ABAB Pedia

Tianjin Massacre

The Tianjin Massacre occurred on June 21, 1870. Crowds gathered in Tianjin amid rumors about a Catholic orphanage. The French consul, Sisters of Charity, other foreigners and Chinese Christians were killed, and consular and mission buildings burned. The Qing sent Zeng GuofanZeng GuofanZeng Guofan (1811–1872) was an official, military commander and Neo-Confucian scholar of the late Qing dynasty, the founder and commander of the Xiang (Hunan) Army. He led that army against the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom for more than a decade, then governed the Liangjiang provinces and Zhili and helped to begin the self-strengthening projects that brought Western machinery and technology to China.Open the full entry and other officials to investigate, agreed to punishments and compensation and dispatched Chonghou to France.

Contents6 sections
Key facts

The orphanage and the spread of rumors

According to the Wellcome Collection, the Sisters of Charity arrived in Tianjin in 1862 and cared for abandoned and sick children. During a cholera epidemic in 1870 many children died, and some shared coffins. In late May and early June rumors circulated that children were being abducted and their organs used for medicine. In his June 27 dispatch, U.S.United StatesThe United States is a federal country in North America made up of 50 states, the District of Columbia as the seat of government, and territories such as Puerto Rico and Guam; its capital is Washington, D.C. The Continental Congress adopted the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776. The 2020 census (April 1, 2020) counted a resident population of 331,449,281, and the 435 seats of the House of Representatives are apportioned among the states on the basis of the census.Open the full entry minister Frederick Low discussed payments for bringing children to the institution, baptisms of dying children and local suspicion of the institution’s seclusion. He reported that, when questioned in person, one man who had spread the stories admitted that his accusations were unfounded.⁠[1][2]

Attacks on the consulate and mission institutions

Before the attack, Tianjin officials and the French authorities had disputed an inspection of the orphanage. On the afternoon of June 21 the French consul, Henri Fontanier, went to the office of Chonghou, the senior official responsible for trade at the northern ports. Accounts differed over where and at whom the consul fired. In a later dispatch Low acknowledged the difficulty of establishing the precise sequence. Fontanier and his assistant were killed, and crowds attacked and burned the French consulate, the Catholic cathedral and the Sisters of Charity’s establishment. The violence took place in the old city, about two miles from the concession where most foreign residents lived.⁠[1][3]

Casualties and the inquiry

Low’s preliminary report of June 27 counted sixteen French subjects and three Russians among the dead, alongside Chinese Christians whose number he could not determine. He noted that much of his information was secondhand. The Wellcome catalogue gives a later total of twenty-one foreigners killed, including ten Sisters of Charity. The Qing assigned Zeng Guofan, governor-general of Zhili, and other officials to investigate. Ding RichangDing RichangDing Richang (died 1882), a native of Fengshun in Guangdong, governed Jiangsu and Fujian and collected rare books. He helped establish the Jiangnan Arsenal, supported Yung Wing’s plans for overseas education and initiated the construction of telegraph lines in southern Taiwan.Open the full entry assisted with the case.⁠[1][2][4][5]

Sentences and compensation

The Qing removed the prefect Zhang Guangzao and the magistrate Liu Jie and sentenced them to exile in Heilongjiang. Two decrees called for twenty death sentences and twenty-five sentences of penal service or exile. A separate report from the acting French consul, preserved in U.S. diplomatic records, describes sixteen actual executions in one group. The Qing agreed to pay 210,000 taels of silver for losses to mission and consular property and merchants, and another 250,000 taels for victims’ families.⁠[4][6]

Chonghou’s mission and Yung Wing’s educational proposal

The Qing sent Chonghou to France to apologize. After his arrival in 1871, French officials sought to reopen the case and attempted to link presentation of his credentials to further negotiations. He insisted that his temporary mission gave him no authority to renegotiate. The Qing refused to execute the local officials and agreed to erect a memorial at the victims’ cemetery in Tianjin. Eight proposed regulations on missionary activity later drawn up by the Zongli Yamen met foreign opposition and were never implemented. Yung WingYung WingYung Wing (1828–1912) was a Chinese educator and diplomat of the late Qing period who graduated from Yale University in 1854 and is described as the first Chinese student to graduate from an American university. He proposed and led the Chinese Educational Mission, which brought 120 Chinese boys to study in the United States from 1872 to 1881, served as the Qing associate minister to the United States, Spain and Peru, and wrote the memoir My Life in China and America (1909).Open the full entry recalled that the case brought Zeng Guofan and Ding Richang together in Tianjin, providing an occasion to renew his proposal to send boys overseas to study. Zeng headed the ensuing memorial. In 1871 John Thomson photographed the ruined chapel. His wet-collodion glass negative is held by the Wellcome Collection in London.⁠[6][5][2]

Sources6 sources

  1. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1870, document 223: Mr. Low to Mr. Fish (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
  2. Interior ruins of the Chapel of the Sisters of Charity after the Tianjin Massacre (opens in a new window)wellcomecollection.org↑
  3. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1870, document 225: Mr. Low to Mr. Fish (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
  4. Foreign Relations of the United States, 1871, document 33: Dispatch and enclosures on the Tianjin settlement (opens in a new window)history.state.gov↑
  5. My Life in China and America (opens in a new window)gutenberg.org↑
  6. 天津教案与晚清外交 [The Tianjin Massacre and Late Qing Diplomacy] (opens in a new window) (in Chinese)cssn.cn↑