 文山先生全集 卷十七 [Complete Works of Master Wenshan, juan 17] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  24. 厓山 [Yashan] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  25. 崖山 [Yashan] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  26. 張弘範 [Zhang Hongfan] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  27. 元史 卷十 [History of Yuan, juan 10] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  28. 文天祥 [Wen Tianxiang] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  29. 文山先生全集 卷十四 [Complete Works of Master Wenshan, juan 14] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)raw.githubusercontent.com↑
  30. Song Dynasty falls as Mongols complete conquest of China (opens in a new window)blog.oup.com↑
  31. 旅遊/廣東新會「崖門古戰場」 千秋絕唱 [Travel: The Yamen Ancient Battlefield in Xinhui, Guangdong] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)worldjournal.com↑
  32. Once the oldest known monument in Hong Kong, Sung Wong Toi has survived development plans and Japanese occupiers’ quarrying (opens in a new window)scmp.com↑
  33. Sung Wong Toi Garden, Ma Tau Wai (opens in a new window)hkmemory.hk↑
  34. Sung Wong Toi (opens in a new window)discoverhongkong.com↑
  35. 南宋 [Southern Song] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)kotobank.jp↑
  36. フビライ・ハン [Kublai Khan] (opens in a new window) (in Japanese)kotobank.jp↑